Western Balkans, European Union, Enlargement, Geopolitics, Actorness
Abstract :
[en] This article critically examines the impact of the Russian invasion of Ukraine on European Union (EU) policies pertaining to the Western Balkan states, namely Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo, Montenegro, North Macedonia, and Serbia. While the EU has long embraced a normative approach towards the Western Balkan region, the article argues that the Union is undergoing a profound shift towards a more geostrategic and geopolitical policy orientation. By employing an extensive analysis of the existing literature and first-hand data, this article makes a valuable contribution to the academic debates surrounding the EU’s enlargement policy (EEP), particularly focusing on its inherent limitations as a normative power. The findings reveal significant inconsistencies within the EU’s treatment of individual Western Balkan countries, with notable concessions being disproportionately granted to Serbia at the expense of the Union’s credibility. It exacerbates the pressure faced by the Western Balkan region, consequently providing fertile ground for Russia to exploit and amplify its illiberal influence in the area.
Disciplines :
Political science, public administration & international relations
L. Lika, The meaning of the Western Balkans Concept for the EU: Genuine Inclusion or Polite Exclusion? Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 1–16 (2023).
F. Duchene, The European Community and the Uncertainties of Interdependence, in A Nation Writ Large? Foreign-Policy Problems before the European Community 1–21 (M. Kohnstamm & W. Hager eds, London, Macmillan 1973).
I. Manners, Normative Power Europe: A Contradiction in Terms?, 40(2) J. Com. Mkt. Stud. 235–258 (2002), doi: 10.1111/1468-5965.00353; Z. Laïdi, L’Europe, puissance normative internationale, in Politiques européennes 227–242 (R. Dehousse ed., Paris, Presses de Sciences Po 2009).
V. Anghel & J. Dzankic, Wartime EU: Consequences of the Russia–Ukraine War on the Enlargement Process, 45(3) J. Eur. Integ. 487–501 (2023), doi: 10.1080/07036337.2023.2190106; I. Marinova, The EU at a Strategic Crossroads: A Geopolitical Player in Great Power Games? 28(2) Eur. foreign Aff. Rev. 117–140 (2023), doi: 10.54648/EERR2023007.
S. Santander & A. Vlassis, EU in Global Affairs: Constrained Ambition in an Unpredictable World?, 25(1) Eur. foreign Aff. Rev. 5–12 (2020), doi: 10.54648/EERR2020002; C. Bretherton & John Vogler, The European Union as a Global Actor (London & New York, Routledge 2006); C. Hill & M. Smith eds, International Relations and the European Union (Oxford & New York, Oxford University Press 2005).
M. Merle, Sociologie des relations internationales (Paris, Dalloz 1988).
J. Jupille & J. A. Caporaso, States, Agency, and Rules: The European Union in Global Environmental Politics, in The European Union in the World Community 213–229 (C. Rhodes ed., Lynne Rienner, Boulder 1998).
R. Yakemtchouk, La politique étrangère de l’Union européenne (Paris, L’Harmattan 2005); S. Vanhoonacker, The Bush Administration (1989–1993) and the Development of a European Security Identity (London & New York, Routledge 2018).
S. Saurugger, Théories et concepts de l’intégration européenne (Paris, Presses de Sciences Po 2020).
F. Schimmelfenning & T. Winzen, Ever Looser Union? Differentiated European Integration (Oxford, Oxford University Press 2020).
L. Demetropoulou, Europe and the Balkans: Membership Aspiration, EU Involvement and Europeanization Capacity in South Eastern Europe, 3(2/3) Southeast Eur. Pol. 87–106 (2002); Lika, supra n. 2.
V. Musliu, Europeanization and Statebuilding as Everyday Practices: Performing Europe in the Western Balkans (London, Routledge 2021); L. Greiçevci, The EU as a State-Builder in International Affairs: The Case of Kosovo (London & New York, Routledge 2022); R. Ilazi, The European Union and Everyday Statebuilding. The Case of Kosovo (London & New York, Routledge 2023).
F. Bieber, Patterns of Competitive Authoritarianism in the Western Balkans, 34(3) East Eur. Pol. 337–354 (2018), doi: 10.1080/21599165.2018.1490272; G. Noutcheva, Fake, Partial and Imposed Compliance: The Limits of the EU’s Normative Power in the Western Balkans, 16(7) J. Eur. Pub. Pol. 1065–1084 (2009), doi: 10.1080/13501760903226872.
S. Keukeleire & T. Delreux, The Foreign Policy of the European Union (Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan 2014).
S. Klose, Theorizing EU Actorness: Towards an Interactionist Role Theory Framework, 56(5) J. Com. Mkt. Stud. 1144–1160, at 1144 (2018), doi: 10.1111/jcms.12725.
