2020_Fonteyn et al._RESC_Wildlife trail or systematic_Camera trap placement has little effect on estimates of mammal diversity in a tropical forest in Gabon.pdf
Camera placement; Wildlife monitoring; Occupancy modelling; Detection probability; Diversity; Composition
Abstract :
[en] Camera traps (CTs) have been increasingly used for wildlife monitoring worldwide. In the tropics, most CT inventories target wildlife‐friendly sites, and CTs are commonly placed towards wildlife trails. However, it has been argued that this placement strategy potentially provides biased results in comparison to more systematic or randomized approaches. Here, we investigated the impact of CT placement on the remotely sensed mammal diversity in a tropical forest in Gabon by comparing pairs of systematically placed and wildlife‐trail‐oriented CTs. Our survey protocol consisted of 15–17 sampling points arranged on a 2 km2 grid and left for one month in the field. This protocol was replicated sequentially in four areas. Each sampling point comprised a CT pair: the ‘systematic CT’, installed at the theoretical point and systematically oriented towards the most uncluttered view; and the ‘trail CT’, placed within a 20‐m radius and facing a wildlife trail. For the vast majority of species, the detection probabilities were comparable between placements. Species average capture rates were slightly higher for trail‐based CTs, though this trend was not significant for any species. Therefore, the species richness and composition of the overall community, such as the spatial distribution patterns (from evenly spread to site‐restricted) of individual species, were similarly depicted by both placements. Opting for a systematic orientation ensures that pathways used preferentially by some species—and avoided by others—will be sampled proportionally to their density in the forest undergrowth. However, trail‐based placement is routinely used, already producing standardised data within large‐scale monitoring programmes. Here, both placements provided a comparable picture of the mammal community, though it might not be necessarily true in depauperate areas. Both types of CT data can nevertheless be combined in multi‐site analyses, since methods now allow accounting for differences in study design and detection bias in original CT data.
Disciplines :
Environmental sciences & ecology
Author, co-author :
Fonteyn, Davy ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département GxABT > Gestion des ressources forestières et des milieux naturels
Vermeulen, Cédric ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département GxABT > Laboratoire de Foresterie des régions trop. et subtropicales
Deflandre, Nicolas; Precious Woods Gabon-CEB. BP 2262. Libreville, Gabon.
Cornelis, Daniel; CIRAD, UPR Forêts et Sociétés, Université Montpellier, Campus de Baillarguet, Montpellier Cedex 5, France
Lhoest, Simon ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département GxABT > Gestion des ressources forestières et des milieux naturels
Abernethy, K.A., Coad, L., Taylor, G., Lee, M.E. & Maisels, F. (2013) Extent and ecological consequences of hunting in Central African rainforests in the twenty-first century. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 368, 20120303.
Agha, M., Batter, T., Bolas, E.C., Collins, A.C., Gomes da Rocha, D., Monteza-Moreno, C.M. et al. (2018) A review of wildlife camera trapping trends across Africa. African Journal of Ecology, 56, 694–701.
Ahumada, J.A., Hurtado, J. & Lizcano, D. (2013) Monitoring the status and trends of tropical forest terrestrial vertebrate communities from camera trap data: a tool for conservation. PLoS One, 8, e73707.
Bahaa-el-din, L., Sollmann, R., Hunter, L.T.B., Slotow, R., Macdonald, D.W. & Henschel, P. (2016) Effects of human land-use on Africa’s only forest-dependent felid: The African golden cat Caracal aurata. Biological Conservation, 199, 1–9.
Benítez-López, A., Santini, L., Schipper, A.M., Busana, M. & Huijbregts, M.A. (2019) Intact but empty forests? Patterns of hunting-induced mammal defaunation in the tropics. PLoS Biology, 17, e3000247.
Bessone, M., Kühl, H.S., Hohmann, G., Herbinger, I., N’Goran, K.P., Asanzi, P. et al. (2020) Drawn out of the shadows: Surveying secretive forest species with camera trap distance sampling. Journal of Applied Ecology, 57, 963–974.
Blake, J.G. & Mosquera, D. (2014) Camera trapping on and off trails in lowland forest of eastern Ecuador: does location matter? Mastozool Neotropical, 21, 17–26.
