[en] 1. Due to intensive selection, broiler chickens became the most efficient meat-producing animals because of their fast growth, supported by a virtually unlimited voluntary feed intake. These characteristics cause many problems in the management of broiler breeder hens because of the negative correlation between muscle growth and reproduction effectiveness. 2. This problem, namely the fast muscle growth versus reproduction health paradox, induces a second paradox, acceptable reproduction and health versus hunger stress and impaired welfare, because broiler breeder hens require dedicated programmes of feed restriction (1) to maximise egg and chick production and (2) to avoid metabolic disorders and mortality in broiler breeders. 3. Given that poultry selection is a global large-scale business and chickens are a prolific species, improvement in profit can only be obtained by selecting on feed conversion and/or for higher breast meat percentage, which will intensify the broiler-breeder paradox. 4. New feeding strategies are being studied, but it is questionable if the paradox can be solved by management tools alone. Because breeding and selection are long-term processes, involving animals, farmers, consumers, industry, environment etc., a more sustainable breeding goal needs to be determined by a multidisciplinary approach and an open debate between several actors in the discussion. 5. Using dwarf broiler breeder hens could be one alternative, because dwarf hens combine relatively good reproductive fitness with ad libitum feeding. Another possibility is to accept lower broiler productivity by assigning economic values to welfare and including integrity traits in an extended breeding goal.
Disciplines :
Animal production & animal husbandry
Author, co-author :
Decuypere, E.
Bruggeman, V.
Everaert, Nadia ; KU Leuven > Department of Biosystems > Division Livestock-Nutrition-Quality
Li, Yue
Boonen, R.
De Tavernier, J.
Janssens, S.
Buys, N.
Language :
English
Title :
The broiler breeder paradox: ethical, genetic and physiological perspectives, and suggestions for solutions.
ANTHONY, N.B., DUNNINGTON, E.A. & SIEGEL, P.B. (1989) Egg production and egg composition of parental lines and F1 and F2 crosses of White Rock chickens selected for 56-day body weight. Poultry Science, 68: 27-36.
BORNSTEIN, S., PLAVNIK, I. & LEV, Y. (1984) Body weight and/ or fatness as potential determinants of the onset of egg production in broiler breeder hens. British Poultry Science, 17: 215-223.
BRODY, T., SIEGEL, P.B. & CHERRY, J.A. (1984) Age, body weight and body composition requirements for the onset of sexual maturity of dwarf and normal chickens. British Poultry Science, 25: 245-252.
BROM, F.W.A. & SCHROTEN, E. (1993) Ethical questions around animal biotechnology: the Dutch approach. Livestock Production Science, 36: 99-107.
BRUGGEMAN, V. (1998) The effect of level and timing of feed restriction on growth and reproductive characteristics and their endocrine control in broiler breeder females. PhD thesis, Katholieke Universiteit (KU) Leuven.
BRUGGEMAN, V., D'HONDT, E., BERGHMAN, L., ONAGBESAN, O., VANMONTFORT, D., VANDESANDE, F. & DECUYPERE, E. (1998) The effect of food intake from 2 to 24 weeks of age on LHRH-1 content in the median eminence and gonadotrophin levels in pituitary and plasma in female broiler breeder chickens. General and Comparative Endocrinology, 112: 200-209.
BRUGGEMAN, V., ONAGBESAN, O., D'HONDT, E., BUYS, N., SAFI, M., VANMONTFORT, D., BERGHMAN, L., VANDESANDE, F. & DECUYPERE, E. (1999) Effects of timing and duration of feed restriction during rearing on productive characteristics in broiler breeder females. Poultry Science, 78: 1424-1434.
BRUGGEMAN, V., ONAGBASAN, O., WITTERS, A. & DECUYPERE, E. (Forthcoming 2010) Chickens: broiler reproduction management, in: Encyclopaedia of Animal Sciences, 2nd Edn (Abingdon, Taylor & Francis).
BUYSE, J., LEENSTRA, F.R., ZEMAN, M., RAHIMI, G. & DECUYPERE, E. (1999) A comparative study of different selection strategies to breed leaner meat-type poultry. Poultry and Avian Biology Reviews, 10: 121-142.