L. Simão, Unpacking EU’s International Actorness: Debates, Theories and Concepts, in EU Global Actorness in a World of Contested Leadership: Policies, Instruments and Perceptions 13–32 (M. R. Freire et al. eds, Cham, Springer International Publishing 2022).
Klose, supra n. 16; Simão, supra n. 17.
W. van Meurs, The next Europe: South-Eastern Europe After Thessaloniki, 6(3) J. Labour & Soc. Aff. Eastern Europe 9–16 (2003); B. J. Gippert, The Interaction Between Local and International Power in EU Police Reform in Bosnia and Herzegovina, 39(1) Contemp. Sec. Pol’y 51–71 (2018).
European Council, supra n. 1.
European Council, EU-Western Balkans Summit: Sofia Declaration, Sofia (17 May 2018).
D. Bechev, The EU and Dispute Settlement: The Case of the Macedonian Name Issue, 37(2) East Eur. Pol. & Soc. 698–717 (2023), doi: 10.1177/08883254221101905; Ilazi, supra n. 13.
V. Musliu, The Berlin Process for the Western Balkans. What Is in a Name? 2 J. Cross-Regional Dialogues 83–101 (2021), doi: 10.25518/2593-9483.172.
European Council, supra n. 1.
L. Lika, The impact of the Berlin Process on the Western Balkans, Working paper n° 5 Studio Europa Maastricht and Centre for European Research in Maastricht (CERiM), Maastricht 1–30 (2023).
A. Kulo & A. Novikau, The Open Balkan initiative: A Step Forward Towards European Integration or Running on Empty? J. Contemp. Eur. Stud. 1–13 (2023), doi: 10.1080/14782804.2023.2204422.
E. P. Joseph, Open Balkan(s) Is Not Just Unwise. It’s Dangerous, Balkan Insight (15 Jun. 2022).
A. Taylor, Rama: Open Balkan fulfilled Its Mission, Time to Focus on Berlin Process, Euractiv (3 Jul. 2023).
V. Vuksanovic, L. Steric & M. Bjelos, Public Perception of Serbian Foreign Policy in the Midst of the War in Ukraine, Western Balkans Security Barometer (Belgrade Centre for Security Policy 2022).
P. Bargués et al., Engagement Against All Odds? Navigating Member States’ Contestation of EU Policy on Kosovo, The International Spectator 1–20 (2024); International Crisis Group (ICG), Managing the Risks of Instability in the Western Balkans, Europe Report No. 265 (Brussels 7 Jul. 2022); F. Bislimi, Serbia’s Loyalty to Putin Threatens Renewed Conflict in the Heart of Europe, Euractiv (3 Mar. 2022).
A. Vasovic, Sanctions on Russia are Main Obstacle to Serbia’s EU Bid – PM Brnabic, Reuters (10 Feb. 2023); International Crisis Group (ICG), supra n. 31, at 12–13; S. Popovic, Serbia’s UN Vote Against Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine Decrypted, Euractiv (3 Mar. 2022).
M. Ruge, How to Kill Four Birds With One Stone: The West’s Foreign Policy Challenge in Serbia, European Council on Foreign Relations (26 Jan. 2023).
Ibid.
S. Keil, Enlargement Politics Based on Geopolitics? A Proposal for a Geopolitics-Driven Enlargement Policy, in A Year Later: War in Ukraine and Western Balkan (Geo)Politics 117–124 (J. Dzankic, S. Kacarska & S. Keil eds, Bologna, European University Institute 2023).
M. Telo, The EU: A Civilian Power’s Diplomatic Action After the Lisbon Treaty. Bridging Internal Complexity and International Convergence, in The EU’s Foreign Policy. What Kind of Power and Diplomatic Action? 27–63 (M. Telo & F. Ponjaert eds, Farnham, Ashgate 2013); Keukeleire & Delreux, supra n. 15.
D. Dudley, European Union Membership Conditionality: The Copenhagen Criteria and the Quality of Democracy, 20(4) Southeast Eur. & Black Sea Stud. 525–545 (2020), doi: 10.1080/14683857.2020. 1805889.
O. Noyan, German Top Aide: No EU-Reform, No Enlargement, Euractiv (28 Nov. 2022).
M.-E. Bélanger & F. Schimmelfennig, Politicization and Rebordering in EU Enlargement: Membership Discourses in European Parliaments, 28(3) J. Eur. Pub. Pol’y 407–426 (2021), doi: 10.1080/13501763. 2021.1881584.
L. Boone quoted in T. Bourgery-Gonse, French Minister Says EU Enlargement Must Be Decided by Year’s End, Euractiv (15 May 2023).