Broadley, K., Burton, A.C., Avgar, T. & Boutin, S. (2019) Density-dependent space use affects interpretation of camera trap detection rates. Ecology and Evolution, 9, 14031–14041.
Burnham, K.P. & Anderson, D.R. (2004) Multimodel inference: understanding AIC and BIC in model selection. Sociological Methods and Research, 33, 261–304.
Burton, A.C., Neilson, E., Moreira, D., Ladle, A., Steenweg, R., Fisher, J.T. et al. (2015) Wildlife camera trapping: a review and recommendations for linking surveys to ecological processes. Journal of Applied Ecology, 3, 675–685.
Cappelle, N., Després-Einspenner, M.-L., Howe, E.J., Boesch, C. & Kühl, H.S. (2019) Validating camera trap distance sampling for chimpanzees. American Journal of Primatology, 81, e22962.
Carbone, C., Cowlishaw, G., Isaac, N.J. & Rowcliffe, J.M. (2005) How far do animals go? Determinants of day range in mammals. American Naturalist, 165, 290–297.
Ceballos, G., Ehrlich, P.R. & Dirzo, R. (2017) Biological annihilation via the ongoing sixth mass extinction signaled by vertebrate population losses and declines. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114, E6089–E6096.
Collen, B., Loh, J., Whitmee, S., McRAE, L., Amin, R. & Baillie, J.E.M. (2009) Monitoring change in vertebrate abundance: the Living planet index. Conservation Biology, 23, 317–327.
Craigie, I.D., Baillie, J.E.M., Balmford, A., Carbone, C., Collen, B., Green, R.E. et al. (2010) Large mammal population declines in Africa’s protected areas. Biological Conservation, 143, 2221–2228.
Cusack, J.J., Dickman, A.J., Rowcliffe, J.M., Carbone, C., Macdonald, D.W. & Coulson, T. (2015a) Random versus game trail-based camera trap placement strategy for monitoring terrestrial mammal communities. PLoS One, 10, e0126373.
Cusack, J.J., Swanson, A., Coulson, T., Packer, C., Carbone, C., Dickman, A.J. et al. (2015b) Applying a random encounter model to estimate lion density from camera traps in Serengeti National Park, Tanzania. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 79, 1014–1021.
Di Bitetti, M.S., Paviolo, A. & De Angelo, C. (2014) Camera trap photographic rates on roads vs. off roads: location does matter. Mastozool Neotropical, 21, 37–46.
Dirzo, R., Young, H.S., Galetti, M., Ceballos, G., Isaac, N.J.B. & Collen, B. (2014) Defaunation in the Anthropocene. Science, 345, 401–406.
Edwards, D.P., Socolar, J.B., Mills, S.C., Burivalova, Z., Koh, L.P. & Wilcove, D.S. (2019) Conservation of tropical forests in the anthropocene. Current Biology, 29, R1008–R1020.
Edwards, D.P., Tobias, J.A., Sheil, D., Meijaard, E. & Laurance, W.F. (2014) Maintaining ecosystem function and services in logged tropical forests. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 29, 511–520.
Fick, S.E. & Hijmans, R.J. (2017) WorldClim 2: new 1-km spatial resolution climate surfaces for global land areas. International Journal of Climatology, 37, 4302–4315.
Forrester, T., O’Brien, T., Fegraus, E., Jansen, P.A., Palmer, J., Kays, R. et al. (2016) An open standard for camera trap data. Biodiversity Data Journal, 4, e10197.
Foster, R.J. & Harmsen, B.J. (2012) A critique of density estimation from camera-trap data. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 76, 224–236.
Gillet, P., Vermeulen, C., Feintrenie, L., Dessard, H. & Garcia, C. (2016) Quelles sont les causes de la déforestation dans le bassin du Congo ? Synthèse bibliographique et études de cas. Biotechnologie, Agronomie, Societe et Environnement, 20, 183–194.
Gogarten, J.F., Hoffmann, C., Arandjelovic, M., Sachse, A., Merkel, K., Dieguez, P. et al. (2020) Fly-derived DNA and camera traps are complementary tools for assessing mammalian biodiversity. Environmental DNA, 2, 63–76.
