[en] Conducting the screening and replanting of crops with low accumulation of heavy metals can effectively reduce the risk of heavy metal accumulation in agricultural products. However，current research focuses more on the screening of crops with low accumulation of a single heavy metal. Target crops also focus more on single-type crops and varieties. Research on the accumulation differences in arsenic and cadmium in different crop types and the priority recommendation list for the planting of low-accumulation crops is limited. This study used a combination of literature data meta-analysis and field survey methods to conduct the relevant work. The results showed that the range of arsenic and cadmium content in rice grains was 0.11-0.624 mg·kg−1 and 0.01-1.935 mg·kg−1，respectively. Under the same pollution level，rice had a relatively higher risk of accumulating arsenic and cadmium than that in maize and leafy vegetables，fruit vegetables，and root and tuber vegetables. Some leafy vegetables had significantly higher arsenic and cadmium levels，and the difference in arsenic and cadmium accumulation ability between varieties of leafy vegetables was greater than that of other types of crops. The risk of arsenic and cadmium accumulation in the edible parts of maize，fruit vegetables，and root and tuber vegetables after replacing rice cultivation was more significant. Based on the above results，a priority recommendation list for the planting of low-accumulation crops based on pollution level was constructed. Field survey results showed that the list was reasonable to a certain extent. The relevant results of this study can provide effective reference for the optimization of crop type or variety selection and safe production in arsenic and cadmium-polluted soils.
Disciplines :
Agriculture & agronomy
Author, co-author :
Ren, Yan-Xin; School of Resources and Environment, Qingdao Agricultural University, Qingdao, China ; Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China
Geng, Zhi-Xi; College of Land and Environment, Shenyang Agricultural University, Shenyang, China
Song, Ning-Ning; School of Resources and Environment, Qingdao Agricultural University, Qingdao, China
Zhang, Ting ; Université de Liège - ULiège > TERRA Research Centre ; Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China
Zhang, Nan; Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China
Wu, Cui-Xia; Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China
Liu, Wei; College of Chemistry and Materials Science, Hebei University, Baoding, China
Zeng, Xi-Bai; Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China
Su, Shi-Ming; Key Laboratory of Agro-Environment, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, Institute of Environment and Sustainable Development in Agriculture, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing, China
Language :
Chinese
Title :
基于作物累积砷镉差异的超标农区优先种植作物筛选
Alternative titles :
[en] Screening for the Priority Crops in Over-standard Planting Region Based on the Difference in Arsenic and Cadmium Accumulated in Crops
［ 1 ］ 蔡美芳，李开明，谢丹平，等 . 我国耕地土壤重金属污染现状与 防 治 对 策 研 究［J］. 环 境 科 学 与 技 术 ，2014，37（S2）：223-230. Cai M F，Li K M，Xie D P，et al. The status and protection strategy of farmland soils polluted by heavy metals［J］. Environmental Science & Technology，2014，37（S2）：223-230.
［ 4 ］ Tong S M， Li H R， Wang L， et al. Concentration， Spatial distribution， contamination degree and human health risk assessment of heavy metals in urban soils across China between 2003 and 2019—A systematic review［J］. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health，2020，17（9），doi：10.3390/ijerph17093099.
［ 5 ］ Han R X，Wang Z，Wang S Q，et al. A combined strategy to mitigate the accumulation of arsenic and cadmium in rice（Oryza sativa L.）［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2023，896，doi：10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.165226.
［ 6 ］ 殷飞，王海娟，李燕燕，等 . 不同钝化剂对重金属复合污染土壤 的 修 复 效 应 研 究［J］. 农 业 环 境 科 学 学 报 ，2015，34（3）438-448. Yin F，Wang H J，Li Y Y，et al. Remediation of multiple heavy metal polluted soil using different immobilizing agents［J］. Journal of Agro-Environment Science，2015，34（3）：438-448.
［ 7 ］ 樊霆，叶文玲，陈海燕，等 . 农田土壤重金属污染状况及修复技术研究［J］. 生态环境学报，2013，22（10）：1727-1736. Fan T，Ye W L，Chen H Y，et al. Review on contamination and remediation technology of heavy metal in agricultural soil［J］. Ecology and Environmental Sciences，2013，22（10）：1727-1736.
