[en] Ivermectin is a widely used antiparasitic in livestock, but its use can result in residues in bovine products and excretions. The objective of the present study was to determine the presence of ivermectin residues in cattle meat, liver, milk, faeces, and urine and assess consumer risk from chronic exposure through contaminated bovine products using a deterministic approach. To determine the presence of ivermectin residues, 124 samples were analysed by liquid chromatography. Residues were found in 68% of faeces samples and small percentages (3%) in liver, milk, and urine, with no residues detected in meat. The mean ivermectin residue in the liver (16.46 µg/kg) remained below the maximum residue limit (MRL); however, in milk (12.46 µg/kg), the residues exceeded the permitted MRL. The results obtained from chronic dietary exposure show that the consumption of ivermectin residues was low, and the risk was assessed as being rare to very rare. Additionally, this study reveals concerning levels of ivermectin residues in milk that may far exceed established safety limits. This situation emphasises the urgent need for stricter regulations and monitoring in milk production, particularly from small farms, to protect vulnerable populations. However, from a one health perspective, the presence of residues in faeces poses potential environmental hazards, warranting further research. Moreover, the detection of residues in milk, despite the ban on ivermectin use in dairy cattle, underscores the importance of compliance with food safety regulations and the need for continued vigilance in this area.
Disciplines :
Veterinary medicine & animal health
Author, co-author :
Paucar-Quishpe, Valeria ; Research Unit of Epidemiology and Risk Analysis Applied to Veterinary Science (UREAR-ULiège), Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liege, 4000 Liège, Belgium ; Fundamental and Applied Research for Animals & Health (FARAH) Center, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liege, 4000 Liège, Belgium ; Instituto de Investigación en Zoonosis (CIZ), Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Cepeda-Bastidas, Darío ; Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Rodríguez-Hidalgo, Richar ; Instituto de Investigación en Zoonosis (CIZ), Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador ; Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Pérez-Otáñez, Ximena; Instituto de Investigación en Zoonosis (CIZ), Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador ; Georges Lemaitre Centre for Earth and Climate Research, Earth & Life Institute, UCLouvain, 1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
Perez, Cecilia ; Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Enríquez, Sandra; Instituto de Investigación en Zoonosis (CIZ), Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Guzman, Erika; Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Ulcuango, Fernanda; Facultad de Ciencias Agrícolas, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Grijalva, Jorge; Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Vanwambeke, Sophie O ; Georges Lemaitre Centre for Earth and Climate Research, Earth & Life Institute, UCLouvain, 1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
Ron-Garrido, Lenin ; Instituto de Investigación en Zoonosis (CIZ), Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador ; Facultad de Medicina Veterinaria y Zootecnia, Universidad Central del Ecuador, Quito 170521, Ecuador
Saegerman, Claude ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département des maladies infectieuses et parasitaires (DMI) > Epidémiologie et analyse des risques appliqués aux sciences vétérinaires
Language :
English
Title :
Evaluating the Human Risks of Consumption of Foods of Bovine Origin with Ivermectin Residues in Ecuador.
Publication date :
29 October 2024
Journal title :
Foods
eISSN :
2304-8158
Publisher :
Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI), Switzerland
This research was funded by the Academy of Research and Higher Education (ARES) through the Research for Development Project (PRD) entitled \u201CSocio-eco-epidemiology of ticks, tickborne parasites, acaricide resistance and residual effects of acaricides in tropical Ecuadorian livestock: environmental, animal and public health impacts (Project number: 03E-2020), which involves universities from Ecuador (CIZ, Universidad Central del Ecuador) and Belgium (UCLouvain and ULi\u00E8ge).Our thanks go to the Acad\u00E9mie de Recherche et d\u2019Enseignement Sup\u00E9rieur (ARES) for funding this research and to the Universidad Central del Ecuador (UCE), UCLouvain, and the University of Li\u00E8ge for hosting this project. In addition, our thanks go to all the farmers who participated, the community leaders, the field technicians, and the students of the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine and Agronomy of the Universidad Central del Ecuador, who participated in the field and laboratory work and thanks to whom this research was possible.