Gray, T.N.E. (2018) Monitoring tropical forest ungulates using camera-trap data. Journal of Zoology, 305, 173–179.
Hansen, M.C., Potapov, P.V., Moore, R., Hancher, M., Turubanova, S.A., Tyukavina, A., et al. (2013). High-resolution global maps of 21st-century forest cover change. Science 342, 850–853.
Harmsen, B.J., Foster, R.J., Silver, S., Ostro, L. & Doncaster, C.P. (2010) Differential use of trails by forest mammals and the implications for camera-trap studies: a case study from Belize. Biotropica, 42, 126–133.
Hedwig, D., Kienast, I., Bonnet, M., Curran, B.K., Courage, A., Boesch, C. et al. (2018) A camera trap assessment of the forest mammal community within the transitional savannah-forest mosaic of the Batéké Plateau National Park, Gabon. African Journal of Ecology, 56, 777–790.
Heinrich, S., Wittman, T.A., Ross, J.V., Shepherd, C.R., Challender, D.W.S. & Cassey, P. (2017). The global trafficking of pangolins: A comprehensive summary of seizures and trafficking routes from 2010–2015.
Henschel, P., Malanda, G.-A. & Hunter, L. (2014) The status of savanna carnivores in the Odzala-Kokoua National Park, northern Republic of Congo. Journal of Mammalogy, 95, 882–892.
Hoffmann, M., Hilton-Taylor, C., Angulo, A., Böhm, M., Brooks, T.M., Butchart, S.H.M. et al. (2010) The impact of conservation on the status of the World’s vertebrates. Science, 330, 1503–1509.
Hofmeester, T.R., Cromsigt, J.P., Odden, J., Andrén, H., Kindberg, J. & Linnell, J.D. (2019) Framing pictures: A conceptual framework to identify and correct for biases in detection probability of camera traps enabling multi-species comparison. Ecology and Evolution, 9, 2320–2336.
Hofmeester, T.R., Rowcliffe, J.M. & Jansen, P.A. (2017) A simple method for estimating the effective detection distance of camera traps. Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation, 3, 81–89.
Howe, E.J., Buckland, S.T., Després-Einspenner, M.-L. & Kühl, H.S. (2017) Distance sampling with camera traps. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 8, 1558–1565.
Hurvich, C.M. & Tsai, C.-L. (1995) Model selection for extended quasi-likelihood models in small samples. Biometrics, 53, 1077–1084.
Jansen, P.A., Ahumada, J., Fegraus, E. & O’Brien, T. (2014) TEAM: a standardised camera trap survey to monitor terrestrial vertebrate communities in tropical forests. Camera Trapping: Wildlife Management and Research. Collingwood, Australia: Csiro Publishing, pp. 263–270.
Julliard, R., Clavel, J., Devictor, V., Jiguet, F. & Couvet, D. (2006) Spatial segregation of specialists and generalists in bird communities. Ecology Letters, 9, 1237–1244.
Kays, R., Kranstauber, B., Jansen, P., Carbone, C., Rowcliffe, M., Fountain, T. et al. (2009) IEEE 34th Conference on Local Computer Networks (LCN 2009). Zurich, Switzerland: IEEE, pp. 811–818.
Kleinschroth, F., Laporte, N., Laurance, W.F., Goetz, S.J. & Ghazoul, J. (2019) Road expansion and persistence in forests of the Congo Basin. Nature Sustainability, 2, 628–634.
Kolowski, J.M. & Forrester, T.D. (2017) Camera trap placement and the potential for bias due to trails and other features. PLoS One, 12, e0186679.
Lhoest, S., Fonteyn, D., Daïnou, K., Delbeke, L., Doucet, J.-L., Dufrêne, M. et al. (2020) Conservation value of tropical forests: Distance to human settlements matters more than management in Central Africa. Biological Conservation, 241, 108351.
MacKenzie, D. & Hines, J. (2018). RPresence: R Interface for Program PRESENCE.
MacKenzie, D.I., Nichols, J.D., Royle, J.A., Pollock, K.H., Bailey, L. & Hines, J.E. (2017) Occupancy estimation and modeling: inferring patterns and dynamics of species occurrence, 2nd. ed. edition. London, UK: Academic Press.
