Wear measurement of dental tissues and materials in clinical studies: A systematic review

[en] tObjectives. This study aims to systematically review the different methods used for wearmeasurement of dental tissues and materials in clinical studies, their relevance and relia-bility in terms of accuracy and precision, and the performance of the different steps of theworkflow taken independently.Methods. An exhaustive search of clinical studies related to wear of dental tissues andmaterials reporting a quantitative measurement method was conducted. MedLine, Embase,Scopus, Cochrane Library and Web of Science databases were used. Prospective studies,pilot studies and case series (>10 patients), as long as they contained a description of wearmeasurement methodology. Only studies published after 1995 were considered.Results. After duplicates’ removal, 495 studies were identified, and 41 remained for quantita-tive analysis. Thirty-four described wear-measurement protocols, using digital profilometryand superimposition, whereas 7 used alternative protocols. A specific form was designed toanalyze the risk of bias. The methods were described in terms of material analyzed; studydesign; device used for surface acquisition; matching software details and settings; typeof analysis (vertical height-loss measurement vs volume loss measurement); type of areainvestigated (entire occlusal area or selective areas); and results.Sinificance. There is a need of standardization of clinical wear measurement. Current meth-ods exhibit accuracy, which is not sufficient to monitor wear of restorative materials andtooth tissues. Their performance could be improved, notably limiting the use of replicas,using standardized calibration procedures and positive controls, optimizing the settings ofscanners and matching softwares, and taking into account unusable data.

Research Center/Unit :

d‐BRU - Dental Biomaterials Research Unit - ULiège

Disciplines :

Dentistry & oral medicine

Author, co-author :

Wulfman, Claudine

KOENIG, Vinciane ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Service prothèse fixée

Mainjot, Amélie ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département de sciences dentaires > Biomatériaux dentaires

Language :

English

Title :

Wear measurement of dental tissues and materials in clinical studies: A systematic review

Publication date :

2018

Journal title :

Dental Materials

ISSN :

0109-5641

eISSN :

1879-0097

Publisher :

Elsevier, Netherlands

Peer reviewed :

Peer Reviewed verified by ORBi

Available on ORBi :

since 08 May 2018

Statistics

Number of views

258 (10 by ULiège)

Number of downloads

7 (5 by ULiège)