［ 8 ］ 曹心德，魏晓欣，代革联，等 . 土壤重金属复合污染及其化学钝 化 修 复 技 术 研 究 进 展［J］. 环 境 工 程 学 报 ，2011，5（7）：1441-1453. Cao X D，Wei X X，Dai G L，et al. Combined pollution of multiple heavy metals and their chemical immobilization in contaminated soils：a review［J］. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering，2011，5（7）：1441-1453.
［ 9 ］ Zheng S A， Zhang M K. Effect of moisture regime on the redistribution of heavy metals in paddy soil ［J］. Journal of Environmental Sciences，2011，23（3）：434-443.
［10］ Sun P，Qu C C，Xiong Z Q，et al. Organic fertilization integrated with water management to remediate As and Cd contamination in a paddy soil ［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2023，886，doi：10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.163992.
［11］ 王荣萍，张雪霞，郑煜基，等 . 水分管理对重金属在水稻根区及在水稻中积累的影响［J］. 生态环境学报，2013，22（12）1956-1961. Wang R P，Zhang X X，Zheng Y J，et al. Accumulation of heavy metal in rhizosphere of rice and their uptake in rice with different water managements［J］. Ecology and Environmental Sciences，2013，22（12）：1956-1961.
［12］ 李林峰，王艳红，李义纯，等 . 调理剂耦合水分管理对双季稻 镉 和 铅 累 积 的 阻 控 效 应［J］. 环 境 科 学 ，2022，43（1）：472-480. Li L F，Wang Y H，Li Y C，et al. Inhibitory effects of soil amendment coupled with water management on the accumulation of Cd and Pb in double-cropping rice［J］. Environmental Science，2022，43（1）：472-480.
［13］ Cui H，Tang S T，Huang S Q，et al. Simultaneous mitigation of arsenic and cadmium accumulation in rice grains by foliar inhibitor with ZIF-8@Ge-132［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2023 860，doi：10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.160307.
［14］ Xu C，Chen Y P，Su C C，et al. Microbial characteristics response to the soil quality of newly created farmland on the Loess Plateau ［J］. Environmental Science and Pollution Research，2021，28 （31）：42290-42299.
［15］ Requejo R，Tena M. Intra-specific variability in the response of maize to arsenic exposure［J］. Environmental Science and Pollution Research，2014，21（18）：10574-10582.
［16］ Rai P K，Lee S S，Zhang M，et al. Heavy metals in food crops：health risks，fate，mechanisms，and management ［J］. Environment International，2019，125：365-385.
［17］ Duan G L，Shao G S，Tang Z，et al. Genotypic and environmental variations in grain cadmium and arsenic concentrations among a panel of high yielding rice cultivars［J］. Rice，2017，10（1），doi：10.1186/s12284-017-0149-2.
［18］ Yi Q S，Wang Y，Yi C，et al. Agronomic and ionomics indicators of high-yield， mineral-dense， and low-Cd grains of wheat （Triticum aestivum L.） cultivars ［J］. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety，2023，261，doi：10.1016/j. ecoenv. 2023. 115120.
［19］ Cao X X，Gao X，Zeng X B，et al. Seeking for an optimal strategy to avoid arsenic and cadmium over-accumulation in crops：soil management vs cultivar selection in a case study with maize［J］. Chemosphere，2021，272，doi：10.1016/j. chemosphere. 2021. 129891.
［20］ 高鑫，颜蒙蒙，曾希柏，等 . 京津冀地区设施土壤中不同蔬菜对 镉 的 累 积 特 征［J］. 农 业 环 境 科 学 学 报 ，2018，37（11）：2541-2548. Gao X，Yan M M，Zeng X B，et al. Cadmium accumulation characteristics of different vegetables in greenhouse soils in the Beijing，Tianjin，and Hebei（BTH）Area，China［J］. Journal of Agro-Environment Science，2018，37（11）：2541-2548.
［21］ Alexander P D，Alloway B J，Dourado A M. Genotypic variations in the accumulation of Cd，Cu，Pb and Zn exhibited by six commonly grown vegetables［J］. Environmental Pollution，2006 144（3）：736-745.
［22］ 赵方杰 . 水稻砷的吸收机理及阻控对策［J］. 植物生理学报2014，50（5）：569-576. Zhao F J. Mechanisms of arsenic uptake by rice and mitigation strategies［J］. Plant Physiology Journal，2014，50（5）：569-576.
［23］ 鲍士旦 . 土壤农化分析［M］.（第三版）. 北京：中国农业出版社，2000.
