Biopsy; Diagnosis, Differential; Humans; Melanoma/diagnosis/pathology; Nevus, Pigmented/diagnosis; Observer Variation; Predictive Value of Tests; Sensitivity and Specificity; Skin Neoplasms/diagnosis/pathology
Abstract :
[en] When a biopsy is taken of a suspicious pigmented skin lesion, histological examination is expected to establish the definitive diagnosis. This study evaluated the inter-observer variation of 20 pathologists in the histological diagnosis of a randomly selected set of suspicious pigmented skin lesions (PSLs), by comparing their diagnoses to a reference diagnosis. Overall sensitivity for melanoma was 87%, ranging from 55% to 100% between the observers. Sensitivity was significantly lower for thin (Breslow thickness <1 mm) than for thick melanomas (83% versus 97%, p=0.005). Overall melanoma specificity was 94%, ranging from 83% to 100% between observers. Dysplastic naevus was the most important source of false-positive diagnoses, mainly in situ melanomas. Positive and negative predictive values in the given test set were 75% and 97%, respectively. In the case of melanoma, there was quite some variation in measured Breslow thickness. This would have led to a different therapeutic approach in 12% of the readings. Some of the variation seemed to be due to a different interpretation of the presence of a co-existent naevus. In 9% (3/35) of the readings, participants did not agree on the presence of ulceration. These results reflect a tendency to overdiagnose mainly thin melanomas in general histopathological practice. They also demonstrate variation in the assessment of major prognostic factors of melanoma.
Disciplines :
Dermatology
Author, co-author :
Brochez, Lieve; University Hospital of Ghent > Dermatology
Verhaeghe, Evelien; University Hospital of Ghent > Dermatology
Grosshans, Edouard
Haneke, Eckhart
Pierard, Gérald ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Dermatopathologie
Ruiter, Dirk
Naeyaert, Jean-Marie
Language :
English
Title :
Inter-observer variation in the histopathological diagnosis of clinically suspicious pigmented skin lesions.
Publication date :
2002
Journal title :
Journal of Pathology
ISSN :
0022-3417
eISSN :
1096-9896
Publisher :
John Wiley & Sons, Inc, Chichester, United Kingdom
Marks R., Jolley D., McCormack C., Dorevitch A.P. (1997) Who removes pigmented skin lesions?. J. Am. Acad Dermatol 36:721-726.
McWilliam L.J., Knox F., Wilkinson N., Oogarah P. (1991) Performance of skin biopsies by general practitioners. Br. Med. J 303:1177-1179.
Balch C.M., Buzaid A., Atkins M.B. (2000) A new American Joint Committee on cancer staging system for cutaneous melanoma. Cancer , for the AJCC Melanoma Staging Committee; 88:1484-1491.
Duray P.H., DerSimonian R., Barnhill R. (1992) An analysis of interobserver recognition of the histopathologic features of dysplastic nevi from a mixed group of nevomelanocytic lesions. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol 27:741-749.
Duncan L.M., Berwick M., Bruijn J.A., Byers R., Mihm M.C., Barnhill R.L. (1993) Histopathologic recognition and grading of dysplastic melanocytic nevi: An interobserver agreement study. J. Invest. Dermatol 100.
Piepkorn M.W., Barnhill R.L., Cannon-Albright L.A. (1994) A multi-observer, population-based analysis of histologic dysplasia in melanocytic nevi. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol 30:707-714.
Cook M.G., Clarke T.J., Humphreys S. (1996) The evaluation of diagnostic and prognostic criteria and the terminology of thin cutaneous malignant melanoma by the CRC Melanoma Pathology Panel. Histopathology 28:497-512.
Corona R., Mele A., Amini M. (1996) Interobserver variability on the histopathologic diagnosis of cutaneous melanoma and other pigmented skin lesions. J. Clin. Oncol 14:1218-1223.
Farmer E.R., Gonin R., Hanna M.P. (1996) Discordance in the histopathologic diagnosis of melanoma and melanocytic nevi between expert pathologists. Hum. Pathol 27:528-531.
(1997) A nationwide survey of observer variation in the diagnosis of thin cutaneous malignant melanoma including the MIN terminology. J. Clin. Pathol , CRC Melanoma Pathology Panel; 50:202-205.
Barnhill R.L., Argenyi Z.B., From L. (1999) Atypical Spitz nevi/tumors: Lack of consensus for diagnosis, discrimination from melanoma and prediction of outcome. Hum. Pathol 30:513-520.
Prade M., Sancho-Garnier H., Cesarini J.P. (1980) Difficulties encountered in the application of Clark classification and the Breslow thickness measurement in cutaneous malignant melanoma. Int. J. Cancer , Cochran A - EORTC Melanoma Pathologist's Group; 26:159-163.
Heenan P.J., Matz L.R., Blackwell J.B. (1984) Inter-observer variation between pathologists in the classification of cutaneous malignant melanoma in Western Australia. Histopathology 8:717-729.