C. Michel quoted in L. Bayer, Charles Michel: Get Ready by 2030 to Enlarge EU, Politico (28 Aug. 2023).
D. Spinant quoted in G. Sorgi, Commission Snubs Charles Michel’s. 2030 EU Enlargement Target, Politico (29 Aug. 2023).
M. Petrovic & N. Tzifakis, A Geopolitical Turn to EU Enlargement, or Another Postponement? An Introduction, 16(2) J. Contemp. Eur. Stud. 157–168 (2021), doi: 10.1080/14782804.2021.1891028; A. Hajrullahu, The Serbia Kosovo Dispute and the European Integration Perspective, 24(1) Eur. foreign Aff. Rev. 101–120 (2019), doi: 10.54648/EERR2019007.
Boone quoted in Bourgery-Gonse, supra n. 40.
Ibid.
Ibid.
The Group of Twelve, Sailing on High Seas: Reforming and Enlarging the EU for the 21st Century (Paris & Berlin 2023).
European Council, European Council Meeting (14 and 15 December 2023) – Conclusions, Brussels 15 Dec. 2023).
B. Stahl, Perverted Conditionality: The Stabilisation and Association Agreement Between the European Union and Serbia, 16(4) Eur. foreign Aff. Rev. 465–487 (2011), doi: 10.54648/EERR2011032.
Anghel & Dzankic, supra n. 5, at 488.
Z. Adzinbaia, EU Aspirations and Russian Realities: Georgia at the Geopolitical Crossroads, Atlantic Council (11 Jan. 2024).
European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document. Kosovo 2023 Report, Brussels, Communication on EU Enlargement Policy, COM(2023), 692 final (8 Nov. 2023).
European Council, supra n. 48, at 5.
Council of the European Union, Enlargement – Council Conclusions on North Macedonia and Albania, Brussels (18 Jul. 2022).
European Neighbourhood Policy and Enlargement Negotiations (DG NEAR), Screening Meetings Completed as Part of Screening Process With Albania and North Macedonia (8 Dec. 2023).
European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document. Montenegro 2023 Report, Brussels, Communication on EU Enlargement Policy, COM(2023) 694 final (8 Nov. 2023).
European Commission, Commission Staff Working Document. Serbia 2023 Report, Communication on EU Enlargement Policy, COM(2023) 695 final (8 Nov. 2023).
The Western Balkans in the World. Linkages and Relations With Non-Western Countries (F. Bieber & N. Tzifakis eds, London & New York, Routledge 2020).
A. Rrustemi et al., Geopolitical Influences of External Powers in the Western Balkans (The Hague Centre for Strategic Studies 2019).
M. Szpala, In the Foorsteps of Ukraine? Republika Srpska’s Challenge to Bosnia and Herzegovina. Future Scenarios (Barcelona, European Institute of the Mediterranean 2023).
J. Marovic, Montenegro: Always at a crossroads, in The Western Balkans in the World. Linkages and Relations With Non-Western Countries 146–163, at 147–149 (F. Bieber & N. Tzifakis eds, London & New York, Routledge 2020).
Keil, supra n. 35, at 119.
Manners, supra n. 4.
K. Raik et al., EU Policy Towards Ukraine: Entering Geopolitical Competition Over European Order, The International Spectator 1–20 (2024).
European External Action Service (EEAS), About EU Military Assistance Mission in Support of Ukraine (EUMAM Ukraine) (8 Dec. 2022), https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eumam-ukraine/about-eu-militaryassistance-mission-support-ukraine-eumam-ukraine_en?s=410260 (accessed 26 Jan. 2024).
S. Cvijic, Hungary’s Illiberal Infection of the Western Balkans, Politico (15 May 2018).
C. Griessler & F. Elek, Hungary, an Anti-role Model for Successful EU Integration? ÖGfE Policy Brief 14, Austrian Institute for International Affairs, Vienna, 1–8 (22 Oct. 2021).
Ibid.
A. Hoxhaj, The EU Rule of Law Initiative Towards the Western Balkans, 13 Hague J. Rule L. 143–172 (2021), doi: 10.1007/s40803-020-00148-w.
Cvijic, supra n. 66.
Griessler & Elek, supra n. 67.
Cvijic, supra n. 66.
Griessler & Elek, supra n. 67.
Hoxhaj, supra n. 69.
The Balkans in Europe Policy Advisory Group (BiEPAG), The Crisis of Democracy in the Western Balkans. Authoritarianism and EU Stabilitocracy (Graz 2017).
European External Action Service (EEAS), Belgrade–Pristina Dialogue: Agreement on the Path to Normalization Between Kosovo and Serbia (27 Feb. 2023), https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/belgradepristina-dialogue-agreement-path-normalisation-between-kosovo-and-serbia_en (accessed 26 Jan. 2024).
Ibid., Art. 4.
Ibid., Art. 1.
Ibid., Art. 7.
European Council, European Council Meeting (15 December 2022) – Conclusions (Brussels 15 Dec. 2022).
