[en] Following a heated local controversy over the construction of a waste incinerator in the Fos-sur-Mer industrial area near Marseille, residents pointed to the lack of knowledge of the industry’s cumulative impact on their health and environment. Under pressure, some of their representatives supported the creation of an independent scientific organization, the Ecocitizen Institute for Pollution Awareness (IECP). Its aim was to conduct independent, localized scientific research on the chronic effects of pollution, and to lobby the administration to change its regulatory practices. This paper examines the work of the IECP to ensure that the “undone science” (Frickel et al. 2010) of pollution and its impacts gets done, by focusing on the specificities of this highly industrialized site. We look at a participatory biomonitoring experiment aimed at documenting pollution in the Gulf of Fos, where scientists working for the IECP accepted anglers’ concerns and requests and switched from a standard sentinel species to another species (conger or Conger conger). We tell the many stories that were shared with us about how congers qualified as a more suitable “cosmopolitical fish” in the study of pollution. Elaborating on actor-network theory and multispecies ethnographies, we go on to discuss the appropriacy appropriateness and success of congers as the newly appointed sentinel species aiding the detection of mercury and PCB contamination hotspots. We argue that this demonstrates the importance of the “ecology of multispecies relations” (Stengers 2010) in maintaining the livability of the area.
Disciplines :
Sociology & social sciences
Author, co-author :
Gramaglia, Christelle; IRSTEA - Montpellier > Unité mixte de recherche «Gestion de l’eau, acteurs et usages»
Melard, François ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département des sciences sociales > Département des sciences sociales
Language :
English
Title :
Looking for the Cosmopolitical Fish: Monitoring Marine Pollution with Anglers and Congers in the Gulf of Fos, Southern France
Alternative titles :
[fr] A la recherche du poisson cosmopolitique : la surveillance de la pollution marine avec les pêcheurs et les Congres dans le Golf du Lion - Sud de la France
Publication date :
14 July 2019
Journal title :
Science, Technology and Human Values
ISSN :
0162-2439
eISSN :
1552-8251
Publisher :
SAGE Publications, New York, United States
Special issue title :
Sensors and Sensing Practices
Volume :
44
Issue :
5
Pages :
814-842
Peer reviewed :
Peer Reviewed verified by ORBi
Funders :
F.R.S.-FNRS - Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique [BE]
Alcaro Luigi, Torre Camilla Della, Petochi Tommaso, Sammarini Valerio, Matiddi V., Corsi Ilaria, Baroni Davide, 2012. “Studies on Environmental Effects of Underwater Chemical Munitions in the Southern Adriatic Sea (Mediterranean Sea).” Marine Technology Society Journal 46 (3): 10–20.
Burgeot Thierry, Bocquene Gilles G., Porte Cinta, Dimeet J., Santella R. M., GarciadelaParra L. M., Pihol-Leszkowicz A., Raoux C., Galgani F.. 1996. “Bioindicators of Pollutant Exposure in the Northwestern Mediterranean Sea.” Marine Ecology Progress Series 131 (1/3): 125–41.
Buytaert Wouter, Zulkakli Zed, Grainger Sam, Acosta Luis, Bastiaensen Johan, Bièvre Bert De, Bhusal Jagat Kumar, 2014. “Citizen Science in Hydrology and Water Resources: Opportunities for Knowledge Generation, Ecosystem Service Management, and Sustainable Development.” Frontiers in Earth Science 2: 26. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feart.2014.00026/full (accessed July 4, 2019).
Callon Michel, Lascoumes Pierre, Barthe Yannick. 2011. Acting in an Uncertain World: An Essay on Technical Democracy. Boston, MA: MIT Press.
Calvillo Nerea. 2018. “Political Airs: From Monitoring to Attuned Sensing Air Pollution.” Social Studies of Science 48 (3): 372–88.
Chahid Adil, Hilali Mustapha, Benlhachimi Abdeljalil, Bouzid Taoufiq. 2014. “Contents of Cadmium, Mercury and Lead in Fish from the Atlantic Sea (Morocco) Determined by Atomic Absorption Spectrometry.” Food Chemistry 147 (March 2014): 357–60.
Charvolin Florian, Roux Jacques, eds. 2013. Passions Cognitives: L’objectivité à l’épreuve du sensible. Paris, France: Éditions des archives contemporaines.
Connolly William E., 2017. Facing the Planetary: Entangled Humanism and the Politics of Swarming. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Conrad Cathy C., Hilchey Krista G.. 2011. “A Review of Citizen Science and Community-based Environmental Monitoring: Issues and Opportunities.” Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 176 (1-4): 273–91.
Daumalin Xavier, Gramaglia Christelle. Forthcoming. “‘Neither Leave Here, Nor Die Here, but Really Live Here’. Milestones for a Social History of Anti-pollution Movements in the Berre/Fos-sur-Mer Industrial Port Zone.” Rives méditerranéennes.