Maisels, F., Strindberg, S., Blake, S., Wittemyer, G., Hart, J., Williamson, E.A. et al. (2013) Devastating decline of forest elephants in Central Africa. PLoS One, 8, e59469.
Malhi, Y., Gardner, T.A., Goldsmith, G.R., Silman, M.R. & Zelazowski, P. (2014) Tropical forests in the Anthropocene. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 39, 125–159.
Mambeya, M.M., Baker, F., Momboua, B.R., Koumba Pambo, A.F., Hega, M., Okouyi Okouyi, V.J. et al. (2018) The emergence of a commercial trade in pangolins from Gabon. African Journal of Ecology, 56, 601–609.
Mann, G.K.H., O’Riain, M.J. & Parker, D.M. (2015) The road less travelled: assessing variation in mammal detection probabilities with camera traps in a semi-arid biodiversity hotspot. Biodiversity and Conservation, 24, 531–545.
Meek, P.D., Ballard, G., Claridge, A., Kays, R., Moseby, K., O’brien, T., et al. (2014) Recommended guiding principles for reporting on camera trapping research. Biodiversity and Conservation, 23, 2321–2343.
Mittermeier, R.A., Rylands, A.B. & Wilson, D.E. (Eds.) (2013). Handbook of the Mammals of the World. Vol. 3. Primates, Lynx Edicions. ed. Barcelona, Spain.
Moore, H.A., Valentine, L.E., Dunlop, J.A. & Nimmo, D.G. (2020) The effect of camera orientation on the detectability of wildlife: a case study from north-western Australia. Conserv: Remote Sens. Ecol.
Nakashima, Y., Hongo, S. & Akomo-Okoue, E.F. (2020) Landscape-scale estimation of forest ungulate density and biomass using camera traps: Applying the REST model. Biological Conservation, 241, 108381.
Nichols, J.D., Bailey, L.L., O’Connell, A.F. Jr, Talancy, N.W., Campbell Grant, E.H., Gilbert, A.T. et al. (2008) Multi-scale occupancy estimation and modelling using multiple detection methods. Journal of Applied Ecology, 45, 1321–1329.
Niedballa, J., Sollmann, R., Courtiol, A. & Wilting, A. (2016) camtrapR: an R package for efficient camera trap data management. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 7, 1457–1462.
Noss, A.J., Cuéllar, R.L., Barrientos, J., Maffei, L., Cuéllar, E., Arispe, R. et al. (2003) A camera trapping and radio telemetry study of lowland tapir (Tapirus terrestris) in Bolivian dry forests. Tapirus Conservation, 12, 24–32.
O’Brien, T.G. (2011) Abundance, density and relative abundance: a conceptual framework. Camera Traps in Animal Ecology. Springer, 71–96.
Oksanen, J., Blanchet, F.G., Friendly, M., Kindt, R., Legendre, P. & McGlinn, D. et al. 2019. Vegan: Community ecology package. 2018.
Precious Woods - CEB, (2018) Rapport annuel 2018. Suivi-Évaluation des indicateurs de performance environnementale CFAD Precious Woods -CEB.
Putz, F.E., Zuidema, P.A., Synnott, T., Peña-Claros, M., Pinard, M.A., Sheil, D. et al. (2012) Sustaining conservation values in selectively logged tropical forests: the attained and the attainable. Conservation Letters, 5, 296–303.others
R Core Team, 2017. R: A language and environment for statistical computing.
Rovero, F. & Marshall, A.R. (2009) Camera trapping photographic rate as an index of density in forest ungulates. Journal of Applied Ecology, 46, 1011–1017.
Rovero, F., Zimmermann, F., Berzi, D. & Meek, P. (2013) “ Which camera trap type and how many do I need?” A review of camera features and study designs for a range of wildlife research applications. Hystrix, 24, 148–156.
Rowcliffe, J.M., Carbone, C., Jansen, P.A., Kays, R. & Kranstauber, B. (2011) Quantifying the sensitivity of camera traps: an adapted distance sampling approach. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 2, 464–476.
Rowcliffe, J.M., Field, J., Turvey, S.T. & Carbone, C. (2008) Estimating animal density using camera traps without the need for individual recognition. Journal of Applied Ecology, 45, 1228–1236.