Boateng E.F. Nasiru M.M. Agyemang M. Meat: Valuable Animal-Derived Nutritional Food. A Review Asian Food Sci. J. 2020 15 9 19 10.9734/afsj/2020/v15i130140
Woźniak D. Cichy W. Dobrzyńska M. Przysławski J. Drzymała-Czyż S. Reasonableness of Enriching Cow’s Milk with Vitamins and Minerals Foods 2022 11 1079 10.3390/foods11081079 35454665
FAO Dairy Market Review: Overview of Global Market Developments in 2023 FAO Rome, Italy 2024 Available online: http://www.nmpf.org/files/DMReport_March31.pdf (accessed on 5 June 2024)
FAO Meat Market Review: Overview of Global Market Developments in 2023 FAO Rome, Italy 2024
INEC Encuesta de Superficie y Producción Agropecuaria Continua Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos Quito, Ecuador 2024
Agrocalidad Categorías de Población de Ganado Bovino de Ecuador 2018 Available online: https://www.agricultura.gob.ec/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/ANEXO-1.pdf (accessed on 28 March 2024)
Rodríguez-Hidalgo R. Pérez-Otáñez X. Garcés-Carrera S. Vanwambeke S.O. Madder M. Benítez-Ortiz W. The current status of resistance to alpha-cypermethrin, ivermectin, and amitraz of the cattle tick (Rhipicephalus microplus) in Ecuador PLoS ONE 2017 12 e0174652 10.1371/journal.pone.0174652
D’Auria M. Guarnaccio A. Racioppi R. Stoia S. Emanuele L. Photodegradation of Drugs and Crop Protection Products Photochemistry of Heterocycles Elsevier Amsterdam, The Netherlands 2023 10.1016/b978-0-12-823745-8.00003-0
Pandit M.A. Tarkeshwar Ivermectin: An Anthelminthic and Insecticide Chemistry and Biological Activities of Ivermectin Wiley Hoboken, NJ, USA 2023 163 197 10.1002/9781394168033.ch8
Pecenka J.R. Lundgren J.G. Effects of herd management and the use of ivermectin on dung arthropod communities in grasslands Basic Appl. Ecol. 2019 40 19 29 10.1016/j.baae.2019.07.006
Mancini L. Lacchetti I. Chiudioni F. Cristiano W. Kevin D.D. Marcheggiani S. Carere M. Bindi L. Borrello S. Need for a sustainable use of medicinal products: Environmental impacts of ivermectin Ann. Ist. Super. Sanita 2020 56 492 496 10.4415/ANN_20_04_12
Soares V.M. Pereira J.G. Barreto F. Jank L. Rau R.B. Ribeiro C.B.D. dos Santos Castilhos T. Tomaszewski C.A. Hillesheim D.R. Mondadori R.G. et al. Residues of Veterinary Drugs in Animal Products Commercialized in the Border Region of Brazil, Argentina, and Uruguay J. Food Prot. 2022 85 980 986 10.4315/JFP-21-415
FAO/WHO Evaluation of Certain Veterinary Drug Residues in Food: Ninety-Fourth Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives WHO Technical Report Series No. 1041 WHO Geneva, Switzerland 2022 301 302 10.1017/cbo9780511622670.019
FAO/WHO Maximum Residue Limits (MRLs) and Risk Management Recommendations (RMRs) for Residues of Veterinary Drugs in Foods World Health Organization—Technical Report Series WHO Geneva, Switzerland 2023
Dedavid e Silva L.A. Ali A. Termignoni C. Vaz Júnior I.d.S. Vaccination against Rhipicephalus microplus: An alternative to chemical control? Cienc. Rural 2024 54 e20230161 10.1590/0103-8478cr20230161
Nyokabi S. Luning P.A. de Boer I.J. Korir L. Muunda E. Bebe B.O. Lindahl J. Bett B. Oosting S.J. Milk quality and hygiene: Knowledge, attitudes and practices of smallholder dairy farmers in central Kenya Food Control 2021 130 108303 10.1016/j.foodcont.2021.108303