Della Torre Camilla della, Petochi Tommaso, Corsi Ilaria, Dinardo M. M., Baroni D., Alcaro L., Focardi S., 2010. “DNA Damage, Severe Organ Lesions and High Muscle Levels of As and Hg in Two Benthic Fish Species from a Chemical Warfare Agent Dumping Site in the Mediterranean Sea.” Science of the Total Environment 408 (9): 2136–45.
Despret Vinciane, Meuret Michel. 2016. “Cosmoecological Sheep and the Arts of Living on a Damaged Planet.” Environmental Humanities 8 (1): 24–36.
Dron Julien, Revenko Gautier, Chamaret Philippe. 2017. “Évaluation de la contamination chimique du milieu marin dans le Golfe de Fos: Congres - Mesure de polluants dans les muscles de congress.” Institut écocitoyen pour la connaissance des pollutions. Fos-sur-Mer: Scientific Report.
Dron Julien, In Press. “Contaminant Signatures and Stable Isotope Values Qualify Conger conger (Linnaeus 1758) as a Pertinent Bioindicator to Identify Marine Contaminant Sources and Pathways.” Ecological Indicators.
Frickel Scott, Edwards Michelle. 2014. “Untangling Ignorance in Environmental Risk Assessment.” In Powerless Science? The Making of the Toxic World in the 20th Century, edited by Boudia Soraya, Jas Nathalie, 215–33. London, UK: Berghahn Books.
Frickel Scott, Gibbon Sahra, Howard Jeff, Kempner Joanna, Ottinger Gwen, Hess David J.. 2010. “Undone Science: Charting Social Movement and Civil Society Challenges to Research Agenda Setting.” Science, Technology, & Human Values 35 (4): 444–73.
Gabrys Jennifer. 2016. Program Earth: Environmental Sensing Technology and the Making of a Computational Planet. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Gabrys Jennifer. 2017. “Citizen Sensing, Air Pollution and Fracking: From ‘Caring about Your Air’ to Speculative Practices of Evidencing Harm.” Sociological Review 65 (2017): 172–92.
Gramaglia Christelle, Dauphin Charles-Enzo. 2017. “Toucher la pollution industrielle du doigt grâce aux lichens: Ethnographie d’une observation scientifique et citoyenne de l’environnement à Fos-sur-Mer.” Techniques & Culture 68 Supplement. http://journals.openedition.org/tc/8610 (accessed July 4, 2019).
Gramaglia Christelle, Silva Delaine Sampaio da. 2012. “Researching Water Quality with Non-humans: An ANT Account.” In Agency without Actors? New Approaches to Collective Action, edited by Passoth J. H., Peuker B., Schillmeier M., 178–95. London, UK: Routledge.
Haraway Donna. 1988. “Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective.” Feminist Studies 14 (3): 575–99.
Haraway Donna. 2008. When Species Meet. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Haraway Donna. 2016. Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Harding Sandra. 2008. Sciences from Below: Feminisms, Postcolonialities, and Modernities. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Hinchliffe S., Kearnes M. B., Degen M., Whatmore S.. 2005. “Urban Wild Things: A Cosmopolitical Experiment.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 23 (5): 643–58.
IFREMER. 2015. “Qualité du Milieu Marin Littoral: Bulletin de la Surveillance 2014.” http://envlit.ifremer.fr/content/download/82838/598568/file/Bulletin_2015_La_Seyne_sur_Mer.pdf (accessed July 4, 2019).
Irwin Alan. 1995. Citizen Science: A Study of People, Expertise and Sustainable Development (Environment and Society). London, UK: Routledge.
James William. 1909. A Pluralistic Universe. New York: Longmans, Green.
Kinchy Abby, Parks Sarah, Jalbert Kirk. 2016. “Fractured Knowledge: Mapping the Gaps in Public and Private Water Monitoring Efforts in Areas Affected by Shale Gas Development.” Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 34 (5): 879–99.
Kirksey Eben, Helmreich Stefan. 2010. “The Emergence of Multispecies Ethnography.” Cultural Anthropology 25 (4): 545–76.
Kirksey Eben. 2015. “Species: A Praxiographic Study.” Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 21 (4): 758–80.
Lash S., Szerszynski B., Wynne B., eds. 1996. Risk, Environment and Modernity: Towards a New Ecology. London, UK: Sage.
Latour Bruno. 2004. “Whose Cosmos? Which Cosmopolitics? A Commentary on Ulrich Beck’s Peace Proposal.” Common Knowledge 10 (3): 450–62.
Latour Bruno. 2018. Down to Earth: Politics in the New Climatic Regime. Cambridge, MA: Polity Press.
Lewis Jamie, Atkinson Paul, Harrington Jean, Featherstone Katie. 2013. “Representation and Practical Accomplishment in the Laboratory: When Is an Animal Model Good-enough?” Sociology 47 (4): 776–92.