［24］ Yu H Y，Li F B，Liu C S，et al. Iron redox cycling coupled to transformation and immobilization of heavy metals：implications for paddy rice safety in the red soil of South China［J］. Advances in Agronomy，2016，137：279-317.
［25］ Yan M M，Zeng X B，Wang J，et al. Dissolved organic matter differentially influences arsenic methylation and volatilization in paddy soils［J］. Journal of Hazardous Materials，2020，388，doi：10.1016/j.jhazmat.2019.121795.
［26］ Cruz S M，Schmidt L，Dalla Nora F M，et al. Microwave-induced combustion method for the determination of trace and ultratrace element impurities in graphite samples by ICP-OES and ICP-MS ［J］. Microchemical Journal，2015，123：28-32.
［27］ Hedges L V，Gurevitch J，Curtis P S，et al. The meta-analysis of response ratios in experimental ecology［J］. Ecology，1999，80 （4）：1150-1156.
［28］ Rosenberg M S，Adams D C，Gurevitch J. MetaWin：statistical software for meta-analysis，version 2［R］. Sunderland：Sinauer Associates，2000.
［29］ Li K，Cao C L，Ma Y B，et al. Identification of cadmium bioaccumulation in rice（Oryza sativa L.）by the soil-plant transfer model and species sensitivity distribution［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2019，692：1022-1028.
［30］ 王擎运，张佳宝，信秀丽，等 . 长期不同施肥方式对砷在典型壤质潮土及作物中累积的影响［J］. 中国生态农业学报，2012，20（10）：1295-1302. Wang Q Y，Zhang J B，Xin X L，et al. Effects of long-term fertilization on As（arsenate）accumulation in typical fluvo-aquic soils and crops［J］. Chinese Journal of Eco-Agriculture，2012，20 （10）：1295-1302.
［31］ Williams P N，Villada A，Deacon C，et al. Greatly enhanced arsenic shoot assimilation in rice leads to elevated grain levels compared to wheat and barley［J］. Environmental Science & Technology，2007，41（19）：6854-6859.
［32］ 曾希柏，苏世鸣，吴翠霞，等 . 农田土壤中砷的来源及调控研究与展望［J］. 中国农业科技导报，2014，16（2）：85-91. Zeng X B，Su S M，Wu C X，et al. Research and prospect of arsenic source and its regulation in arable land soil［J］. Journal of Agricultural Science and Technology，2014，16（2）：85-91.
［33］ 高智群，张美剑，赵科理，等 . 土壤—水稻系统重金属空间异质性研究——以浙江省嵊州市为例［J］. 中国环境科学，2016，36（1）：215-224. Gao Z Q，Zhang M J，Zhao K L，et al. Heavy metal contamination in soil-rice system and its spatial variation in Shengzhou City［J］. China Environmental Science，2016，36（1）：215-224.
［34］ 方波，肖腾伟，苏娜娜，等 . 水稻镉吸收及其在各器官间转运 积 累 的 研 究 进 展［J］. 中 国 水 稻 科 学 ，2021，35（3）：225-237. Fang B，Xiao T W，Su N N，et al. Research progress on cadmium uptake and its transport and accumulation among organs in rice［J］. Chinese Journal of Rice Science，2021，35（3）：225-237.
［35］ 施亚星，吴绍华，周生路，等 . 土壤-作物系统中重金属元素吸收、迁移和积累过程模拟［J］. 环境科学，2016，37（10）：3996-4003. Shi Y X，Wu S H，Zhou S L，et al. Simulation of the absorption，migration and accumulation process of heavy metal elements in soil-crop system［J］. Environmental Science，2016，37（10）：3996-4003.
［36］ Gu J F， Zhou H， Tang H L， et al. Cadmium and arsenic accumulation during the rice growth period under in situ remediation ［J］. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety， 2019， 171：451-459.
［37］ 欧阳喜辉，赵玉杰，刘凤枝，等 . 不同种类蔬菜对土壤镉吸收能力的研究［J］. 农业环境科学学报，2007，27（1）：67-70. Ouyang X H，Zhao Y J，Liu F Z，et al. Absorption ability of different types of vegetables for soil Cd in Beijing［J］. Journal of Agro-Environment Science，2007，27（1）：67-70.
［38］ Nabulo G，Young S D，Black C R. Assessing risk to human health from tropical leafy vegetables grown on contaminated urban soils ［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2010，408（22）：5338-5351.
