[en] Heart rate variability (HRV) is a non-invasive measurement of the balance between the sympathetic and parasympathetic innervation to the myocardium. Used as an indicator of health, welfare and fitness level, its measurement during exercise has been suggested to be helpful in sport horses. The aims of this study were to assess the within- and between-day repeatability of time-domain HRV-measurements during exercise, and to evaluate the effect of gait (as a factor of increasing exercise intensity) on HRV. Heart rate (HR), root mean square of successive differences (RMSSD) between normal heartbeats and the standard deviation of normal (R-R) intervals (SDNN) were assessed during a standardised exercise test (SET) on five consecutive days in a sample of 21 healthy Warmblood dressage horses. All variables showed good between-day repeatability (Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient), while only RMSSD showed reliable within-day repeatability (Wilcoxon signed-rank test). Increase of exercise intensity was significantly associated with increased HR and decreased RMSSD and SDNN, with a negative correlation between HR and the two HRV-measurements. HR and HRV values varied significantly with intensity of exercise (rest, walk, trot, canter and whole SET), though HRV at rest was not different to that at walk, and HRV at trot was not different to that at canter. In conclusion, the results of this study support the use and show the repeatability of time-domain HRV-measurements during exercise in Warmblood dressage horses. Further investigation for use of HRV in other equestrian disciplines, levels and health state is warranted.
Disciplines :
Veterinary medicine & animal health
Author, co-author :
Frippiat, Thibault ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Fundamental and Applied Research for Animals and Health (FARAH) ; Sportpaardenarts – Equine Sports Medicine, P.O. Box 170, 1250 AD Laren, The Netherlands
van Beckhoven, C.; Heart for Horses, Duifhuisweg 19, 5061 KZ Oisterwijk, The Netherlands
van Gasselt, V.J.; Vincent van Gasselt Dressage, P.O. Box 170, 1250 AD Laren, The Netherlands
Dugdale, A. ; Paragon Veterinary Referrals, Paragon Business Village, 1 Red Hall Crescent, Wakefield, WF1 2DF, United Kingdom
Vandeweerd, J.M. ; Integrated Veterinary Research Unit (IVRU) – Namur Research Institute for Life Sciences (NARILIS), Department of Veterinary Medicine, Faculty of Sciences, University of Namur, Rue de Bruxelles 61, 5000 Namur, Belgium
Language :
English
Title :
Effect of gait on, and repeatability of heart rate and heart rate variability measurements in exercising Warmblood dressage horses
Bellenger, C.R., Fuller, J.T., Thomson, R.L., Davison, K., Robertson, E.Y. and Buckley, J.D., 2016. Monitoring athletic training status through autonomic heart rate regulation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine 46: 1461-1486.
Broux, B., De Clercq, D., Decloedt, A., Ven, S., Vera, L., Van Steenkiste, G., Mitchell, K., Schwarzwald, C. and Van Loon, G., 2017. Heart rate variability parameters in horses distinguish atrial fibrillation from sinus rhythm before and after successful electrical cardioversion. Equine Veterinary Journal 49: 723-728.
Broux, B., De Clercq, D., Vera, L., Ven, S., Deprez, P., Decloedt, A. and Van Loon, G., 2018. Can heart rate variability parameters derived by a heart rate monitor differentiate between atrial fibrillation and sinus rhythm?. BMC Veterinary Research 14: 320.
Casties, J.F., Mottet, D. and Le Gallais, D., 2006. Non-linear analyses of heart rate variability during heavy exercise and recovery in cyclists. International Journal of Sports Medicine 27: 780-785.
Chalmers, T., Hickey, B.A., Newton, P., Lin, C.-T., Sibbritt, D., McLachlan, C.S., Clifton-Bligh, R., Morley, J. and Lal, S., 2021. Stress watch: the use of heart rate and heart rate variability to detect stress: a pilot study using smart watch wearables. Sensors 22: 151.
Contreras-Aguilar, M.D., Cerón, J.J., Muñoz, A. and Ayala, I., 2021. Changes in saliva biomarkers during a standardized increasing intensity field exercise test in endurance horses. Animal 15: 100236.
Cottin, F., Barrey, E., Lopes, P. and Billat, V., 2006. Effect of repeated exercise and recovery on heart rate variability in elite trotting horses during high intensity interval training. Equine Veterinary Journal 38: 204-209.
Cottin, F., Médigue, C., Lopes, P., Petit, E., Papelier, Y. and Billat, V.L., 2005. Effect of exercise intensity and repetition on heart rate variability during training in elite trotting horse. International Journal of Sports Medicine 26: 859-867.