Paucar-Quishpe V. Pérez-Otáñez X. Rodríguez-Hidalgo R. Cepeda-Bastidas D. Pérez-Escalante C. Grijalva-Olmedo J. Enríquez S. Arciniegas-Ortega S. Sandoval-Trávez L. An economic evaluation of cattle tick acaricide-resistances and the financial losses in subtropical dairy farms of Ecuador: A farm system approach PLoS ONE 2023 18 e0287104 10.1371/journal.pone.0287104
CIL En Ecuador, dos de cada tres litros de leche comercializan de modo informal Centro De La Industria Láctea Del Ecuador Quito, Ecuador 2023 Available online: https://www.cil-ecuador.org/post/en-ecuador-dos-de-cada-tres-litros-de-leche-comercializan-de-modo-informal#:~:text=2min.-,EnEcuador%2Cdosdecadatreslitrosdelechecomercializan,5%27500.000litrospordía (accessed on 14 August 2024)
Choco Andino Pichincha Reserva de biósfera del Chocó Andino De Pichincha Available online: https://www.chocoandinopichincha.com/ (accessed on 24 October 2022)
Ministerio de Ambiente y Agua Plan de Manejo Parque Nacional Cayambe Coca Ministerio de Ambiente y Agua Quito, Ecuador 2022 10.1542/ppe_document265.spanish
Benavides B. Análisis de los Sistemas Productivos Agropecuarios Ganaderos en el Noroccidente de Pichincha Repositorio Digital-Universidad Central del Ecuador Quito, Ecuador 2022
PDOT Quijos Plan de Desarrollo y Ordenamiento Territorial del Cantón Quijos Dirección de Planificación y Ordenamiento Territorial, GAD Municipal Quijos Quito, Ecuador 2024 1 394
Paucar V. Ron-Román J. Benítez-Ortiz W. Celi M. Berkvens D. Saegerman C. Ron-Garrido L. Bayesian Estimation of the Prevalence and Test Characteristics (Sensitivity and Specificity) of Two Serological Tests (RB and SAT-EDTA) for the Diagnosis of Bovine Brucellosis in Small and Medium Cattle Holders in Ecuador Microorganisms 2021 9 1815 10.3390/microorganisms9091815
Agrocalidad Reporte Vacunacion Fiebre Aftosa Agencia de Regulación y Control Fito y Zoosanitario Quito, Ecuador 2023
INEN Acreditación de laboratorios de ensayo y calibración según NTE INEN- ISO/IEC 17025:2018 INEN Quito, Ecuador 2018
INEC Censo De Población Y Vivienda (PV 2010) 2010 Available online: https://www.ecuadorencifras.gob.ec/censo-de-poblacion-y-vivienda/ (accessed on 31 May 2024)
Carrasco Cabrera L. Medina Pastor P. EFSA The 2020 European Union report on pesticide residues in food EFSA J. 2022 20 e07215 10.2903/j.efsa.2022.7215 35386573
FAO/WHO Instructions for Electronic Submission of Data on Chemical Contaminants in Food and the Diet. Global Environment Monitoring System—Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment Programme (GEMS/Food) Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) Rome, Italy 2023
Hubal E.A.C. de Wet T. Du Toit L. Firestone M.P. Ruchirawat M. van Engelen J. Vickers C. Identifying important life stages for monitoring and assessing risks from exposures to environmental contaminants: Results of a World Health Organization review Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 2014 69 113 124 10.1016/j.yrtph.2013.09.008 24099754
Hagan J. Shaw J. Duncan P. Bright Futures: Guidelines for Health Supervision of Infants, Children, and Adolescents 4th ed. American Academy of Pediatrics Itasca, Illinois, USA 2017 10.1016/j.rbmo.2016.12.001
FAO/WHO Joint FAO/WHO Expert Meeting on Dietary Exposure Assessment Methodologies for Residues of Veterinary Drugs: Final Report Including Report of Stakeholder Meeting World Health Organization Geneva, Switzerland 2012 Available online: https://www.fao.org/fileadmin/user_upload/agns/pdf/jecfa/Dietary_Exposure_Assessment_Methodologies_for_Residues_of_Veterinary_Drugs.pdf (accessed on 22 July 2024)
