[en] Manual palpation or ultrasonographic examination of the cow's genital tract are currently used by veterinarians involved in reproductive management, but knowledge of the potential and the limitations of both methods is important to obtain an optimal accuracy in the diagnosis of physiological and pathological ovarian structures. This review presents the main features of manual and ultrasonographic characteristics of follicles, corpora lutea (with or without a cavity), follicular and lutenized cysts and the reliability of the two methods is compared. Manual diagnosis of follicles <10 mm is rather inaccurate, but ultrasound offers the possibility to diagnose follicles <5 mm and to measure their inner diameter. The predictive values of the presence or absence of a corpus luteum as determined by palpation are similar (78 vs. 75%). Manual or ultrasonographic diagnosis of the growing or regressing corpus luteum is rather difficult. The positive predictive value of a mature corpus luteum diagnosed by ultrasonography is lower (87%) than the negative predictive value (92%). Compared to manual palpation, ultrasonography permits a better estimation of the number and to determine more precisely the size of the mature corpus luteum. The positive values for follicular cysts diagnosed by palpation or by ultrasonography are 66 and 74% respectively, and for luteal cysts, the values are 66 and 85%, respectively. Manual palpation or ultrasonography are useful tools to diagnose ovarian structures in the cow. The accuracy of such methods can be enhanced by securing information on the reproductive history of the animal, palpation of uterine horns, vaginal examination or progesterone determinations.
Disciplines :
Veterinary medicine & animal health
Author, co-author :
Hanzen, Christian ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département clinique des animaux de production (DCP) > Obstétr. et path. de la reprod. des équidés, rumin. et porcs
Pieterse, M.
Szenci, Otto
Drost, M.
Language :
English
Title :
Relative Accuracy of the Identification of Ovarian Structures in the Cow by Ultrasonography and Palpation Per Rectum
AL-DAHASH S. Y. A., DAVID J. S. E. Histological examination of ovaries and uteri from cows with cystic ovaries. Veterinary Record. 101:1977;342-347.
ARCHBALD L. F., TRAN T., M A. S. S. E. Y R., KLAPSTEIN E. Conception rates in dairy cows after timed insemination and simultaneous treatment with gonadotrophin releasing hormone and/or prostaglandin F2alpha. Theriogenology. 37:1992;723-731.
BELLING T. H. The look and feel of normal bovine ovaries. Veterinary Medicine. 81:1986;455-463.
BIERSCHWAL C. J., GARVERICK H. A., MARTIN C. E., Youngquist R. S., CANTLEY T. C., BROWN M. D. Clinical responses of dairy cows with ovarian cysts to GnRH. Journal of Animal Science. 41:1975;1660-1665.
BOYD H., MUNRO C. D. Progesterone assays and rectal palpation in pre-service management of a dairy herd. Veterinary Record. 104:1979;341-343.
CARROLL D. J., PIERSON R. A., HAUSER E. R., GRUMMER R. R., COMBS D. K. Variability of ovarian structures and plasma progesterone profiles in dairy cows with ovarian cysts. Theriogenology. 34:1990;349-370.
DAWSON F. L. M. Accuracy of rectal palpation in the diagnosis of ovarian function in the cow. Veterinary Record. 96:1975;218-220.
DINSMORE R. P., WHITE M. E., GUARD C. L. Effect of gonadotropin-releasing hormone on clinical response and fertility in cows with cystic ovaries, as related to milk progesterone concentration and days after parturition. Journal of American Veterinary Medical Association. 195:1989;327-330.
DOBSON H., NANDA A. S. Reliability of cysts diagnosis and effect of energy status on LH released by estradiol or GnRH in cows with ovarian cysts. Theriogenology. 37:1992;465-472.
DOBSON H., RANKIN J. E. F., WARD W. R. Bovine cystic ovarian disease: plasma hormone concentrations and treatment. Veterinary Record. 101:1977;459-461.
DONALDSON L. E., HANSEL W. Cystic corpora lutea and normal and cystic Graafian follicles in the cow. Australian Veterinary Journal. 44:1968;304-308.
EDDY R. G. Cloprostenol as a treatment for nonvisible oestrus and cystic disease in dairy cows. Veterinary Record. 100:1977;62-65.
EDMONDSON A. J., FISSORE R. A., PASHEN R. L., BONDURANT R. H. The use of ultrasonography for the study of the bovine reproductive tract. 1. Normal and pathological ovarian structures. Animal Reproduction Science. 12:1986;157-165.
EL-WISHY A. B., GHONEIM I. M. Ovarian function in Buffalo cows with special reference to the accuracy of rectal palpation. Reproduction Domestic Animal. 30:1995;39-41.
FARIN P. W., YOUNGQUIST R. S., PARFET J. R., GARVERICK H. A. Diagnosis of luteal and follicular ovarian cysts by palpation per rectum and linear-array ultrasonography in dairy cows. Journal of American Veterinary Medical Association. 200:1992;1085-1089.