CAHANER, A., NITZAN, Z. & NIR, I. (1986) Reproductive performance of broiler lines divergently selected on abdominal fat. Poultry Science, 65: 1236-1243.
CHEN, S.E., MCMURBRY, J.P. & WALZEM, R.L. (2006) Overfeeding-induced ovarian dysfunction in broiler breeder hens is associated with lipotoxity. Poultry Science, 85: 70-81.
CHRISTIANSEN, S.B. & SANDØE, P. (2000) Bioethics: limits to the interference with life. Animal Reproduction Science, 60-61: 15-29.
COSTA, M.J. (1981) Fundamental principles of broiler breeders nutrition and the design of feeding programs. World's Poultry Science Journal, 37: 177-192.
DECUYPERE, E., BRUGGEMAN, V., BARBATO, G.F. & BUYSE, J. (2003) Growth and reproduction problems associated with selection for increased broiler meat production, in: MUIR, W.M. & AGGREY, S.E. (Eds) Poultry Genetics, Breeding and Technology, pp. 13-28 (Wallingford, CABI Publ.).
DECUYPERE, E., BRUGGEMAN, V., ONAGBESAN, O. & SAFI, M. (1999) Endocrine physiology of reproduction in the female chicken: old wine in new bottles. Proceedings of the International Congress on Bird Reproduction, Tours, 1999, pp. 145-153.
DECUYPERE, E., HOCKING, P.M., TONA, K., ONAGBESAN, O., BRUGGEMAN, V., JONES, E.K.M., CASSY, S., RIDEAU, N., METAYER, S., JEGO, Y., PUTTERFLAM, J., TESSERAUD, S., COLLIN, A., DUCLOS, M., TREVIDY, J.J. & WILLIAMS, J. (2006) Broiler breeder paradox: a project report. World's Poultry Science Journal, 62: 443-453.
EDENS, F.W., VAN KREY, H.P. & SIEGEL, P.B. (1973) Selection for body weight at eight weeks of age. 9. Chickens spermatozoa respiration. Poultry Science, 52: 977-981.
EMMERSON, D. (2003) Breeding objectives and selection strategies for broiler production, in: MUIR, W.M. & AGGREY, S.E. (Eds) Poultry Genetics, Breeding and Biotechnology, pp. 113-127 (Wallingford, CABI Publ.).
FABRE TECHNOLOGY PLATFORM (2005) Sustainable Animal Breeding and Reproduction. A Vision for 2025 (Fabre Technology Platform). Available: www.fabretp.org
FRANCIS, C.A. & CALLAWAY, M.B. (1993) Crop improvement for future farming systems, in: CALLAWAY, M.B. & FRANCIS, C.A. (Eds) Crop Improvement for Sustainable Agriculture, pp. 1-18 (Lincoln, NE, University of Nebraska Press).
FRASER, D. (1995) Science, values and animal welfare: exploring the inextricable connection. Animal Welfare, 4: 103-117.
FRASER, D. (2001) The 'New Perception' of animal agriculture: legless cows, featherless chickens and a need for genuine analysis. Journal of Animal Science, 79: 634-641.
GODDARD, M.E. & BEILHARZ, R.G. (1977) Natural selection and animal breeding. Proceedings of the 3rd International Congress SABRAO, Animal Breeding Papers, 4 19-4 21.
HOCKING, P.M. (1993) Effects of body weight at sexual maturity and the degree and age of restriction during rearing on the ovarian follicular hierarchy of broiler breeder females. British Poultry Science, 34: 793-801.
HOCKING, P.M., WADDINGTON, D., WALKER, M.A. & GILBERT, A.B. (1989) Control of the development of the follicular hierarchy in broiler breeder pullets by food restriction during rearing. British Poultry Science, 30: 161-174.
JAAP, R.G. & MUIR, F.V. (1968) Erratic oviposition and egg defects in broiler-type pullets. Poultry Science, 47: 417-423.