Novaes S.F.D. Schreiner L.L. Silva I.P.E. Franco R.M. Residues of veterinary drugs in milk in Brazil Ciência Rural 2017 47 e20170215 10.1590/0103-8478cr20170215
EMA Opinion of the Committee for Medicinal Products for Veterinary Use on the establishment of maximum residue limits; procedure no: EU/09/170/SCM; name of the substance: Octenidine dihydrochloride (INN) Vet. Med. Prod. Data Manag. Opin. 2013 44 1 3
Health Canada List of Maximum Residue Limits (MRLs) for Veterinary Drugs in Foods Food and Drugs Act Health Canada Ottawa, ON, Canada 2024
Paucar V. Pérez-Otáñez X. Rodríguez-Hidalgo R. Perez C. Cepeda-Bastidas D. Grijalva J. Enríquez S. Arciniegas-Ortega S. Vanwambeke S.O. Ron-Garrido L. et al. The Associated Decision and Management Factors on Cattle Tick Level of Infestation in Two Tropical Areas of Ecuador Pathogens 2022 11 403 10.3390/pathogens11040403
Brito S.N. Determinación de residuos de antibióticos en carne de ganado bovino por el método de ELISA en el Centro de Faenamiento de la Empresa Pública Metropolitana de rastro Quito- La Ecuatoriana Repositorio Digital-Universidad Central del Ecuador Quito, Ecuador 2017 168
Puga-Torres B. Aragón Vásquez E. Ron L. Álvarez V. Bonilla S. Guzmán A. Lara D. De la Torre D. Milk Quality Parameters of Raw Milk in Ecuador between 2010 and 2020: A Systematic Literature Review and Meta-Analysis Foods 2022 11 3351 10.3390/foods11213351
Puga-Torres B. Aragón E. Contreras A. Escobar D. Guevara K. Herrera L. López N. Luje D. Martínez M. Sánchez L. et al. Analysis of quality and antibiotic residues in raw milk marketed informally in the Province of Pichincha–Ecuador Food Agric. Immunol. 2024 35 2291321 10.1080/09540105.2023.2291321
de la Cueva F. Naranjo A. Torres B.P. Aragón E. Presence of heavy metals in raw bovine milk from Machachi, Ecuador Granja 2021 33 21 30 10.17163/lgr.n33.2021.02
Freire N. Evaluacion cuantitativa de residuos en carne de ganado de engorde, post aplicacion pour-on, del producto fipronil mas ivermectina Univ. Cent. Ecuad. 2017 14 1 49
Balseca P. Determinacion cuantitativa de residuos en leche de epronomectina usado como mosquicida en vacas lecheras Universidad Central del Ecuador Quito, Ecuador 2017 1 44
Junco M. Iglesias L.E. Sagués M.F. Guerrero I. Zegbi S. Saumell C.A. Effect of macrocyclic lactones on nontarget coprophilic organisms: A review Parasitol. Res. 2021 120 773 783 10.1007/s00436-021-07064-4
Finch D. Schofield H. Floate K.D. Kubasiewicz L.M. Mathews F. Implications of Endectocide Residues on the Survival of Aphodiine Dung Beetles: A Meta-Analysis Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2020 39 863 872 10.1002/etc.4671 32181912
Herd R.P. Sams R.A. Ashcraft S.M. Persistence of ivermectin in plasma and faeces following treatment of cows with ivermectin sustained-release, pour-on or injectable formulations Int. J. Parasitol. 1996 26 1087 1093 10.1016/S0020-7519(96)80007-5 8982789
Suárez V.H. Lifschitz A.L. Sallovitz J.M. Lanusse C.E. Effects of faecal residues of moxidectin and doramectin on the activity of arthropods in cattle dung Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. 2009 72 1551 1558 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2007.11.009 18192015
