Predicting Long-Term Recovery of Consciousness in Prolonged Disorders of Consciousness Based on Coma Recovery Scale-Revised Subscores: Validation of a Machine Learning-Based Prognostic Index.
coma recovery scale-revised; disorders of consciousness; machine learning; prognosis; rehabilitation; General Neuroscience
Abstract :
[en] Prognosis of prolonged Disorders of Consciousness (pDoC) is influenced by patients' clinical diagnosis and Coma Recovery Scale-Revised (CRS-R) total score. We compared the prognostic accuracy of a novel Consciousness Domain Index (CDI) with that of clinical diagnosis and CRS-R total score, for recovery of full consciousness at 6-, 12-, and 24-months post-injury. The CDI was obtained by a combination of the six CRS-R subscales via an unsupervised machine learning technique. We retrospectively analyzed data on 143 patients with pDoC (75 in Minimally Conscious State; 102 males; median age = 53 years; IQR = 35; time post-injury = 1-3 months) due to different etiologies enrolled in an International Brain Injury Association Disorders of Consciousness Special Interest Group (IBIA DoC-SIG) multicenter longitudinal study. Univariate and multivariate analyses were utilized to assess the association between outcomes and the CDI, compared to clinical diagnosis and CRS-R. The CDI, the clinical diagnosis, and the CRS-R total score were significantly associated with a good outcome at 6, 12 and 24 months. The CDI showed the highest univariate prediction accuracy and sensitivity, and regression models including the CDI provided the highest values of explained variance. A combined scoring system of the CRS-R subscales by unsupervised machine learning may improve clinical ability to predict recovery of consciousness in patients with pDoC.
Disciplines :
Neurosciences & behavior
Author, co-author :
Magliacano, Alfonso ; IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi ONLUS, 50143 Firenze, Italy ; Polo Specialistico Riabilitativo, Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi, 83054 Sant'Angelo dei Lombardi, Italy
Liuzzi, Piergiuseppe ; IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi ONLUS, 50143 Firenze, Italy ; Scuola Superiore Sant'Anna, Istituto di BioRobotica, 56025 Pontedera, Italy
Formisano, Rita ; Fondazione Santa Lucia IRCCS, 00179 Rome, Italy
Grippo, Antonello ; IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi ONLUS, 50143 Firenze, Italy
Angelakis, Efthymios; Neurosurgery Department, University of Athens Medical School, 11527 Athens, Greece
Thibaut, Aurore ; Université de Liège - ULiège > GIGA > GIGA Consciousness - Coma Science Group
Gosseries, Olivia ; Université de Liège - ULiège > GIGA > GIGA Consciousness - Coma Science Group
Lamberti, Gianfranco ; Neurorehabilitation and Vegetative State Unit E. Viglietta, 12100 Cuneo, Italy
Bagnato, Sergio ; Unit of Neurophysiology and Unit for Severe Acquired Brain Injuries, Rehabilitation Department, Giuseppe Giglio Foundation, 90015 Cefalù, Italy
Edlow, Brian L ; Center for Neurotechnology and Neurorecovery, Department of Neurology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA 02114, USA
Lejeune, Nicolas ; Université de Liège - ULiège > GIGA > GIGA Consciousness - Coma Science Group ; CHN William Lennox, 1340 Ottignies, Belgium
Veeramuthu, Vigneswaran ; Division of Clinical Neuropsychology, Thomson Hospital Kota Damansara, Petaling Jaya 47810, Malaysia
Trojano, Luigi ; Department of Psychology, University of Campania L. Vanvitelli, 81100 Caserta, Italy
Zasler, Nathan; Concussion Care Centre of Virginia, Ltd., Richmond, VA 23233, USA
Schnakers, Caroline ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Unités de recherche interfacultaires > GIGA-CRC In vivo Imaging (Centre de Recherche du Cyclotron) ; Research Institute, Casa Colina Hospital and Centers for Healthcare, Pomona, CA 91767, USA
Bartolo, Michelangelo; Neurorehabilitation Unit, HABILITA Zingonia/Ciserano, 24040 Bergamo, Italy
Mannini, Andrea ; IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi ONLUS, 50143 Firenze, Italy
Estraneo, Anna; IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi ONLUS, 50143 Firenze, Italy ; Polo Specialistico Riabilitativo, Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi, 83054 Sant'Angelo dei Lombardi, Italy
Predicting Long-Term Recovery of Consciousness in Prolonged Disorders of Consciousness Based on Coma Recovery Scale-Revised Subscores: Validation of a Machine Learning-Based Prognostic Index.