More statistics

Scopus citations^®

Scopus citations^®
without self-citations

OpenCitations

OpenAlex citations

Bibliography

Lee, A., He, L.H., Lyons, K., Swain, M.V., Tooth wear and wear investigations in dentistry. J Oral Rehabil 39 (2012), 217–225.
Corica, A., Caprioglio, A., Meta-analysis of the prevalence of tooth wear in primary dentition. Eur J Paediatr Dent 15 (2014), 385–388.
Kreulen, C.M., Van't Spijker, A., Rodriguez, J.M., Bronkhorst, E.M., Creugers, N.H.J., Bartlett, D.W., Systematic review of the prevalence of tooth wear in children and adolescents. Caries Res 44 (2010), 151–159.
Huysmans, M.C.D.N.J.M., Chew, H.P., Ellwood, R.P., Clinical studies of dental erosion and erosive wear. Caries Res 45:Suppl. 1 (2011), 60–68.
Stober, T., Heuschmid, N., Zellweger, G., Rousson, V., Rues, S., Heintze, S.D., Comparability of clinical wear measurements by optical 3D laser scanning in two different centers. Dent Mater 30 (2014), 499–506.
Esquivel-Upshaw, J.F., Young, H., Jones, J., Yang, M., Anusavice, K.J., In vivo wear of enamel by a lithia disilicate-based core ceramic used for posterior fixed partial dentures: first-year results. Int J Prosthodont 19 (2006), 391–396.
Heintze, S.D., Faouzi, M., Rousson, V., Ozcan, M., Correlation of wear in vivo and six laboratory wear methods. Dent Mater 28 (2012), 961–973.
Heintze, S.D., How to qualify and validate wear simulation devices and methods. Dent Mater 22 (2006), 712–734.
Heintze, S.D., Ilie, N., Hickel, R., Reis, A., Loguercio, A., Rousson, V., Laboratory mechanical parameters of composite resins and their relation to fractures and wear in clinical trials—a systematic review. Dent Mater 33 (2017), e101–14.
Smith, B.G., Knight, J.K., An index for measuring the wear of teeth. Br Dent J 156 (1984), 435–438.
Lussi, A., Dental erosion clinical diagnosis and case history taking. Eur J Oral Sci 104 (1996), 191–198.
Cvar, J.F., Ryge, G., Reprint of criteria for the clinical evaluation of dental restorative materials. Clin Oral Investig 2005:9 (1971), 215–232.
Leinfelder, K.F., Taylor, D.F., Barkmeier, W.W., Goldberg, A.J., Quantitative wear measurement of posterior composite resins. Dent Mater 2 (1986), 198–201.
Moffa, J., Lugassy, A., Calibration of evaluators utilizing the M-L occlusal loss scale. J Dent Res, 65, 1986, 302.
Perry, R., Kugel, G., Kunzelmann, K.H., Flessa, H.P., Estafan, D., Composite restoration wear analysis: conventional methods vs. three-dimensional laser digitizer. J Am Dent Assoc 131 (2000), 1472–1477.
Jørgensen, K.D., Asmussen, E., Occlusal abrasion of a composite restorative resin with ultra-fine filler-an initial study. Quintessence Int Dent Dig 9 (1978), 73–78.
Lambrechts, P., Vanherle, G., Vuylsteke, M., Davidson, C.L., Quantitative evaluation of the wear resistance of posterior dental restorations: a new three-dimensional measuring technique. J Dent 12 (1984), 252–267.
Chadwick, R.G., Mitchell, H.L., Cameron, I., Hunter, B., Tulley, M., Development of a novel system for assessing tooth and restoration wear. J Dent 25 (1997), 41–47.
Mehl, A., Gloger, W., Kunzelmann, K.H., Hickel, R., A new optical 3-D device for the detection of wear. J Dent Res 76 (1997), 1799–1807.
Mitchell, H.L., Chadwick, R.G., Mathematical shape matching as a tool in tooth wear assessment—development and conduct. J Oral Rehabil 25 (1998), 921–928.
DeLong, R., Intra-oral restorative materials wear: rethinking the current approaches: how to measure wear. Dent Mater 22 (2006), 702–711.
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D.G., PRISMA Group, Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. J Clin Epidemiol 62 (2009), 1006–1012.
Van't Spijker, A., Kreulen, C.M., Bronkhorst, E.M., Creugers, N.H.J., Assessment of early attrition using an ordinary flatbed scanner. J Dent 40 (2012), 603–608.
Chen, H., Lowe, A.A., de Almeida, F.R., Fleetham, J.A., Wang, B., Three-dimensional computer-assisted study model analysis of long-term oral-appliance wear. Part 2. Side effects of oral appliances in obstructive sleep apnea patients. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 134 (2008), 408–417.
Chen, H., Lowe, A.A., de Almeida, F.R., Wong, M., Fleetham, J.A., Wang, B., Three-dimensional computer-assisted study model analysis of long-term oral-appliance wear: Part 1: methodology. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 134 (2008), 393–407.