KARUNAJEEWA, H. (1987) A review of current poultry feeding systems and their potential acceptability to animal welfarists. World's Poultry Science Journal, 43: 20-32.
KATANBAF, M.N., DUNNINGTON, E.A. & SIEGEL, P.B. (1989) Restricted feeding in early and late-feathering chickens. 2. Reproductive responses. Poultry Science, 68: 352-358.
KITANO, H. (2004) Biological robustness. Nature Reviews Genetics, 5: 826-837.
KNAP, P.W. (2005) Breeding robust pigs. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 45: 763-773.
LECLERCQ, B., KOVASSI-KOUAKOU, J. & SIMON, J. (1985) Laying performance, egg composition and glucose tolerance of genetically lean or fat meat-type breeders. Poultry Science, 64: 1609-1616.
LERNER, I.M. (1954) Genetic Homeostasis (New York, NY, John Wiley).
LIU, G., DUNNINGTON, E.A. & SIEGEL, P.B. (1995) Correlated responses to long-term divergent selection for eight-week body weight in chickens: growth, sexual maturity and egg production. Poultry Science, 74: 1259-1268.
MARINNI, P.J. & GOODMAN, B.L. (1969) Semen characteristics as influenced by selection for divergent growth rate in chickens. Poultry Science, 48: 859-865.
MEPHAM, T.B. (1995) Ethical aspects of animal biotechnology. Journal of the Agricultural Society, University of Wales, 75: 3-21.
NESTOR, K.E. (1977) The influence of a genetic change in egg production, body weight, fertility or response to cold stress on semen yield in the turkey. Poultry Science, 56: 421-425.
OLESEN, I., GROEN, A.F. & GJERDE, B. (2000) Definition of animal breeding goals for sustainable production systems. Journal of Animal Science, 78: 570-582.
ONAGBESAN, O., BRUGGEMAN, V. & DECUYPERE, E. (2009) Intraovarian growth factors regulating ovarian function in avian species: a review. Animal Reproduction Science, 111: 121-140.
ONAGBESAN, O., BRUGGEMAN, V., VAN AS, P., TONA, K., WILLIAMS, J. & DECUYPERE, E. (2003) BMPs and BMPRs in the chicken ovary and the effects of BMP-4 and -7 on granulose cell proliferation and progesterone production in vitro. Journal of Physiology, Endocrinology and Metabolism, 285: 973-983.
ONAGBESAN, O., DECUYPERE, E., LEENSTRA, F. & EHLHARDT, D.A. (1999a) Differential effects of amount of feeding on cell proliferation and progesterone production in response to gonadotrophins and insulin-like growth factors by ovarian granulose cells of broiler breeder chickens selected for fatness or leanness. Journal of Reproduction and Fertility, 166: 73-85.
ONAGBESAN, O., METAYER, S., TONA, K., WILLIAMS, J., DECUYPERE, E. & BRUGGEMAN, V. (2006) Effects of genotype and feed allowance on plasma LH, FSH, progesterone, estradiol levels, follicle differentiation and egg production rates of broiler breeder hens. Poultry Science, 85: 1245-1258.
ONAGBESAN, O., VLEUGELS, B., BUYS, N., BRUGGEMAN, V., SAFI, M. & DECUYPERE, E. (1999b) Insulin-like growth factors in the regulation of avian ovarian functions. Domestic Animal Endocrinology, 17: 299-313.
POLLOCK, D.L. (1999) A geneticist's perspective from within a broiler primary breeder company. Poultry Science, 78: 414-418.
RAUW, W.M., KANIS, E., NOORDHUIZEN-STASSEN, E.W. & GROMMERS, F.J. (1998) Undesirable side effects of selection for high production efficiency. Livestock Production Science, 56: 15-33.
REDDY, P.R.K. & SIEGEL, P.B. (1977) Chromosomal abnormalities in chickens selected for high and low body weight. Journal of Heredity, 68: 253-256.
RENDEL, J.M. (1963) Correlation between the number of scutellar and abdominal bristles in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics, 48: 391-408.