Mélard François, Stassart Pierre. 2017. “The Diplomacy of Practitioners: For an Ecology of Practices about the Problem of the Coexistence of Wind Farms and Red Kites.” Environmental Education Research 24(9): 1359–1370.
Mitman Gregory, Fausto-Sterling Anne. 1992. “Whatever Happened to Planaria? C.M. Child and the Physiology of Inheritance.” In The Right Tools for the Job: At Work in Twentieth Century Life Sciences, edited by Clarke A. E., Fujimura J., 172–96. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Narbonne Jean-François, Garrigues P., Ribera D., Raoux C., Mathieu A., Lemaire P., Salaun J. P., Lafaurie M.. 1991. “Mixed-function Oxygenase Enzymes as Tools for Pollution Monitoring: Field Studies on the French Coast of the Mediterranean Sea.” Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology C-Pharmacology Toxicology & Endocrinology 100 (1/2): 37–42.
Osadtchy Clara. 2015. “Confits environnementaux en territoire industriel: réappropriation territoriale et émergence d’une justice environnementale. Le cas de l’étang de Berre et de Fos-sur-Mer.” PhD diss., Université du Maine, Le Mans, France.
Ottinger Gwen. 2009. “Epistemic Fencelines: Air Monitoring Instruments and Expert-resident Boundaries.” Spontaneous Generations 3 (13): 55–67.
Ottinger Gwen. 2010. “Constructing Empowerment through Interpretations of Environmental Surveillance Data.” Surveillance and Empowerment 8 (2): 221–34.
Paillard Bernard. 1981. La damnation de Fos. Paris, France: Seuil.
Ramade/Gérim, Cabinet. 2011. Suivi du milieu marin année 2010 pour le compte du Centre de traitement multifilières de déchets ménagers de Fos-sur-Mer EveRé, Research report, Mouriès.
Rose Deborah Bird, van Dooren Thom, eds. 2011. “Unloved Others: Death of the Disregarded in the Time of Extinctions.” Issue 50, Australian Humanities Review 50. Canberra: Australian National University Press.
Savan Beth, Morgan Alexis J., Gore Christopher. 2003. “Volunteer Environmental Monitoring and the Role of the Universities: The Case of Citizens’ Environment Watch.” Environmental Management 31 (5): 561–68.
Schillmeier Michael. 2012. “Science, Cosmopolitics and the Question of Agency.” In Agency without Actors? New Approaches to Collective Action, edited by Passoth J. H., Peuker B., Schillmeier M., 31–53. London, UK: Routledge.
Schillmeier Michael. 2014. Eventful Bodies: The Cosmopolitics of Illness. Farnham, UK: Ashgate.
Stengers Isabelle. 2005. “The Cosmopolitical Proposal.” In Making Things Public: Atmospheres of Democracy, edited by Latour B., Weibel Peter, 994–1003. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Stengers Isabelle. 2006. La vierge et le neutrino: Les scientifiques dans la tourmente. Paris, France: Les empêcheurs de penser en rond.
Stengers Isabelle. 2010. “Including Nonhumans in Political Theory: Opening Pandora’s Box?” In Political Matter: Technoscience, Democracy, and Public Life, edited by Braun Bruce, Whatmore Sarah, 3–34. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Storelli Maria Maddalena, Perrone Veronica Giuliana, Busco Vito Pietro, Spedicato D., Barone G.. 2012. “Persistent Organic Pollutants (PCBs and DDTs) in European conger eel, Conger conger L., from the Ionian Sea (Mediterranean Sea).” Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 88 (6): 928–32.
Tsing Anna Lowenhaupt. 2015. The Mushroom at the End of the World: On the Possibility of Life in Capitalist Ruins. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Turnhout Esther, Hisschemöller Matthijs, Eijsackers Herman. 2007. “Ecological Indicators: Between the Two Fires of Science and Policy.” Ecological Indicators 7 (2): 215–28.
Van Dooren Thom, Kirksey Eben, Münster Ursula. 2016. “Multispecies Studies: Cultivating Arts of Attentiveness.” Environmental Humanities 8 (1): 1–23.
Waterton Claire, Tsouvalis Judith. 2015. “On the Political Nature of Cyanobacteria: Intra-active Collective Politics in Loweswater, the English Lake District.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 33 (3): 477–93.
Whatmore Sarah J., Landström Catharina. 2011. “Flood Apprentices: An Exercise in Making Things Public.” Economy and Society 40 (4): 582–610.
Wynne Brian. 2016. “Misunderstood Misunderstanding: Social Identities and Public Uptake of Science.” Public Understanding of Science 1 (3): 281–304.
Wylie Sara A., Jalbert Kirk, Dosemagen Shannon. 2014. “Institutions for Civic Technoscience: How Critical Making Is Transforming Environmental Research.” The Information Society 30 (2): 116–26.