Rowcliffe, J.M., Jansen, P.A., Kays, R., Kranstauber, B. & Carbone, C. (2016) Wildlife speed cameras: measuring animal travel speed and day range using camera traps. Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation, 2, 84–94.
Rowcliffe, J.M., Kays, R., Carbone, C. & Jansen, P.A. (2013) Clarifying assumptions behind the estimation of animal density from camera trap rates. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 77, 876–876.
Rowcliffe, J.M., Kays, R., Kranstauber, B., Carbone, C. & Jansen, P.A. (2014) Quantifying levels of animal activity using camera trap data. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 5, 1170–1179.
Royle, J.A., Nichols, J.D., Karanth, K.U. & Gopalaswamy, A.M. (2009) A hierarchical model for estimating density in camera-trap studies. Journal of Applied Ecology, 46, 118–127.
Sala, O.E., Chapin, F.S. III, Armesto, J.J., Berlow, E., Bloofield, J., Dirzo, R. et al. (2000) Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. Science, 287, 1770–1774.
Scotson, L., Johnston, L.R., Iannarilli, F., Wearn, O.R., Mohd-Azlan, J., Wong, W.M. et al. (2017) Best practices and software for the management and sharing of camera trap data for small and large scales studies. Remote Sensing in Ecology and Conservation, 3, 158–172.
Sollmann, R., Mohamed, A., Samejima, H. & Wilting, A. (2013) Risky business or simple solution–Relative abundance indices from camera-trapping. Biological Conservation, 159, 405–412.
Strindberg, S., Maisels, F., Williamson, E.A., Blake, S., Stokes, E.J., Aba’a, R. et al. (2018). Guns, germs, and trees determine density and distribution of gorillas and chimpanzees in Western Equatorial Africa. Science Advances, 4, eaar2964.
TEAM Network (2011). Terrestrial vertebrate protocol implementation manual, v. 3.1. Trop. Ecol. Assess. Monit. Netw. Cent. Appl. Biodivers. Sci. Conserv. Int. Arlingt. VA USA.
Tobler, M.W. (2015). Camera Base Version 1.7, User guide. Available at http://www.atrium-biodiversity.org/tools/camerabase/ (accessed 17 September 2020).
Vande weghe, J.P., Christy, P., Ducrocq, M., Lee, M., Vande weghe, G. & Pauwels, O.S.G. (2016) Biodiversité des parcs nationaux et réserves du Gabon. 2. Espèces, écosystèmes et populations, Agence nationale des parcs nationaux (ANPN), ed. edition. Libreville
Wearn, O.R., Rowcliffe, J.M., Carbone, C., Bernard, H. & Ewers, R.M. (2013) Assessing the status of wild felids in a highly-disturbed commercial forest reserve in Borneo and the implications for camera trap survey design. PLoS One, 8, e77598.
Weckel, M., Giuliano, W. & Silver, S. (2006) Jaguar (Panthera onca) feeding ecology: distribution of predator and prey through time and space. Journal of Zoology, 270, 25–30.
Wickham, H. (2016) ggplot2: elegant graphics for data analysis. Springer.
Willcox, D., Nash, H.C., Trageser, S., Kim, H.J., Hywood, L., Connelly, E. et al. (2019) Evaluating methods for detecting and monitoring pangolin populations (Pholidota: Manidae). Global Ecology and Conservation, 17, e00539.
Wilson, D.E. & Mittermeier, R.A. (Eds.). (2009). Handbook of the Mammals of the World. Vol. 1. Carnivores. Barcelona, Spain: Lynx Edicions.
Wilson, D.E. & Mittermeier, R.A. (Eds.). (2011). Handbook of the Mammals of the World. Vol. 2., Hoofed Mammals. Barcelona, Spain: Lynxs Edicions.
Wilson, D.E., Mittermeier, R.A. & Lacher, T.E. (2016). Handbook of the Mammals of the World. Vol. 6. Lagomorphs and Rodents 1. Barcelona, Spain: Lynx Edicions.
Ziegler, S., Fa, J.E., Wohlfart, C., Streit, B., Jacob, S. & Wegmann, M. (2016) Mapping bushmeat hunting pressure in Central Africa. Biotropica, 48, 405–412.