Lumaret J.P. Galante E. Lumbreras C. Mena J. Bertrand M. Bernal J.L. Cooper J.F. Kadiri N. Crowe D. Field Effects of Ivermectin Residues on Dung Beetles J. Appl. Ecol. 1993 30 428 436 10.2307/2404183
Kövecses J. Marcogliese D.J. Avermectins: Potential Environmental Risks and Impacts on Freshwater Ecosystems in Quebec Scientific and Technical Report ST-233E Environment Canada, Quebec Region, Environmental Conservation, St. Lawrence Centre Montréal, QC, Canada 2005
Wohde M. Blanckenhorn W.U. Floate K.D. Lahr J. Lumaret J.P. Römbke J. Scheffczyk A. Tixier T. Düring R.A. Analysis and dissipation of the antiparasitic agent ivermectin in cattle dung under different field conditions Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2016 35 1924 1933 10.1002/etc.3462
Mendoza M. El Comercio El 36% de la carne sale de camales clandestinos 2017 Available online: https://www.elcomercio.com/actualidad/quito/carne-camales-clandestinos-quito-normativa.html (accessed on 7 June 2024)
Castillo M.J. Carpio C.E. Demand for High-Quality Beef Attributes in Developing Countries: The Case of Ecuador J. Agric. Appl. Econ. 2019 51 568 590 10.1017/aae.2019.21
Ritchie H. Roser M. Meat and Dairy Production OurWorldInData.org Available online: https://ourworldindata.org/meat-production (accessed on 7 June 2024)
Baquerizo V. Córdova V. Impacto económico del sector lácteo: Un estudio de los gastos publicitarios y las ventas en tiempos de pandemia 593 Digit. Publ. CEIT 2022 7 310 321 10.33386/593dp.2022.6-1.1527
CIL El sector lácteo ecuatoriano se reactiva con miras positivas para el 2022 Centro de Industria Láctea del Ecuador Quito, Ecuador 2022 Available online: https://www.cil-ecuador.org/post/el-sector-lácteo-ecuatoriano-se-reactiva-con-miras-positivas-para-el-2022 (accessed on 21 October 2023)
Bermeo F. Seguridad alimentaria; Responsabilidad de los Gobiernos Autónomos Descentralizados Provinciales Flacsoandes 2015 13 1 4
CIL Entre 2022 y 2023 el consumo de lácteos en Ecuador cayó un 12% Centro De La Industria Láctea Del Ecuador Quito, Ecuador 2024
JECFA Toxicological Evaluation of Certain Veterinary Drug Residues in Food- Eighty-first meeting of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives WHO Geneva, Switzerland 2016 Volume 18
Lankas G.R. Minsker D.H. Robertson R.T. Effects of ivermectin on reproduction and neonatal toxicity in rats Food Chem. Toxicol. 1989 27 523 529 10.1016/0278-6915(89)90048-3
Hoang R. Temple C. Correia M.S. Clemons J. Hendrickson R.G. Characteristics of ivermectin toxicity in patients taking veterinary and human formulations for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 Clin. Toxicol. 2022 60 1350 1355 10.1080/15563650.2022.2134788
Vragović N. Bažulić D. Njari B. Risk assessment of streptomycin and tetracycline residues in meat and milk on Croatian market Food Chem. Toxicol. 2011 49 352 355 10.1016/j.fct.2010.11.006 21074594
Agrocalidad Centros de faenamiento habilitados como MABIO utilizarán logo para diferenciar sus productos Agencia de Regulación y Control Fito y Zoosanitario Quito, Ecuador 2020 Available online: https://actoresproductivos.com/agrocalidad-presenta-oficialmente-el-logotipo-mabio// (accessed on 9 June 2024)
USP 42, Official Monographs, Ivermectin United Stated Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville, MD, USA 2020 2555 2556
Nuñez M. Palma M. Araneda M. Pérez R. Validation of an analytical method and determination of ivermectin residues in sheep tissues Rev. Cient. 2007 17 6