[en] The implementation of regular and relevant evaluations of surveillance systems is critical in improving their effectiveness and their relevance whilst limiting their cost. The complex nature of these systems and the variable contexts in which they are implemented call for the development of flexible evaluation tools. Within this scope, participatory tools have been developed and implemented for the African swine fever (ASF) surveillance system in Corsica (France). The objectives of this pilot study were, firstly, to assess the applicability of participatory approaches within a developed environment involving various stakeholders and, secondly, to define and test methods developed to assess evaluation attributes. Two evaluation attributes were targeted: the acceptability of the surveillance system and its the non-monetary benefits. Individual semi-structured interviews and focus groups were implemented with representatives from every level of the system. Diagramming and scoring tools were used to assess the different elements that compose the definition of acceptability. A contingent valuation method, associated with proportional piling, was used to assess the non-monetary benefits, i.e., the value of sanitary information. Sixteen stakeholders were involved in the process, through 3 focus groups and 8 individual semi-structured interviews. Stakeholders were selected according to their role in the system and to their availability. Results highlighted a moderate acceptability of the system for farmers and hunters and a high acceptability for other representatives (e.g., private veterinarians, local laboratories). Out of the 5 farmers involved in assessing the non-monetary benefits, 3 were interested in sanitary information on ASF. The data collected via participatory approaches enable relevant recommendations to be made, based on the Corsican context, to improve the current surveillance system.
Disciplines :
Médecine vétérinaire & santé animale
Auteur, co-auteur :
Calba, Clémentine
Antoine-Moussiaux, Nicolas ; Université de Liège > Département de productions animales > Biostatistique, économie, sélection animale
Charrier, François; Institut Scientifique de Recherche Agronomique - INRA
Hendrikx, Pascal; ANSES, France
Saegerman, Claude ; Université de Liège > Département des maladies infectieuses et parasitaires (DMI) > Epidémiologie et analyse des risques appl. aux sc. vétér.
Peyre, Marisa; CIRAD, France
Goutard, Flavie; CIRAD, France
Langue du document :
Anglais
Titre :
Applying participatory approaches in the evaluation of surveillance systems: A pilot study on African swine fever surveillance in Corsica.
Auer A.M., Dobmeier T.M., Haglund B.J., Tillgren P. The relevance of WHO injury surveillance guidelines for evaluation: learning from the Aboriginal Community-Centered Injury Surveillance System (ACCISS) and two institution-based systems. BMC Public Health 2011, 11:744.
Bradley J.E., Mayfield M.V., Mehta M.P., Rukonge A. Participatory evaluation of reproductive health care quality in developing countries. Soc. Sci. Med. 2002, 55:269-282.
Bronner A., Hénaux V., Fortané N., Hendrikx P., Calavas D. Why do farmers and veterinarians not report all bovine abortions, as requested by the clinical brucellosis surveillance system in France?. BMC Vet. Res. 2014, 10:93.
Calba C., Goutard F.L., Hoinville L., Hendrikx P., Lindberg A., Saegerman C., Peyre M. Surveillance systems evaluation: a systematic review of the existing approaches. BMC Public Health 2015, 15:448.
Calba C., Ponsich A., Nam S., Collineau L., Min S., Thonnat J., Goutard F.L. Development of a participatory tool for the evaluation of village animal health workers in Cambodia. Acta Trop. 2014, 134:17-28.
Casabianca F., Picard P., Sapin J., Gauthier J., Vallée M. Contribution à l'épidémiologie des maladies virales en élevage porcin extensif. Application à la lutte contre le maladie d'Aujeszky en Région Corse. Journées Recherches Porcines France 1989, 21:153-160.
Catley A., Admassu B. Using participatory epidemiology to assess the impact of livestock diseases. FAO-OIE-AU/IBAR-IAEA Consultative Group Meeting on Contagious Bovine Pleuropneumonia in Africa, 12-14 November 2003 2003.
