Antigenic Diversity of Bovine Viral Diarrhoea Viral Isolates Contradicts the Concept of Herd Specific Strain

In the epidemiology of bovine viral diarrhoea (BVD), immunotolerant - persistently infected animals (IPI) appear to be major sources of contamination. These animals produce large quantities of replicating virus and have therefore been proposed as being responsible for generating antigenic variability. However, limited studies have failed to detect antigenic or genetic changes in viruses isolated at different times from IPI. An hypothesis is that the immunotolerance of IPI against their homologous strain is accompanied by immune elimination of antigenic variants. The presence of an IPI in a herd could therefore limit antigenic variation, eventually leading to the existence of herd specific strains. To verify this hypothesis we characterized, against a panel of monoclonal antibodies, 37 BVD virus strains isolated from IPI of 12 herds in Eastern Belgium. Intra-herd antigenic variation was compared to inter-herd variation. Antigenic variation within herds was found to be surprisingly high but, nevertheless, significantly lower than variation between herds.