Hayashi, M., Tsubakimoto, Y., Takeshige, F., Ebisu, S., Analysis of longitudinal marginal deterioration of ceramic inlays. Oper Dent 29 (2004), 386–391.
Krämer, N., Frankenberger, R., Leucite-reinforced glass ceramic inlays after six years: wear of luting composites. Oper Dent 25 (2000), 466–472.
Gao, W., Peng, D., Smales, R.J., Yip, K.H.K., Comparison of atraumatic restorative treatment and conventional restorative procedures in a hospital clinic: evaluation after 30 months. Quintessence Int 34 (2003), 31–37.
Yip, K.H.K., Smales, R.J., Gao, W., Peng, D., The effects of two cavity preparation methods on the longevity of glass ionomer cement restorations: an evaluation after 12 months. J Am Dent Assoc 133 (2002), 744–751 quiz 769.
Lo, E.C., Luo, Y., Fan, M.W., Wei, S.H., Clinical investigation of two glass-ionomer restoratives used with the atraumatic restorative treatment approach in China: two-years results. Caries Res 35 (2001), 458–463.
Luo, Y., Lo, E.C.M., Fang, D.T.S., Smales, R.J., Wei, S.H.Y., Clinical evaluation of Dyract AP restorative in permanent molars: 2-year results. Am J Dent 15 (2002), 403–406.
Wassell, R.W., Walls, A.W., McCabe, J.F., Direct composite inlays versus conventional composite restorations: 5-year follow-up. J Dent 28 (2000), 375–382.
Walls, A.W., The use of adhesively retained all-porcelain veneers during the management of fractured and worn anterior teeth: part 2. Clinical results after 5 years of follow-up. Br Dent J 178 (1995), 337–340.
Bartlett, D., Sundaram, G., Moazzez, R., Trial of protective effect of fissure sealants, in vivo, on the palatal surfaces of anterior teeth, in patients suffering from erosion. J Dent 39 (2011), 26–29.
Sundaram, G., Wilson, R., Watson, T.F., Bartlett, D., Clinical measurement of palatal tooth wear following coating by a resin sealing system. Oper Dent 32 (2007), 539–543.
Bartlett, D.W., Blunt, L., Smith, B.G., Measurement of tooth wear in patients with palatal erosion. Br Dent J 182 (1997), 179–184.
Ogle, R.E., Davis, E.L., Clinical wear study of three commercially available artificial tooth materials: thirty-six month results. J Prosthet Dent 79 (1998), 145–151.
Al-Omiri, M.K., Harb, R., Abu Hammad, O.A., Lamey, P.-J., Lynch, E., Clifford, T.J., Quantification of tooth wear: conventional vs new method using toolmakers microscope and a three-dimensional measuring technique. J Dent 38 (2010), 560–568.
Al-Omiri, M.K., Sghaireen, M.G., Alzarea, B.K., Lynch, E., Quantification of incisal tooth wear in upper anterior teeth: conventional vs new method using toolmakers microscope and a three-dimensional measuring technique. J Dent 41 (2013), 1214–1221.
Wood, I.D., Kassir, A.S.A., Brunton, P.A., Effect of lateral excursive movements on the progression of abfraction lesions. Oper Dent 34 (2009), 273–279.
Palaniappan, S., Bharadwaj, D., Mattar, D.L., Peumans, M., Van Meerbeek, B., Lambrechts, P., Three-year randomized clinical trial to evaluate the clinical performance and wear of a nanocomposite versus a hybrid composite. Dent Mater 25 (2009), 1302–1314.
Schmid-Schwap, M., Rousson, V., Vornwagner, K., Heintze, S.D., Wear of two artificial tooth materials in vivo: a 12-month pilot study. J Prosthet Dent 102 (2009), 104–114.
Lohbauer, U., Reich, S., Antagonist wear of monolithic zirconia crowns after 2 years. Clin Oral Investig 21 (2017), 1165–1172.
Heintze, S.D., Zellweger, G., Sbicego, S., Rousson, V., Muñoz-Viveros, C., Stober, T., Wear of two denture teeth materials in vivo-2-year results. Dent Mater 29 (2013), e191–204.
DeLong, R., Pintado, M.R., Douglas, W.H., Fok, A.S., Wilder, A.D., Swift, E.J., et al. Wear of a dental composite in an artificial oral environment: a clinical correlation. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 100 (2012), 2297–2306.
Palaniappan, S., Celis, J.-P., Van Meerbeek, B., Peumans, M., Lambrechts, P., Correlating in vitro scratch test with in vivo contact free occlusal area wear of contemporary dental composites. Dent Mater 29 (2013), 259–268.
Chadwick, R.G., Mitchell, H.L., Ward, S., Rationalization of quantitative tooth surface loss data for epidemiological research. J Oral Rehabil 31 (2004), 42–46.
Price, R.B., Gerrow, J.D., Sutow, E.J., MacSween, R., The dimensional accuracy of 12 impression material and die stone combinations. Int J Prosthodont 4 (1991), 169–174.