Giacino J.T. Katz D.I. Schiff N.D. Whyte J. Ashman E.J. Ashwal S. Barbano R. Hammond F.M. Laureys S. Ling G.S.F. et al. Practice guideline update recommendations summary: Disorders of consciousness: Report of the Guideline Development, Dissemination, and Implementation Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology; the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine; and the National Institute on Disability, Independent Living, and Rehabilitation Research Neurology 2018 91 450 460 10.1212/wnl.0000000000005926
Kondziella D. Bender A. Diserens K. van Erp W. Estraneo A. Formisano R. Laureys S. Naccache L. Ozturk S. Rohaut B. et al. European Academy of Neurology guideline on the diagnosis of coma and other disorders of consciousness Eur. J. Neurol. 2020 27 741 756 10.1111/ene.14151
Laureys S. Celesia G.G. Cohadon F. Lavrijsen J. León-Carrión J. Sannita W.G. Sazbon L. Schmutzhard E. Von Wild K.R. Zeman A. et al. Unresponsive wakefulness syndrome: A new name for the vegetative state or apallic syndrome BMC Med. 2010 8 68 10.1186/1741-7015-8-68
Giacino J.T. Ashwal S. Childs N. Cranford R. Jennett B. Katz D.I. Kelly J.P. Rosenberg J.H. Whyte J. Zafonte R.D. et al. The minimally conscious state: Definition and diagnostic criteria Neurology 2002 58 349 353 10.1212/WNL.58.3.349
Sattin D. Morganti L. De Torres L. Dolce G. Arcuri F. Estraneo A. Cardinale V. Piperno R. Zavatta E. Formisano R. et al. Care pathways models and clinical outcomes in Disorders of consciousness Brain Behav. 2017 7 e00740 10.1002/brb3.740
Estraneo A. Masotta O. Bartolo M. Pistoia F. Perin C. Marino S. Lucca L. Pingue V. Casanova E. Romoli A. et al. Multi-center study on overall clinical complexity of patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness of different etiologies Brain Inj. 2021 35 1 7 10.1080/02699052.2020.1861652
Fins J.J. Bernat J.L. Ethical, palliative, and policy considerations in disorders of consciousness Neurology 2018 91 471 475 10.1212/WNL.0000000000005927
Estraneo A. Moretta P. Loreto V. Lanzillo B. Cozzolino A. Saltalamacchia A. Lullo F. Santoro L. Trojano L. Predictors of recovery of responsiveness in prolonged anoxic vegetative state Neurology 2013 80 464 470 10.1212/WNL.0b013e31827f0f31
Estraneo A. Trojano L. Prognosis in disorders of consciousness Coma and Disorders of Consciousness Schnakers C. Springer Cham, Switzerland 2018 17 36
Thibaut A. Schiff N. Giacino J. Laureys S. Gosseries O. Therapeutic interventions in patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness Lancet Neurol. 2019 18 600 614 10.1016/S1474-4422(19)30031-6
Feng Y. Zhang J. Zhou Y. Bai Z. Yin Y. Noninvasive brain stimulation for patients with a disorder of consciousness: A systematic review and meta-analysis Rev. Neurosci. 2020 31 905 914 10.1515/revneuro-2020-0033
Giacino J.T. Kalmar K. Whyte J. The JFK Coma Recovery Scale-Revised: Measurement characteristics and diagnostic utility Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2004 85 2020 2029 10.1016/j.apmr.2004.02.033 15605342
Estraneo A. De Bellis F. Masotta O. Loreto V. Fiorenza S. Sapio M.L. Trojano L. Demographical and clinical indices for long-term evolution of patients in vegetative or in minimally conscious state Brain Inj. 2019 33 1633 1639 10.1080/02699052.2019.1658220 31533482
Estraneo A. Fiorenza S. Magliacano A. Formisano R. Mattia D. Grippo A. Romoli A.M. Angelakis E. Cassol H. Thibaut A. et al. Multicenter prospective study on predictors of short-term outcome in disorders of consciousness Neurology 2020 95 e1488 e1499 10.1212/WNL.0000000000010254 32661102
Estraneo A. Magliacano A. Fiorenza S. Formisano R. Grippo A. Angelakis E. Cassol H. Thibaut A. Gosseries O. Lamberti G. et al. Risk factors for 2-year mortality in patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness: An international multicentre study Eur. J. Neurol. 2022 29 390 399 10.1111/ene.15143 34657359
Portaccio E. Morrocchesi A. Romoli A.M. Hakiki B. Taglioli M.P. Lippi E. Di Renzone M. Grippo A. Macchi C. Score on Coma Recovery Scale-Revised at admission predicts outcome at discharge in intensive rehabilitation after severe brain injury Brain Inj. 2018 32 730 734 10.1080/02699052.2018.1440420 29482376
Seel R.T. Sherer M. Whyte J. Katz D.I. Giacino J.T. Rosenbaum A.M. Hammond F.M. Kalmar K. Pape T.L.-B. Zafonte R. et al. Assessment Scales for Disorders of Consciousness: Evidence-Based Recommendations for Clinical Practice and Research Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2010 91 1795 1813 10.1016/j.apmr.2010.07.218
