Bacteriological Techniques/instrumentation; Bronchoscopes; Bronchoscopy/methods; Colony Count, Microbial; Cross Infection/diagnosis; Diagnosis, Differential; Humans; Pneumonia/diagnosis; Pneumonia/microbiology; Prospective Studies; Reproducibility of Results; Sensitivity and Specificity; Specimen Handling/instrumentation; Specimen Handling/methods; Intensive Care Units; Pulmonary and Respiratory Medicine; Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine; Cardiology and Cardiovascular Medicine
Abstract :
[en] UNLABELLED: Protected specimen brush (PSB) is considered to be one of the standard methods for the diagnosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia, but to our knowledge, intraindividual variability in results has not been reported previously.
PURPOSE: To compare the results of two PSB performed in the same subsegment on patients with suspected ICU-acquired pneumonia (IAP).
STUDY DESIGN: Between October 1991 and April 1992, each mechanically ventilated patient with suspected IAP underwent bronchoscopy with two successive PSB in the lung segment identified as abnormal on radiographs. Results of the two PSB cultures were compared using 10(3) cfu/ml cutoff for a positive result. Four definite diagnoses were established during the follow up: definite pneumonia, probable pneumonia, excluded pneumonia, and uncertain pneumonia.
POPULATION: Forty-two episodes in 26 patients were studied; 60 percent of patients received prior antibiotic therapy. Thirty-two microorganisms were isolated from 24 pairs of PSB. Definite diagnosis was definite pneumonia in 7, probable pneumonia in 8, excluded pneumonia in 17, and uncertain pneumonia in 10 cases.
RESULTS: The PSB recovered the same microorganisms and argued for a good qualitative reproducibility. The distinction of positive and negative results on the basis of the 10(3) cfu/ml classic threshold was less reproducible. For 24 percent of the microorganisms recovered and in 16.7 percent of episodes of suspected IAP, the two consecutive samples gave results spread out on each side of the 10(3) cfu/ml cutoff. Discordance was higher when definite diagnosis was certain or probable than when diagnosis was excluded (p = 0.015). There was no statistical effect of the order of samples between the two specimens for bacterial index and microorganism concentrations.
CONCLUSION: These findings argue for the poor repeatability of PSB in suspected IAP and question the yield of the 10(3) cfu/ml threshold. In attempting to diagnose IAP, the results of PSB must be interpreted with caution considering the intraindividual variability.
Disciplines :
Anesthesia & intensive care
Author, co-author :
Timsit, Jean-François; Intensive Care Unit, Hôpital Saint Joseph, Paris, France
Misset, Benoît ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > > Service des soins intensifs ; Intensive Care Unit, Hopital Saint Joseph, Paris, France
Francoual, Serge; Intensive Care Unit, Hopital Saint Joseph, Paris, France
Goldstein, Fred William; Intensive Care Unit, Hopital Saint Joseph, Paris, France
Vaury, Philippe; Intensive Care Unit, Hopital Saint Joseph, Paris, France
Carlet, Jean; Intensive Care Unit, Hopital Saint Joseph, Paris, France
Language :
English
Title :
Is protected specimen brush a reproducible method to diagnose ICU-acquired pneumonia?
JY Fagon J Chastre Y Domart JL Trouillet J Pierre P Darne Nosocomial pneumonia in patients receiving continuous mechanical ventilation: prospective analysis of 52 episodes with use of the protected specimen brush and quantitative culture technique Am Rev Respir Dis 139 1989 877 884
FR De Castro J Solé Violan B Lafarga Capuz J Caminero Luna B Gonzalez Rodriguez JL Manzano Alonzo Reliability of the bronchoscopic protected catheter brush in the diagnosis of pneumonia in mechanically ventilated patients Crit Care Med 19 1991 171 175
JY Fagon J Chastre A Hance M Guiguet JL Trouillet Y Domart Detection of nosocomial lung infection in ventilated patients: use of protected specimen brush and quantitative culture techniques in 147 patients Am Rev Respir Dis 138 1988 110 116
A Torres J Puig De La Becasa A Xaubet R Rodriguez-Roisin MT Jimenez De Anta A Agusti Vidal Diagnostic value of quantitative cultures of bronchoalveolar lavage and telescoping plugged catheters in mechanically ventilated patients with bacterial pneumonia Am Rev Respir Dis 140 1989 306 310
WG Johanson AK Pierce JP Sandford GD Thomas Nosocomial respiratory infection with Gram negative bacilli: the significance of colonization of the respiratory tract Ann Intern Med 77 1972 701 706
NW Wimberley JB Bass BW Boyd MB Kirkpatrick RA Serio HM Pollok Use of a bronchoscopic catheter brush for the diagnosis of pulmonary infections Chest 81 1982 556 562
WG Johanson JJ Seidenfeld P Gomez R De Los Santos JJ Coalson Bacteriologic diagnosis of nosocomial pneumonia following prolonged mechanical ventilation Am Rev Respir Dis 137 1988 259 264
J Chastre F Viau P Brun J Pierre MC Dauge A Bouchama Prospective evaluation of the protected specimen brush for the diagnosis of pneumonia in ventilated patients Am Rev Respir Dis 130 1984 924 929
N Wimberley LJ Falling JG Bartlett A fiberoptic bronchoscopy technique to obtain uncontaminated lower airway secretions for bacterial culture Am Rev Respir Dis 119 1979 337 343
RP Baughman JE Thorpe J Staneck M Rashkin PT Frame Use of the protected specimen brush in patients with endotracheal or tracheostomy tubes Chest 91 1987 233 236