Cetin, A.R., Unlu, N., Clinical wear rate of direct and indirect posterior composite resin restorations. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 32 (2012), e87–94.
Folwaczny, M., Mehl, A., Kunzelmann, K.H., Hickel, R., Determination of changes on tooth-colored cervical restorations in vivo using a three-dimensional laser scanning device. Eur J Oral Sci 108 (2000), 233–238.
Pintado, M.R., Anderson, G.C., DeLong, R., Douglas, W.H., Variation in tooth wear in young adults over a two-year period. J Prosthet Dent 77 (1997), 313–320.
Krämer, N., Küssner, P., Motmaen, I., Köhl, M., Wöstmann, B., Frankenberger, R., Marginal quality and wear of extended posterior resin composite restorations: eight-year results in vivo. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater 50 (2015), 13–22.
Schlueter, N., Ganss, C., De Sanctis, S., Klimek, J., Evaluation of a profilometrical method for monitoring erosive tooth wear. Eur J Oral Sci 113 (2005), 505–511.
Etman, M.K., Woolford, M., Dunne, S., Quantitative measurement of tooth and ceramic wear: in vivo study. Int J Prosthodont 21 (2008), 245–252.
Chadwick, R.G., Mitchell, H.L., Manton, S.L., Ward, S., Ogston, S., Brown, R., Maxillary incisor palatal erosion: no correlation with dietary variables?. J Clin Pediatr Dent 29 (2005), 157–163.
Krämer, N., Kunzelmann, K.-H., Taschner, M., Mehl, A., Garcia-Godoy, F., Frankenberger, R., Antagonist enamel wears more than ceramic inlays. J Dent Res 85 (2006), 1097–1100.
Mundhe, K., Jain, V., Pruthi, G., Shah, N., Clinical study to evaluate the wear of natural enamel antagonist to zirconia and metal ceramic crowns. J Prosthet Dent 114 (2015), 358–363.
Rosin, M., Splieth, C., Hessler, M., Gärtner, C., Kordass, B., Kocher, T., Quantification of gingival edema using a new 3-D laser scanning method. J Clin Periodontol 29 (2002), 240–246.
Rodriguez, J.M., Austin, R.S., Bartlett, D.W., A method to evaluate profilometric tooth wear measurements. Dent Mater 28 (2012), 245–251.
Chadwick, R.G., Mitchell, H.L., Conduct of an algorithm in quantifying simulated palatal surface tooth erosion. J Oral Rehabil 28 (2001), 450–456.
Pintado, M.R., Delong, R., Ko, C.C., Sakaguchi, R.L., Douglas, W.H., Correlation of noncarious cervical lesion size and occlusal wear in a single adult over a 14-year time span. J Prosthet Dent 84 (2000), 436–443.
Stober, T., Bermejo, J.L., Rammelsberg, P., Schmitter, M., Enamel wear caused by monolithic zirconia crowns after 6 months of clinical use. J Oral Rehabil 41 (2014), 314–322.
Rodriguez, J.M., Austin, R.S., Bartlett, D.W., In vivo measurements of tooth wear over 12 months. Caries Res 46 (2012), 9–15.
Heintze, S.D., Zellweger, G., Grunert, I., Muñoz-Viveros, C.A., Hagenbuch, K., Laboratory methods for evaluating the wear of denture teeth and their correlation with clinical results. Dent Mater 28 (2012), 261–272.
Peters, M.C., Delong, R., Pintado, M.R., Pallesen, U., Qvist, V., Douglas, W.H., Comparison of two measurement techniques for clinical wear. J Dent 27 (1999), 479–485.
Söderholm, K.J., Lambrechts, P., Sarrett, D., Abe, Y., Yang, M.C., Labella, R., et al. Clinical wear performance of eight experimental dental composites over three years determined by two measuring methods. Eur J Oral Sci 109 (2001), 273–281.
Lambrechts, P., Braem, M., Vuylsteke-Wauters, M., Vanherle, G., Quantitative in vivo wear of human enamel. J Dent Res 68 (1989), 1752–1754.
Stober, T., Geiger, A., Rues, S., Dreyhaupt, J., Rammelsberg, P., Ohlmann, B., Factors affecting wear of composite resin denture teeth-24-month results from a clinical study. Clin Oral Investig 16 (2012), 413–420.
Ohlmann, B., Rohstock, K., Kugler, J., Gilde, H., Dreyhaupt, J., Stober, T., Influences on clinical wear of acrylic denture teeth: a pilot study. Int J Prosthodont 20 (2007), 496–498.
Anselm Wiskott, H.W., Perriard, J., Scherrer, S.S., Dieth, S., Belser, U.C., In vivo wear of three types of veneering materials using implant-supported restorations: a method evaluation. Eur J Oral Sci 110 (2002), 61–67.
Rosin, M., Steffen, H., Konschake, C., Greese, U., Teichmann, D., Hartmann, A., et al. One-year evaluation of an Ormocer restorative-a multipractice clinical trial. Clin Oral Investig 7 (2003), 20–26.
Turssi, C.P., De Moraes Purquerio, B., Serra, M.C., Wear of dental resin composites: insights into underlying processes and assessment methods-a review. J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater 65 (2003), 280–285.
