Quality of care; Vascular access; Haemodialysis; Infection; Peer review
Abstract :
[en] AIMS: In order to improve the supervision and to evaluate the quality of care in dialysis units, a national project was promoted as a Peer Review. It consisted of systematic, continuous and critical evaluation of the care and the application of international guidelines and compared the reality of care with standards. METHOD: The first chart consisted of the evaluation of infectious episodes of vascular access. This point is particularly relevant since infection represents the second cause of mortality in haemodialysis. A questionnaire concerning each patient was designed. Questions concerned the description of vascular access and the related infectious events. Each questionnaire included 21 items. The project involved 29 dialysis centres, 1,644 patients and 1,775 vascular accesses. The database included 90,525 data. RESULTS: Among the 29 centres, the native arteriovenous fistula (AVF) is the first choice (67.5%) in vascular access, but the proportion of AVF decreases with age contrary to the catheter, which is more frequently chosen, in older patients. Independent of age, 20% of hospitalisations are among patients with catheters and only 7% among patients with AVF. The RR (relative risk) of being hospitalised (any complication of vascular access) is 1.68 for patients with catheters compared to patients with AVF. The rate of infections does not increase with age but is higher for patients with catheters (RR = 2.26). The number of infections appears to be dependent on the staphylococcus aureus carriage in the year. CONCLUSIONS: This first step allows each centre to compare itself to others in an anonymous way. This approach should lead to specific recommendations to improve the quality of care in dialysis units.
Disciplines :
Urology & nephrology
Author, co-author :
Theelen, Bernadette ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > DIALYSE (SN +6)
Rorive, Georges ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département des sciences cliniques > Département des sciences cliniques
Jacquerye A. Guide de l'évaluation de la qualité des soins infirmiers, Paris: Edition du centurion, 1983
Jacquerye A. La qualité des soins infirmiers, Maloine 1999
Donabedian A. The definition of quality approaches to first assessments, In: Health Arbor MI: Health administration Press, 1980
Nassar M, Andayus JC. Infections complications of the haemodialysis access. Kidney International 2001; Vol. 60: 1-13
Ministère des affaires sociales de la santé publique et l'environnement, Bruxelles: Développement continu de la qualité des soins, proposition de politique nationale, Copenhagen: Bureau Régional Européen O.M.S., 1995
Grenier R, Drapeau J. Normes et critères de la qualité des soins infirmiers, Montreal: Maloine, 1989
Van Waeleghem JP, Elseviers MM, Lindley EJ. pour l'EDTNA/ERCA Collaborative Research Programme, Gestion de l'accès vasculaire en Europe 1° partie, étude des politiques ces centres de dialyse, EDTNA/ERCA Journal 2000; XXVI (4): 30-33
Dr. Cao Huu T., Les sténoses des veines centrales: revue de littérature de 1980 à 2000, Néphrologie 2001, vol. 22; 8: 483
Saad F., Central Venous Dialysis Catheters. Catheter-Associated Infection, Seminars in Dialysis 2001
N.K.F.-DOQI, Clinical Practice Guidelines for Vascular Access, National Foundation, 2000