［39］ Marchiol L，Assolari S，Sacco P，et al. Phytoextraction of heavy metals by canola（Brassica napus）and radish（Raphanus sativus）grown on multicontaminated soil［J］. Environmental Pollution，2004，132（1）：21-27.
［40］ Perfus-Barbeoch L，Leonhardt N，Vavasseur A，et al. Heavy metal toxicity： cadmium permeates through calcium channels and disturbs the plant water status［J］. The Plant Journal，2002，32 （4）：539-548.
［41］ Zhou H，Zeng M，Zhou X，et al. Assessment of heavy metal contamination and bioaccumulation in soybean plants from mining and smelting areas of southern Hunan province， China［J］. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry，2013，32（12）：2719-2727.
［42］ 董俊文，高培培，孙洪欣，等 . 设施叶菜类蔬菜重金属镉、铅和砷累积特征及健康风险评价［J］. 环境科学，2022，43（1）：481-489. Dong J W，Gao P P，Sun H X，et al. Characteristics and health risk assessment of cadmium，lead，and arsenic accumulation in leafy vegetables planted in a greenhouse［J］. Environmental Science，2022，43（1）：481-489.
［43］ Zeng X B，Bai L Y，Gao X，et al. Agricultural planning by selecting food crops with low arsenic accumulation to efficiently reduce arsenic exposure to human health in an arsenic-polluted mining region［J］. Journal of Cleaner Production，2021，308，doi：10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127403.
［44］ 孟媛 . 几种叶类蔬菜对镉砷的富集效应及其耐性机制［D］. 杨凌：西北农林科技大学，2019. Meng Y. Accumulation of cadmium and arsenic in different leafy vegetables and tolerant mechanism［D］. Yangling：Northwest A&F University，2019.
［45］ Rahman M A，Hasegawa H. Aquatic arsenic：phytoremediation using floating macrophytes［J］. Chemosphere，2011，83（5）：633-646.
［46］ Muchuweti M，Birkett J W，Chinyanga E，et al. Heavy metal content of vegetables irrigated with mixtures of wastewater and sewage sludge in Zimbabwe：implications for human health［J］. Agriculture，Ecosystems & Environment，2006，112（1）：41-48.
［47］ Zhou H，Yang W T，Zhou X，et al. Accumulation of heavy metals in vegetable species planted in contaminated soils and the health risk assessment ［J］. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health， 2016， 13（3）， doi： 10.3390/ ijerph13030289.
［48］ 李富荣，李敏，杜应琼，等 . 茄果类蔬菜对其产地土壤重金属的吸收富集与安全阈值研究［J］. 农产品质量与安全，2018，（1）：52-58. Li F R，Li M，Du Y Q，et al. Residual behavior and dietary risk assessment of lambda-cyhalothrin in papaya［J］. Quality and Safety of Agro-Products，2018，（1）：52-58.
［49］ 杨晓远，王海娟，王宏镔 . 龙葵（Solanum nigrum L.）超富集镉的生理和分子机制研究进展［J］. 生态毒理学报，2020，15 （6）：72-81. Yang X Y，Wang H J，Wang H B. Advances in physiological and molecular mechanisms of cadmium hyperaccumulation by Solanum nigrum L.［J］. Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology，2020，15（6）：72-81.
［50］ 陈 建 军 ，于 蔚 ，祖 艳 群 ，等 . 玉 米（Zea mays）对 镉 积 累 与 转 运的 品 种 差 异 研 究［J］. 生 态 环 境 学 报 ，2014，23（10）：1671-1676. Chen J J， Yu W， Zu Y Q， et al. Variety difference of Cd accumulation and translocation in Zea mays［J］. Ecology and Environmental Sciences，2014，23（10）：1671-1676.
［51］ Wang B B，Lin Z C，Li X，et al. Genome-wide selection and genetic improvement during modern maize breeding［J］. Nature Genetics，2020，52（6）：565-571.
［52］ Cao X X，Bai L Y，Zeng X B，et al. Is maize suitable for substitution planting in arsenic-contaminated farmlands？［J］. Plant，Soil and Environment，2019，65（9）：425-434.
［53］ 任超，肖建辉，李竞天，等 . 不同玉米品种 Cd、Pb、Zn 和 As 积累与转运特性［J］. 环境科学，2022，43（8）：4232-4252. Ren C，Xiao J H，Li J T，et al. Accumulation and transport characteristics of Cd，Pb，Zn，and As in different maize varieties ［J］. Environmental Science，2022，43（8）：4232-4252.