D’Agosto, T., Peçanha, T., Bartels, R., Moreira, D.N., Silva, L.P., Nóbrega, A.C.L. and Lima, J.R.P., 2014. Cardiac autonomic responses at onset of exercise: effects of aerobic fitness. International Journal of Sports Medicine 35: 879-885.
De Oliveira, G.L., Marques, A.H., da Fonseca, V.F., Pozzolo, B.A., Panacioni, F., Santos, T.C., Guedes, A.A., Mocelin, A.G., Bertin, R.L. and Ulbrich, A.Z., 2020. Handrail support interference in cardiac autonomic modulation adjustments in young adults during maximal exercise testing. Scientific Reports 10: 11196.
Eggensperger, B.H. and Schwarzwald, C.C., 2017. Influence of 2nd-degree AV blocks, ECG recording length, and recording time on heart rate variability analyses in horses. Journal of Veterinary Cardiology 19: 160-174.
Fisher, J.P., Ogoh, S., Junor, C., Khaja, A., Northrup, M. and Fadel, P.J., 2009. Spontaneous baroreflex measures are unable to detect age-related impairments in cardiac baroreflex function during dynamic exercise in humans. Experimental Physiology 94: 447-458.
Fraipont, A., Van Erck, E., Ramery, E., Richard, E., Denoix, J.M., Lekeux, P. and Art, T., 2011. Subclinical diseases underlying poor performance in endurance horses: diagnostic methods and predictive tests. Veterinary Record 169: 154.
Frick, L., Schwarzwald, C.C. and Mitchell, K.J., 2019. The use of heart rate variability analysis to detect arrhythmias in horses undergoing a standard treadmill exercise test. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 33: 212-224.
Frippiat, T., Van Beckhoven, C., Moyse, E. and Art, T., 2021. Accuracy of a heart rate monitor for calculating heart rate variability parameters in exercising horses. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 104: 103716.
Garcia-Tabar, I., Sánchez-Medina, L., Aramendi, J.F., Ruesta, M., Ibañez, J. and Gorostiaga, E.M., 2013. Heart rate variability thresholds predict lactate thresholds in professional world-class road cyclists. Journal of Exercise Physiology Online 16: 38-50.
Gehlen, H., Faust, M.D., Grzeskowiak, R.M. and Trachsel, D.S., 2020. Association between disease severity, heart rate variability (HRV) and serum cortisol concentrations in horses with acute abdominal pain. Animals 10: 1-14.
Gordan, R., Gwathmey, J.K. and Xie, L.-H., 2015. Autonomic and endocrine control of cardiovascular function. World Journal of Cardiology 7: 204.
Gramkow, H.L. and Evans, D.L., 2006. Correlation of race earnings with velocity at maximal heart rate during a field exercise test in Thoroughbred racehorses. Equine Veterinary Journal 38: 118-122.
Hargens, T.A., Chambers, S., Luden, N.D. and Womack, C.J., 2022. Reliability of the heart rate variability threshold during treadmill exercise. Clinical physiology and functional imaging 42: 292-299.
Heponiemi, T., Elovainio, M., Pulkki, L., Puttonen, S., Raitakari, O. and Keltikangas-Järvinen, L., 2007. Cardiac autonomic reactivity and recovery in predicting carotid atherosclerosis: the cardiovascular risk in young finns study. Health Psychology 26: 13-21.
Houben, R.M.A.C., Vernooij, H.J.C.M. and Sloet van Oldruitenborgh-Oosterbaan, M.M., 2021. Effect of recording length and posture on the reliability of heart rate variability in horses. Pferdeheilkunde 37: 577-827.
Hunt, K.J. and Saengsuwan, J., 2018. Changes in heart rate variability with respect to exercise intensity and time during treadmill running. BioMedical Engineering Online 17: 128. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12938-018-0561-x
Janczarek, I., Wilk, I., Kędzierski, W., Stachurska, A. and Kowalik, S., 2017. Offtrack training ameliorates emotional excitability in purebred Arabian racehorses. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 97: 42-50.
Kapteijn, C.M., Frippiat, T., van Beckhoven, C., van Lith, H.A., Endenburg, N., Vermetten, E. and Rodenburg, T.B., 2022. Measuring heart rate variability using a heart rate monitor in horses (Equus caballus) during groundwork. Frontiers in Veterinary Science 9: 939534. https://doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2022.939534
Karapetian, G.K., Engels, H.J., Gretebeck, K.A. and Gretebeck, R.J., 2012. Effect of caffeine on LT, VT and HRVT. International Journal of Sports Medicine 33: 507-513.