Catley A., Alders R.G., Wood J.L. Participatory epidemiology: approaches, methods, experiences. Vet. J. 2012, 191:151-160.
Corbin J.M., Strauss A. Grounded theory research: procedures, canons, and evaluative criteria. Qual. Sociol. 1990, 13:3-21.
Costard S., Mur L., Lubroth J., Sanchez-Vizcaino J., Pfeiffer D. Epidemiology of African swine fever virus. Virus Res. 2013, 173:191-197.
Côte L., Turgeon J. Comment lire de façon critique les articles de recherche qualitative en médecine. Pédag. Méd. 2002, 3:81-90.
Delabouglise A., Antoine-Moussiaux N., Phan T., Dao D., Nguyen T., Truong B., Nguyen X., Vu T., Nguyen K., Le H., Salem G. The perceived value of passive animal health surveillance: the case of highly pathogenic avian influenza in Vietnam. Zoonoses Public Health 2015, 10.1111/zph.12212.
Desvaux S., Le Potier M.F., Bourry O., Hutet E., Rose N., Anjoubault G., Havet P., Clément T., Marcé C. Peste porcine africaine: étude sérologique dans les abattoirs en Corse durant l'hiver 2014. Bull. Epidémiol. 2014, 63:19.
Dozois E., Blanchet-Cohen N., Langlois M. DE 201: A Practitioner's Guide to Developmental Evaluation 2010, The J.W. McConnell Family Foundation and the International Institute for Child Rights and Development. http://www.mcconnellfoundation.ca/en/resources/publication/de-201-a-practitioner-s-guide-to-developmental-evaluation.
Drewe J., Hoinville L., Cook A., Floyd T., Gunn G., Stärk K. SERVAL: a new framework for the evaluation of animal health surveillance. Transbound. Emerg. Dis. 2015, 62:33-45.
Drewe J., Hoinville L., Cook A., Floyd T., Stärk K. Evaluation of animal and public health surveillance systems: a systematic review. Epidemiol. Infect. 2012, 140:575-590.
European Commission, 2011. Commission Implementing Decision of 15 December 2011 amending Decision 2005/363/ EC concerning animal health protection measures against African swine fever in Sardinia, Italy. (accessed 29.04.15.). http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/%3Furi=CELEX.32007D0012&from=EN.
German R.R., Lee L., Horan J., Milstein R., Pertowski C., Waller M. Updated guidelines for evaluating public health surveillance systems. MMWR recommendations and reports. Cent. Dis. Control Prev. 2001, 50:1-35.
Glaser B., Strauss A. The Discovery of Grounded Theory. Strategies for Qualitative Research 1967, 271. Transaction Publishers, Hawthorne, New-York.
Guest G., Bunce A., Johnson L. How many interviews are enough? An experiment with data saturation and variability. Field Methods 2006, 18:59-582.
Hendrickx S., El Masry I., Atef M., Aref N., El Zahraa Kotb F., El Shabacy R., Jobre Y. A Manual for Practitioners in Community-based Animal Health Outreach (caho) for Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza 2011, 77. The International Livestock Research Institute and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
Hendrikx P., Gay E., Chazel M., Moutou F., Danan C., Richomme C., Boue F., Souillard R., Gauchard F., Dufour B. OASIS: an assessment tool of epidemiological surveillance systems in animal health and food safety. Epidemiol. Infect. 2011, 139:1486-1496.
Hoinville L., Alban L., Drewe J., Gibbens J., Gustafson L., Häsler B., Saegerman C., Salman M., Stärk K. Proposed terms and concepts for describing and evaluating animal-health surveillance systems. Prev. Vet. Med. 2013, 112:1-12.
Hoischen-Taubner S., Bielecke A., Sundrum A., 2014. Different perspectives on animal health and implications for communication between stakeholders. In: Schobert Heike, Riecher Maja-Catrin, Fischer Holger, Aenis Thomas, Knierim Andrea (Eds.) Farming Systems Facing Global Challenges: Capacities and Strategies, 8-16.