Annen J. Filippini M.M. Bonin E. Cassol H. Aubinet C. Carrière M. Gosseries O. Thibaut A. Barra A. Wolff A. et al. Diagnostic accuracy of the CRS-R index in patients with disorders of consciousness Brain Inj. 2019 33 1409 1412 10.1080/02699052.2019.1644376
Liuzzi P. De Bellis F. Magliacano A. Estraneo A. Mannini A. Consciousness-Domain Index: A data-driven clustering-based consciousness labeling Annu. Int. Conf. IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Soc. 2022 2022 1062 1065 10.1109/embc48229.2022.9871151
Halkidi M. Batistakis Y. Vazirgiannis M. On Clustering Validation Techniques J. Intell. Inf. Syst. 2001 17 107 145 10.1023/A:1012801612483
Bodien Y.G. Carlowicz C.A. Chatelle C. Giacino J.T. Sensitivity and Specificity of the Coma Recovery Scale–Revised Total Score in Detection of Conscious Awareness Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2016 97 490 492 10.1016/j.apmr.2015.08.422
Estraneo A. Moretta P. De Tanti A. Gatta G. Giacino J.T. Trojano L. An Italian multicentre validation study of the coma recovery scale-revised Eur. J. Phys. Rehabil. Med. 2015 51 627 634
Ramspek C.L. Jager K.J. Dekker F.W. Zoccali C. van Diepen M. External validation of prognostic models: What, why, how, when and where? Clin. Kidney J. 2020 14 49 58 10.1093/ckj/sfaa188
Cabitza F. Campagner A. Soares F. de Guadiana-Romualdo L.G. Challa F. Sulejmani A. Seghezzi M. Carobene A. The importance of being external. methodological insights for the external validation of machine learning models in medicine Comput. Methods Programs Biomed. 2021 208 106288 10.1016/j.cmpb.2021.106288
Baricich A. Recovery from vegetative state of patients with a severe brain injury: A 4-year real-practice prospective cohort study Funct. Neurol. 2017 32 131 136 10.11138/FNeur/2017.32.3.131
Mosenthal A.C. Lavery R.F. Addis M. Kaul S. Ross S. Marburger R. Deitch E.A. Livingston D.H. Isolated Traumatic Brain Injury: Age Is an Independent Predictor of Mortality and Early Outcome J. Trauma 2002 52 907 911 10.1097/00005373-200205000-00015
Gutchess A. Plasticity of the aging brain: New directions in cognitive neuroscience Science 2014 346 579 582 10.1126/science.1254604
Chen H. Epstein J. Stern E. Neural Plasticity After Acquired Brain Injury: Evidence from Functional Neuroimaging PMR 2010 2 S306 S312 10.1016/j.pmrj.2010.10.006
Mikolic A. Groeniger J.O. Zeldovich M. Wilson L. van Lennep J.E.R. van Klaveren D. Polinder S. Åkerlund C. Amrein K. Andreassen L. et al. Explaining Outcome Differences between Men and Women following Mild Traumatic Brain Injury J. Neurotrauma 2021 38 3315 3331 10.1089/neu.2021.0116
Moretta P. Estraneo A. De Lucia L. Cardinale V. Loreto V. Trojano L. A study of the psychological distress in family caregivers of patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness during in-hospital rehabilitation Clin. Rehabil. 2014 28 717 725 10.1177/0269215514521826
D’Ippolito M. Aloisi M. Azicnuda E. Silvestro D. Giustini M. Verni F. Formisano R. Bivona U. Changes in Caregivers Lifestyle after Severe Acquired Brain Injury: A Preliminary Investigation BioMed Res. Int. 2018 2018 2824081 10.1155/2018/2824081
Formisano R. Azicnuda E. Sefid M.K. Zampolini M. Scarponi F. Avesani R. Early rehabilitation: Benefits in patients with severe acquired brain injury Neurol. Sci. 2017 38 181 184 10.1007/s10072-016-2724-5
Formisano R. Contrada M. Aloisi M. Buzzi M.G. Cicinelli P. Della Vedova C. Laurenza L. Matteis M. Spanedda F. Vinicola V. et al. Improvement rate of patients with severe brain injury during post-acute intensive rehabilitation Neurol. Sci. 2018 39 753 755 10.1007/s10072-017-3203-3
Schnakers C. Hirsch M. Noé E. Llorens R. Lejeune N. Veeramuthu V. De Marco S. Demertzi A. Duclos C. Morrissey A.-M. et al. Covert Cognition in Disorders of Consciousness: A Meta-Analysis Brain Sci. 2020 10 930 10.3390/brainsci10120930
Estraneo A. Loreto V. Masotta P.O. Pascarella A. Trojano L. Do Medical Complications Impact Long-Term Outcomes in Prolonged Disorders of Consciousness? Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2018 99 2523 2531.e3 10.1016/j.apmr.2018.04.024
Liuzzi P. Magliacano A. De Bellis F. Mannini A. Estraneo A. Predicting outcome of patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness using machine learning models based on medical complexity Sci. Rep. 2022 12 13471 10.1038/s41598-022-17561-w