Directorate-General for Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations (DG NEAR), Commission Adopts 2023 Enlargement Package, Recommends to Open Negotiations With Ukraine and Moldova, to Grant Candidate Status to Georgia and to Open Accession Negotiations With BiH, Once the Necessary Degree of Compliance Is Achieved (Brussels 8 Nov. 2023).
Directorate-General for Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations (DG NEAR), Bosnia and Herzegovina Report 2022, Brussels (12 Oct. 2022).
Anghel & Dzankic, supra n. 5, at 488.
Directorate-General for Neighbourhood and Enlargement Negotiations (DG NEAR), European Commission Announces Additional €680 million Investment Package for the Western Balkans under the Economic and Investment Plan (13 Dec. 2023).
F. Bieber, The Rise of Authoritarianism in the Western Balkans (Cham, Palgrave Macmillan 2020); M. Nic, Balkan Troubles (Berlin Policy Journal 2017).
K. Morrison & V. Garcevic, The Orthodox Church, Montenegro, and the ‘Serbian World’ (Sarajevo, Atlantic Initiative 2023).
Ibid.
DW, Tensions in Montenegro Over Serbian Church Leaders (9 May 2021).
Morrison & Garcevic, supra n. 86; D. Sito-Sucic, Montenegro’s Parliament Passes No-confidence Motion on Cabinet, Reuters (20 Aug. 2022); RFE/RL’s Balkan Service, Montenegro Government Signs Controversial Agreement With Serbian Orthodox Church (3 Aug. 2022).
European Parliament, European Parliament Resolution of 19 October 2023 on the recent developments in the Serbia–Kosovo dialogue, including the situation in the northern municipalities in Kosovo, P9_TA(2023)0372 (Brussels, 19 Oct. 2023).
A. Beha, Disputes Over the 15-Point Agreement on Normalization of Relations Between Kosovo and Serbia, 43 (1) Nationalities Papers 1–20 (2015), doi: 10.1080/00905992.2014.990367; Kosovo Democratic Institute (KDI), 7 vite pas marrëveshjes së parë për normalizim: ku janë Kosova dhe Serbia me ‘normalizim’ sot? Prishtinë, Republic of Kosovo 1–14, at 9 (Apr. 2020).
L. O’Carroll & C. Bell-Davies, Macron and Scholz urge Kosovo to hold fresh elections to ease Serbia tensions, The Guardian (2 Jun. 2023).
X. Bami, EU Announces Measures Against Kosovo Over Unrest in North, Balkan Insight (14 Jun. 2023).
M. Dunai, EU hits Kosovo With sanctions After Serb Tensions Flare Up Again, Financial Times (14 Jun. 2023).
Kosovo’s Foreign Policy and Bilateral Relations (L. Lika ed., London & New York, Routledge 2023); D. Gashi & P. Kelmendi, The Dynamics of US–Kosovo Relations: An Investigation of Key Factors, in Kosovo’s Foreign Policy and Bilateral Relations 29–54 (L. Lika ed., London & New York, Routledge 2023).
RTK, Kurti: Masat e BE-së kundër Kosovës të padrejta (2 Jul. 2023).
L. O’Carroll, US and EU Leaders Urged to Change Tack on Kosovo–Serbia Tensions, The Guardian (8 Aug. 2023).
A. Kurti, Prime Minister Kurti’s Full Address at the Joint Press Conference With the Deputy General Director of the Kosova Police, Fehmi Hoti, Prime Minister Office, Prishtinë, Republic of Kosovo (24 Sep. 2023); European Parliament, supra n. 90.
Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Republic of Kosovo, Sveçla: Yesterday’s Attack in the North Was a Terrorist Organisation That Has Been Led and Ordered Directly by Official Belgrade, Prishtinë, Republic of Kosovo (9 Oct. 2023).
J. Dettmer, Kosovo attack: Who Benefits, Politico (2 Oct. 2023).
S. Marsh, Kosovo Says Serbia’s Behaviour Same as Russia’s Before Ukraine Invasion, Reuters (2 Oct. 2023).
European Parliament, supra n. 90.
B. Radeljic & C. R. Ozsahin, The Inefficiency of the EU Leverage in Serbia During the Russo-Ukranian War, Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 1–20 (2023).
Morrison & Garcevic, supra n. 86.
M. Suslov, Russian World Concept: Post-Soviet Geopolitical Ideology and the Logic of Spheres of Influence, 23 (2) Geopolitics 330–353 (2018), doi: 10.1080/14650045.2017.1407921.
S. Lynch, Kosovo Wants Back in EU Good Graces, Comeuppance for Serbia, Politico (24 Jan. 2024).
T. Reuten quoted in Euronews Albania, Dutch MEP: EU Must Stop Disastrous Appeasement of Vucic! (7 Oct. 2023).