GUAY P., BEDOYA M. A study of the equivalence between rectal palpation, laparoscopy, laparotomy and ovarian dissection for evaluation of the ovarian response of PMSG-superovulated cows. Canadian Veterinary Journal. 22:1981;353-355.
HARDIN D. R. The benefits of palpation before synchronization. Agri-Practice. 5:1984;29-32.
KAHN W., LEIDL W. Diagnosis of ovarian function in the cow by sonography. Tierarztliche Umschau. 41:1986;3-12.
KAHN W., LEIDL W. Ultrasonic characteristics of pathological conditions of the bovine uterus and ovaries. Taverne M. M., Willemse A. H. Diagnostic ultrasound and animal reproduction. 1989;53-65 Kluwer Academic Publisher.
KANEDA Y., DOMEKI I., NAKAHARA T. Effects of removal of cystic fluid from cystic corpus luteum on luteinization and conception rate in dairy heifers. Japanese Journal of Animal Reproduction. 26:1980;37-42.
KASTELIC J. P., PIERSON R. A., GINTHER O. J. Ultrasonic morphology of corpora lutea and central luteal cavities during the estrous cycle and early pregnancy in heifers. Theriogenology. 34:1990a;487-498.
KASTELIC J. P., BERGFELT D. R., GINTHER O. J. Relationship between ultrasonic assessment of the corpus luteum and plasma progesterone concentration in heifers. Theriogenology. 33:1990b;1269-1278.
KELTON D. F., WHITE M. E., HODGES R. J., GUARD C. L., POWERS P. M., DINSMORE R. P., STEHMAN S. M., HILLMAN R. B., YODER S. S. The relationships among palpator experience, milk progesterone concentration and estrus and fertility in cows with palpable corpora lutea treated with cloprostenol. Cornell Veterinarian. 78:1988;105-112.
KELTON D. F., LESLIE K. E., ETHERINGTON W. G., BONNETT B. N., WALTON J. S. Accuracy of rectal palpation and a rapid milk progesterone enzymeimmunassay for determining the presence of a functional corpus luteum in subestrous dairy cows. Canadian Veterinary Journal. 32:1991;286-291.
KESLER D. J., GARVERICK H. A., CAUDLE A. B. Clinical and endocrine responses of dairy cows with ovarian cysts to GnRH and PGF2a. Journal of Animal Science. 46:1978;719-725.
KITO S., OKUDA K., MIYAZAWA K., SATO K. Study of the appearance of the cavity in the corpus luteum of cows by using ultrasonic scanning. Theriogenology. 25:1986;325-333.
KRUIP T. H. A. M., DIELEMAN S. J. Macroscopic classification of bovine follicles and its validation by micromorphological and steroid biochemical procedures. Reproduction Nutrition Development. 22:1982;465-469.
LANDSVERK K., KARLBERG K. Accuracy of rectal palpation in the diagnosis of ovarian function in the cow. Proceedings of 11th International Congress on Animal Reproduction and A.I. 1988;99.
LESLIE K. E., BOSU W. T. K. Plasma progesterone concentrations in dairy cows with cystic ovaries and clinical responses following treatment with fenprostalene. Canadian Veterinary Journal. 24:1983;352-356.
MARION G. B., GIER H. T., CHOUDARY J. B. Micromorphology of the bovine ovarian system. Journal of Animal Science. 27:1968;451-465.
MCENTEE K. Cystic corpora lutea in cattle. International Journal of Fertility. 3:1958;20-128.
MORROW D. A., ROBERTS S. J., MCENTEE K., GRAY H. G. Postpartum ovarian activity and uterine involution in dairy cattle. Journal of American Veterinary Medical Association. 149:1966;1596-1609.
MORTIMER R. G., OLSON J. D., HUFFMAN E. M., FARIN P. W., BALL L., ABBITT B. Serum progesterone concentration in pyometric and normal postpartum dairy cows. Theriogenology. 19:1983;647-653.
NAKAO T., SUGIHASHI A., SAGA N., TSUNODA N., KAWATA K. Use of milk progesterone enzyme immunoassay for differential diagnosis of follicular cyst, luteal cyst and cystic corpus luteum in cows. American Journal of Veterinary Research. 44:1983;888-890.
OMRAN S. N., AYLIFFE T. R., BOYD J. S. Preliminary observations of bovine ovarian structures using B-mode realtime ultrasound. Veterinary Record. 122:1988;465-469.
OTT R. S., BRETZLAFF K. N., HIXON J. E. Comparison of palpable corpora lutea with serum progesterone concentration in cows. Journal of American Veterinary Medical Association. 188:1986;1417-1419.