Karapetian, G.K., Engels, H.J. and Gretebeck, R.J., 2008. Use of heart rate variability to estimate LT and VT. International Journal of Sports Medicine 29: 652-657.
Khan, A.A., Junejo, R.T., Thomas, G.N., Fisher, J.P. and Lip, G.Y.H., 2021. Heart rate variability in patients with atrial fibrillation and hypertension. European Journal of Clinical Investigation 51: e13361.
Kim, S.H., Lim, K.R., Seo, J.-H., Ryu, D.R., Lee, B.-K., Cho, B.-R. and Chun, K.J., 2022. Higher heart rate variability as a predictor of atrial fibrillation in patients with hypertension. Scientific Reports 12: 3702.
Kinnunen, S., Laukkanen, R., Haldi, J., Hanninen, O. and Atalay, M., 2006. Heart rate variability in trotters during different training periods. Equine Veterinary Journal Suppl. 36: 214-217.
Koo, T.K. and Li, M.Y., 2016. A guideline of selecting and reporting intraclass correlation coefficients for reliability research. Journal of Chiropractic Medicine 15: 155-163.
Kuwahara, M., Hiraga, A., Kai, M., Tsubone, H. and Sugano, S., 2010. Influence of training on autonomic nervous function in horses: evaluation by power spectral analysis of heart rate variability. Equine Veterinary Journal 31: 178-180.
Lenoir, A., Trachsel, D.S., Younes, M., Barrey, E. and Robert, C., 2017. Agreement between electrocardiogram and heart rate meter is low for the measurement of heart rate variability during exercise in young endurance horses. Frontiers in Veterinary Science 4: 170.
Littlejohn, A., Kruger, J.M. and Bowles, F., 1977. Exercise studies in horses: 2. The cardiac response to exercise in normal horses and in horses with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Equine Veterinary Journal 9: 75-83.
Lorello, O., Ramseyer, A., Burger, D., Gerber, V., Bruckmaier, R.M., Van der Kolk, J.H. and Navas de Solis, C., 2017. Repeated measurements of markers of autonomic tone over a training season in eventing horses. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 53: 38-44.
Manresa-Rocamora, A., Flatt, A.A., Casanova-Lizón, A., Ballester-Ferrer, J.A., Sarabia, J.M., Vera-Garcia, F.J. and Moya-Ramón, M., 2021. Heart rate-based indices to detect parasympathetic hyperactivity in functionally overreached athletes. A meta-analysis. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports 31: 1164-1182.
McConachie, E.L., Giguère, S., Rapoport, G. and Barton, M.H., 2016. Heart rate variability in horses with acute gastrointestinal disease requiring exploratory laparotomy. Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care 26: 269-280.
McCrae, P., Spong, H., Golestani, N., Mahnam, A., Bashura, Y. and Pearson, W., 2023. Validation of an equine smart textile system for heart rate variability: a preliminary study. Animals 13: 512.
McDuffee, L., Carr, L. and Montelpare, W., 2022. An observational evaluation of stress in horses during therapeutic riding sessions. Journal of Veterinary Behavior 49: 53-64.
McDuffee, L., Mills, M., McNiven, M. and Montelpare, W., 2019. Establishing statistical stability for heart rate variability in horses. Journal of Veterinary Behavior 32: 30-35.
Moreno, I.L., Pastre, C.M., Ferreira, C., de Abreu, L.C., Valenti, V.E. and Vanderlei, L.C.M., 2013. Effects of an isotonic beverage on autonomic regulation during and after exercise. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 10: 2.
Norman, S.E., Eager, R.A., Waran, N.K., Jeffery, L., Schroter, R.C. and Marlin, D.J., 2005. Recording of ECG signals on a portable MiniDisc recorder for time and frequency domain heart rate variability analysis. Physiology and Behavior 83: 729-738.
Nyerges-Bohák, Z., Nagy, K., Rózsa, L., Póti, P. and Kovács, L., 2021. Heart rate variability before and after 14 weeks of training in Thoroughbred horses and Standardbred trotters with different training experience. PLoS ONE 16: e0259933.
Ohmura, H., Hobo, S., Hiraga, A. and Jones, J.H., 2012. Changes in heart rate and heart rate variability during transportation of horses by road and air. American Journal of Veterinary Research 73: 515-521.