RENEMA, R.A., ROBINSON, F.E. & ZUIDHOF, M.J. (2007) Reproductive efficiency and metabolism of female broiler breeders as affected by genotype, feed allocation and age at photostimulation. 1. Sexual maturation. Poultry Science, 86: 2267-2277.
ROBINSON, F.E., ZUIDHOF, M.J. & RENEMA, R.A. (2007) Reproductive efficiency and metabolism of female broiler breeders as affected by genotype, feed allocation and age at photostimulation. 1. Pullet growth and development. Poultry Science, 86: 2256-2266.
ROLLIN, B.E. (1995) The Frankenstein Syndrome: Ethical and Social Issues in the Genetic Engineering of Animals, (Cambridge, NY, Press Syndicate).
ROMERO-SANCHEZ, H., PLUMSTEAD, P.W. & BRAKE, J. (2007a) Feeding broiler breeder males. 1. Effect of feeding program and dietary crude protein during rearing on body weight and fertility of broiler breeder males. Poultry Science, 86: 168-174.
ROMERO-SANCHEZ, H., PLUMSTEAD, P.W. & BRAKE, J. (2007b) Feeding broiler breeder males. 3. Effect of feed allocation program from sixteen to twenty-six weeks and subsequent feed increments during the production period on body weight and fertility. Poultry Science, 86: 775-781.
RUSHEN, J. (2003) Changing concepts of farm animal welfare: bridging the gap between applied and basic research. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 81: 199-214.
SANDØE, P. & HOLTUY, N. (1998) Ethical aspects of biotechnology in farm animal production. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section A - Animal Science Supplement, 29: 51-58.
SIEGEL, P.B. (1963) Selection for body weight at eight weeks of age. 2. Correlated responses of feathering, body weights and reproductive characteristics. Poultry Science, 42: 896-905.
SOLLER, M., EITAN, Y. & BRODY, T. (1984) Effect of diet and early quantitative feed restriction on the minimum weight requirement for the onset of sexual maturity in White Rock broiler breeders. Poultry Science, 63: 1255-1261.
SRISKANDARAJAH, N. & BAWDEN, R. (1994) Farming as a human activity: an alternative world view, paper presented at a seminar on Achieving Results by Cooperation Within Environmental Protection and Agriculture (Kookola: Finland).
STAR, L., ELLEN, D., UITDEHAAG, K. & BROM, F.W.A. (2008) A plea to implement robustness into a breeding goal: poultry as an example. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 21: 109-125.
Sustainable European Farm Animal Breeding AND Reproduction (SEFABAR) (2005) Code of Good Practice for Farm Animal Breeding Organisations. Version 2005 (SEFABAR). Available: www.effab.org
THOMPSON, P.B. & NARDONE, A. (1999) Sustainable livestock production: methodological and ethical challenges. Livestock Production Science, 61: 111-119.
TRIYUWANTA, A., LETERRIER, C., BRILLARD, J.P. & NYS, Y. (1992) Maternal body weight and feed allowance of breeders affect performance of dwarf broiler breeders and tibial ossification of their progeny. Poultry Science, 71: 244-254.
WANG, S.Y. & JOHNSON, P.A. (1993) Increase in ovarian alphainhibin gene expression and plasma immunoreactive inhibin level is correlated with a decrease in ovulation rate in domestic hen. General and Comparative Endocrinology, 91: 52-58.
YU, M.W., ROBINSON, F.E., CHARLES, R.G. & WEINGARDT, R. (1992a) Effect of feed allowance during rearing and breeding on female broiler breeders. 2. Ovarian morphology and production. Poultry Science, 71: 1750-1761.
YU, M.W., ROBINSON, F.E. & ETCHES, R.J. (1992b) Effect of feed allowance during rearing and breeding on female broiler breeders. 2. Ovarian steroidogenesis. Poultry Science, 71: 1762-1767.
ZUIDHOF, J.M., RENEMA, R.A. & ROBINSON, F.E. (2007) Reproductive efficiency and metabolism of female broiler breeders as affected by genotype, feed allocation and age at photostimulation. 1. Reproductive efficiency. Poultry Science, 86: 2278-2286.