Johnson N., Lilja N., Ashby J.A., Garcia J.A. The practice of participatory research and gender analysis in natural resource management. Nat. Res. Forum 2004, 28:189-200.
Kariuki J., Njuki J. Using participatory impact diagrams to evaluate a community development project in Kenya. Dev. Pract. 2013, 23:90-106.
Louviere J.J., Hensher D.A., Swait J.D. Environmental valuation case studies. Stated Choice Methods: Analysis and Applications 2003, 329-353. Cambridge University Press.
Mariner J., Hendrickx S., Pfeiffer D., Costard S., Knopf L., Okuthe S., Chibeu D., Parmley J., Musenero M., Pisang C. Integration of participatory approaches into surveillance systems. Rev. Sci. Technol. 2011, 30:653-659.
Moennig V. Introduction to classical swine fever: virus, disease and control policy. Vet. Microbiol. 2000, 73:93-102.
Mur L., Atzeni M., Martínez-López B., Feliziani F., Rolesu S., Sanchez-Vizcaino J. Thirty-five-year presence of African swine fever in Sardinia: history, evolution and risk factors for disease maintenance. Transbound. Emerg. Dis. 2014, 10.1111/tbed.12264.
Mur L., Martínez-López B., Costard S., de la Torre A., Jones B.A., Martínez M., Sánchez-Vizcaíno F., Muñoz M.J., Pfeiffer D.U., Sánchez-Vizcaíno J.M. Modular framework to assess the risk of African swine fever virus entry into the European Union. BMC Vet. Res. 2014, 10:145.
Nitsch M., Waldherr K., Denk E., Griebler U., Marent B., Forster R. Participation by different stakeholders in participatory evaluation of health promotion: a literature review. Eval. Progr. Plan. 2013, 40:42-54.
Pahl-Wostl C. Participative and stakeholder-based policy design, evaluation and modeling processes. Integr. Assess. 2002, 3:3-14.
Peyre M., Hoinville L., Haesler B., Lindberg A., Bisdorff B., Dorea F., Wahlström H., Frössling J., Calba C., Grosbois V., Goutard F. Network analysis of surveillance system evaluation attributes: a way towards improvement of the evaluation process. International Conference on Animal Health Surveillance (ICAHS) 2014.
Pretty J.N. Participatory learning for sustainable agriculture. World Dev. 1995, 23:1247-1263.
Pretty J.N., Guijt I., Thompson J., Scoones I. Participatory Learning and Action: A Trainer's Guide 1995, 267. International Institute for Environment and Development.
Rice M., Franceschini M.C. The participatory evaluation of healthy municipalities, cities and communities initiatives in the Americas. Health Promotion Evaluation Practices in the Americas 2009, 221-236. Springer.
Sawford K.E. Animal Health Surveillance for Early Detection of Emerging Infectious Disease Risks. Phd Thesis. Department of Medical Science 2011, 247. University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta.
Shaik S., Barnett B.J., Coble K.H., Miller J.C., Hanson T. Insurability conditions and livestock disease insurance. The Economics of Livestock Disease Insurance: Concepts, Issues and International Case Studies 2006, 53-67. CABI Publishing. S.R. Koontz, D.L. Hoag, D.D.G. Thilmany, J.W.J.L. Grannis (Eds.).
Torre A.D.L., Bosch J., Iglesias I., Muñoz M., Mur L., Martínez-López B., Martínez M., Sánchez-Vizcaíno J. Assessing the risk of African swine fever introduction into the European Union by wild boar. Transbound. Emerg. Dis. 2013, 62(3):272-279.
Tsai P., Scott K.A., Pappaioanou M., Gonzalez M.C., Keusch G.T. Sustaining Global Surveillance and Response to Emerging Zoonotic Diseases 2009, National Academies Press.