PATHIRAJA N., OYEDIPE E. O., VOH A. A., DAWUDA P. M. Accuracy of rectal palpation in the diagnosis of corpora lutea in Zebu cows. British Veterinary Journal. 142:1986;467-471.
PIERSON R. A., GINTHER O. J. Ultrasonography of the bovine ovary. Theriogenology. 21:1984a;495-504.
PIERSON R. A., GINTHER O. J. Ultrasonography for the detection of pregnancy and study of embryonic development in heifers. Theriogenology. 22:1984b;225-233.
PIERSON R. A., GINTHER O. J. Reliability of diagnostic ultrasonography for identification and measurement of follicles and detecting the corpus luteum in heifers. Theriogenology. 28:1987;929-936.
PIERSON R. A., GINTHER O. J. Follicular populations during the estrus cycle in heifers. 3. Time of selection of the ovulatory follicle. Animal Reproduction Science. 16:1988a;81-95.
PIERSON R. A., GINTHER O. J. Ultrasonic imaging of the ovaries and uterus in cattle. Theriogenology. 29:1988b.
PIETERSE M. C. Ultrasonic characteristics of physiological structures on bovine ovaries. Taverne M. M., Willemse A. H. Diagnostic Ultrasound and Animal Reproduction. 1989;53-65 Kluwer Academic Publisher.
PIETERSE M. C., KAPPEN K. A., KRUIP Th. A.M., TAVERNE M. A. M. Aspiration of bovine oocytes during transvaginal ultrasound scanning of the ovaries. Theriogenology. 30:1988;751-762.
PIETERSE M. C., TAVERNE M. A. M., KRUIP Th. A.M., WILLEMSE A. H. Detection of corpora lutea and follicles in cows: a comparison of transvaginal ultrasonography and rectal palpation. Veterinary Record. 126:1990;552-554.
QUIRK S. M., HICHEY G. J., FORTUNE J. E. Growth and regression of ovarian follicles during the follicular phase of the oestrous cycle in heifers undergoing spontaneous and PGF 2a induced luteolysis. Journal of Reproduction and Fertility. 77:1986;211-219.
RAJAMAHENDRAN R., TAYLOR C. Characterization of ovarian activity in postpartum dairy cows using ultrasound imaging and progesterone profiles. Animal Reproduction Science. 22:1990;171-180.
RIBADU A. Y., WARD W. R., DOBSON H. Comparative evaluation of ovarian structures in cattle by palpation per rectum, ultrasonography and plasma progesterone concentration. Veterinary Record. 135:1994;452-457.
ROBERTS, S. J. 1986, Veterinary Obstetrics and Genital Disease, NY, lthaca.
SEGUIN B. E. Ovarian cysts in dairy cows. Morow D. A. Current Therapy in Theriogenology. 1980;199-204 WB Saunders, Philadelphia.
SHEMESH M., LINDNER H. R., AYALON N. Competitive protein-binding assay of progesterone in bovine jugular venous plasma during the oestrous cycle. Journal of Reproduction and Fertility. 26:1971;167-179.
SIROIS J., FORTUNE J. E. Ovarian follicular dynamics during the oestrous cycle in heifers monitored by real-time ultrasonography. Biology of Reproduction. 39:1988;308-317.
SMITH R. D. Evaluation of diagnostic tests. Veterinary Clinical Epidemiology. A problem-oriented approach. 1991;29-43.
SPRECHER D. J., NEBEL R. L., WHITTIER W. D. Predictive value of palpation per rectum vs milk and serum progesterone levels for the diagnosis of bovine follicular cysts and luteal cysts. Theriogenology. 30:1988;701-709.
SPRECHER D. J., NEBEL R. L., WHITMAN S. S. The predictive value, sensitivity and specificity of palpation per rectum and transrectal ultrasonography for the determination of bovine luteal status. Theriogenology. 31:1989;1165-1172.
STABENFELDT G. H., EWING L. L., MCDONALD L. E. Peripheral plasma progesterone levels during the bovine oestrous cycle. Journal of Reproduction and Fertility. 19:1969;433-442.
STUDER E. Palpation of the genital tract for prediction of estrus in the cow. Veterinary Medicine/Small Animal Clinician. 1975;1337-1341.
THATCHER W. W., de la SOTA R. L., SCHMITT E. P.-J., DIAZ T. C., BADINGA L., SIMMEN F. A., STAPLES C. R., DROST M. Control and management of ovarian follicles in cattle to optimize fertility. Reproduction Fertility and Development. 8:1996;203-217.
WATSON E. D., MUNRO C. D. A re-assessment of the technique of rectal palpation of corpora lutea in cows. British Veterinary Journal. 136:1980;555-560.
ZEMJANIS R. Diagnostic and Therapeutic Techniques in Animal Reproduction, 2nd Edition. 1970;Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore. p. 57.