Colloby P.S., West K.P., Fletcher A. (1991) Observer variation in the measurement of Breslow depth and Clark's level in thin cutaneous malignant melanoma. J. Pathol 163:245-250.
Krieger N., Hiatt R.A., Sagebiel R.W., Clark W.H., Mihm M.C. (1994) Inter-observer variability among pathologists' evaluation of malignant melanoma: Effects upon an analytic study. J. Clin. Epidemiol 47:897-902.
Lock-Andersen J., Hou-Jensen K., Hansen J.P., Jensen N.K., Sogaard H., Andersen P.K. (1995) Observer variation in the histological classification of cutaneous malignant melanoma. Scand. J. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. Hand. Surg 29:141-148.
McDermott N.C., Hayes D.P., Al-Sader M.H. (1998) Identification of vertical growth phase in malignant melanoma; a study of interobserver agreement. Am. J. Clin. Pathol 110:753-757.
Cramer S.F. (1997) Interobserver variability in dermatopathology. Arch. Dermatol 133:1033-1036.
Riegelman R.K., Hirsch R.P. Studying a Study and Testing a Test: How to Read the Medical Literature , Little, Brown and Company: Boston (Mass.); 1991, 165-174.
Kirkwood B.R. (1988) The chi-squared test for contingency tables. Essentials of Medical Statistics , Blackwell Scientific Publications: Oxford; 87-93.
Kirkwood B.R. (1988) Non-parametric methods. Essentials of Medical Statistics , Blackwell Scientific Publications: Oxford; 151-152.
Kirkwood B.R. (1988) Non-parametric methods. Essentials of Medical Statistics , Blackwell Scientific Publications: Oxford; 147-151.
Cramer S.F., Roth L.M., Ulbright T.M. (1991) The mystique of the mistake. With proposed standards for validating proficiency tests in anatomic pathology. Am. J. Clin. Pathol 96:774-777.
MacKie R.M., Dole D., Hunter J.A.A. (1997) Cutaneous malignant melanoma in Scotland: Incidence, survival, and mortality, 1979-94. Br. Med. J 315:1117-1121.
Swerlick R.A., Chen S. (1996) The melanoma epidemic. Is increased surveillance the solution or the problem?. Arch. Dermatol 132:881-884.
Clark W.H., Elder D.E., Guerry D., Epstein M.N., Greene M.H., Van Horn M. (1984) A study of tumor progression: The precursor lesions of superficial spreading and nodular melanoma. Hum. Pathol 15:1147-1165.
Guerry D., Synnestvedt M., Elder D.E., Schultz D. (1993) Lessons from tumor progression: The invasive radial growth phase of melanoma is common, incapable of metastasis, and indolent. J. Invest. Dermatol 100.
Steijlen P.M., Bergman W., Hermans J., Scheffer E., Van Vloten W.A., Ruiter D.J. (1988) The efficacy of histopathology criteria required for diagnosing dysplastic naevi. Histopathology 12:289-300.
Piepkorn M. (1990) A hypothesis incorporating the histologic characteristics of dysplastic nevi into the normal biological development of melanocytic nevi. Arch. Dermatol 126:514-518.
Grob J.J., Andrac L., Romano M.H. (1988) Dysplastic naevus in non-familial melanoma. A clinicopathological study of 101 cases. Br. J. Dermatol 118:745-752.
Klein L.J., Barr R.J. (1990) Histologic atypia in clinically benign nevi. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol 22:275-282.
Roush G.C., Dubin N., Barnhill R.L. (1993) Prediction of histologic melanocytic dysplasia from clinical observation. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol 29:555-562.
Meyer L.J., Piepkorn M., Goldgar D.E. (1996) Interobserver concordance in discriminating clinical atypia of melanocytic nevi, and correlations with histologic atypia. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol 34:618-625.
Murphy G.F., Mihm M. (1999) Recognition and evaluation of cytological dysplasia in acquired melanocytic nevi. Hum. Pathol 30:506-512.
Clemente C., Cochran A.J., Elder D.E. (1991) Histopathologic diagnosis of dysplastic nevi: Concordance among pathologists convened by the World Health Organization Melanoma Programme. Hum. Pathol 22:313-319.
de Wit P.E.J., van't Hof-Grootenboer B., Ruiter D.J. (1993) Validity of the histopathological criteria used for diagnosing dysplastic naevi. Eur. J. Cancer 29:831-839.
Calder C.J., Campbell A.P., Plastow S.R. (1990) Measurement techniques for melanoma: A statistical comparison. J. Clin. Pathol 43:922-923.
Månsson-Brahme E., Carstensen J., Erhardt K., Lagerlof B., Ringborg U., Rutqvist L.E. (1994) Prognostic factors in thin cutaneous malignant melanoma. Cancer 73:2324-2332.
McCalmont T.H. (1997) Melanoma and melanoma in situ: Build a better diagnosis through architecture. Semin. Cutaneous Medicine Surg 16:97-107.