Parker, M., Goodwin, D., Eager, R.A., Redhead, E.S. and Marlin, D.J., 2009. Comparison of Polar® heart rate interval data with simultaneously recorded ECG signals in horses. Comparative Exercise Physiology 6: 137-142.
Ramos-Campo, D.J., Rubio-Arias, J.A., Ávila-Gandía, V., Marín-Pagán, C., Luque, A. and Alcaraz, P.E., 2017. Heart rate variability to assess ventilatory thresholds in professional basketball players. Journal of Sport and Health Science 6: 468-473.
Rosselot, P., Mendonça, T., González, I. and Tadich, T., 2019. Behavioral and physiological differences between working horses and Chilean rodeo horses in a handling test. Animals 9: 397.
Shiraishi, Y., Katsumata, Y., Sadahiro, T., Azuma, K., Akita, K., Isobe, S., Yashima, F., Miyamoto, K., Nishiyama, T., Tamura, Y., Kimura, T., Nishiyama, N., Aizawa, Y., Fukuda, K. and Takatsuki, S., 2018. Real-time analysis of the heart rate variability during incremental exercise for the detection of the ventilatory threshold. Journal of the American Heart Association 7: e006612.
Sloan, R.P., Shapiro, P.A., Lauriola, V., McIntyre, K., Pavlicova, M., Choi, C.W.J., Choo, T.H. and Scodes, J.M., 2021. The impact of aerobic training on cardiovascular reactivity to and recovery from psychological and orthostatic challenge. Psychosomatic Medicine 83: 125-137.
Tomczak, M. and Tomczak, E., 2014. The need to report effect size estimates revisited. An overview of some recommended measures of effect size. Trends in Sport Sciences 1: 19-25.
Tulppo, M.P., Makikallio, T.H., Takala, T.E.S., Seppanen, T. and Huikuri, H.V., 1996. Quantitative beat-to-beat analysis of heart rate dynamics during exercise. American Journal of Physiology – Heart and Circulatory Physiology 271: H244-H252.
Van Erck-Westergren, E., 2014. Value of field trials to investigate poor performance in sport horses. Equine Veterinary Journal 46: 14.
Van Vollenhoven, E., Fletcher, L., Page, P.C., Ganswindt, A. and Grant, C.C., 2017. Heart rate variability in healthy, adult pony mares during transrectal palpation of the reproductive tract by veterinary students. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 58: 68-77.
Van Vollenhoven, E., Grant, C.C., Fletcher, L., Ganswindt, A. and Page, P.C., 2016. Repeatability and reliability of heart rate variability in healthy, adult pony mares. Journal of Equine Veterinary Science 46: 73-81.
Vasconcellos, F., Seabra, A., Montenegro, R., Cunha, F., Bouskela, E. and Farinatti, P., 2015. Can heart rate variability be used to estimate gas exchange threshold in obese adolescents?. International Journal of Sports Medicine 36: 654-660.
Vermeulen, A.D. and Evans, D.L., 2006. Measurements of fitness in Thoroughbred racehorses using field studies of heart rate and velocity with a global positioning system. Equine Veterinary Journal 38: 113-117.
Vitale, V., Balocchi, R., Varanini, M., Sgorbini, M., Macerata, A., Sighieri, C. and Baragli, P., 2013. The effects of restriction of movement on the reliability of heart rate variability measurements in the horse (Equus caballus). Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research 8: 400-403.
Vitale, V., Conte, G., Baragli, P., Jose-Cunilleras, E. and Sgorbini, M., 2021. Heart rate variability in newborn foals and its association with illness: a pilot study. Italian Journal of Animal Science 20: 1829-1836.
Vitale, V., Viu, J., Armengou, L., Ríos, J. and Jose-Cunilleras, E., 2020. Prognostic value of measuring heart rate variability at the time of hospital admission in horses with colic. American Journal of Veterinary Research 81: 147-152.
Voss, B., Mohr, E. and Krzywanek, H., 2002. Effects of aqua-treadmill exercise on selected blood parameters and on heart-rate variability of horses. Journal of Veterinary Medicine Series A: Physiology Pathology Clinical Medicine 49: 137-143.
Williams, R.J. and Chandler, R.E., 2009. Heart rates of horses during competitive dressage. Comparative Exercise Physiology 6: 7-15.
Younes, M., Robert, C., Barrey, E. and Cottin, F., 2016. Effects of age, exercise duration, and test conditions on heart rate variability in young endurance horses. Frontiers in Physiology 7: 155.