Azzopardi, A., Bartlett, D.W., Watson, T.F., Smith, B.G., A literature review of the techniques to measure tooth wear and erosion. Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent 8 (2000), 93–97.
McDowell, G.C., Bloem, T.J., Lang, B.R., Asgar, K., In vivo wear. Part I: The Michigan computer-graphic measuring system. J Prosthet Dent 60 (1988), 112–120.
Chadwick, R.G., McCabe, J.F., Walls, A.W., Mitchell, H.L., Storer, R., Comparison of a novel photogrammetric technique and modified USPHS criteria to monitor the wear of restorations. J Dent 19 (1991), 39–45.
Attin, T., Zirkel, C., Hellwig, E., Brushing abrasion of eroded dentin after application of sodium fluoride solutions. Caries Res 32 (1998), 344–350.
Field, J., Waterhouse, P., German, M., Quantifying and qualifying surface changes on dental hard tissues in vitro. J Dent 38 (2010), 182–190, 10.1016/j.jdent.2010.01.002.
Güth, J., Keul, C., Beuer, F., Konec, D., Stimmelmayr, M., Edelhoff, D., Ein neuer Ansatz zur Quantifizierung von Zahnhartsubstanzverlusten mittels Intraoralscan. Annu. Conf. Ger. Prosthodont. Assoc. DGPro, 2012 p. Abstr. no. 16.
Lawson, N.C., Radhakrishnan, R., Givan, D.A., Ramp, L.C., Burgess, J.O., Two-year randomized, controlled clinical trial of a flowable and conventional composite in Class I restorations. Oper Dent 40 (2015), 594–602.
Park, J., Choi, D.-S., Jang, I., Yook, H.-T., Jost-Brinkmann, P.-G., Cha, B.-K., A novel method for volumetric assessment of tooth wear using three-dimensional reverse-engineering technology: a preliminary report. Angle Orthod 84 (2014), 687–692.
Hartkamp, O., Lohbauer, U., Reich, S., Antagonist wear by polished zirconia crowns. Int J Comput Dent 20 (2017), 263–274.
Vandeweghe, S., Vervack, V., Dierens, M., De Bruyn, H., Accuracy of digital impressions of multiple dental implants: an in vitro study. Clin Oral Implants Res 28 (2017), 648–653.
Blais, F., Review of 20 years of range sensor development. J Electron Imaging 13 (2004), 231–243, 10.1117/1.1631921.
Bogue, R., Three-dimensional measurements: a review of technologies and applications. Sens Rev 30 (2010), 102–106, 10.1108/02602281011022670.
Esquivel-Upshaw, J.F., Rose, W.F., Barrett, A.A., Oliveira, E.R., Yang, M.C.K., Clark, A.E., et al. Three years in vivo wear: core-ceramic, veneers, and enamel antagonists. Dent Mater 28 (2012), 615–621.
Esquivel-Upshaw, J., Rose, W., Oliveira, E., Yang, M., Clark, A.E., Anusavice, K., Randomized, controlled clinical trial of bilayer ceramic and metal-ceramic crown performance. J Prosthodont 22 (2013), 166–173.
Silva, N.R.F.A., Thompson, V.P., Valverde, G.B., Coelho, P.G., Powers, J.M., Farah, J.W., et al. Comparative reliability analyses of zirconium oxide and lithium disilicate restorations in vitro and in vivo. J Am Dent Assoc 1939 142:Suppl. 2 (2011), 4S–9S.
Sorensen, J.A., Cruz, M., Mito, W.T., Raffeiner, O., Meredith, H.R., Foser, H.P., A clinical investigation on three-unit fixed partial dentures fabricated with a lithium disilicate glass-ceramic. Pract Periodontics Aesthetic Dent PPAD 11 (1999), 95–106 quiz 108.
Stober, T., Bermejo, J.L., Schwindling, F.S., Schmitter, M., Clinical assessment of enamel wear caused by monolithic zirconia crowns. J Oral Rehabil 43 (2016), 621–629.
Suputtamongkol, K., Anusavice, K.J., Suchatlampong, C., Sithiamnuai, P., Tulapornchai, C., Clinical performance and wear characteristics of veneered lithia-disilicate-based ceramic crowns. Dent Mater 24 (2008), 667–673.
Ohlmann, B., Trame, J.-P., Dreyhaupt, J., Gabbert, O., Koob, A., Rammelsberg, P., Wear of posterior metal-free polymer crowns after 2 years. J Oral Rehabil 35 (2008), 782–788.
Stober, T., Dreyhaupt, J., Lehnung, U., Rammelsberg, P., Occlusal wear of metal-free ceramic-filled polymer crowns after 2 years in service. Int J Prosthodont 21 (2008), 161–165.
Zenthöfer, A., Rammelsberg, P., Schmitt, C., Ohlmann, B., Wear of metal-free resin composite crowns after three years in service. Dent Mater J 32 (2013), 787–792.
Palaniappan, S., Elsen, L., Lijnen, I., Peumans, M., Van Meerbeek, B., Lambrechts, P., Three-year randomised clinical trial to evaluate the clinical performance, quantitative and qualitative wear patterns of hybrid composite restorations. Clin Oral Investig 14 (2010), 441–458.
Palaniappan, S., Bharadwaj, D., Mattar, D.L., Peumans, M., Van Meerbeek, B., Lambrechts, P., Nanofilled and microhybrid composite restorations: Five-year clinical wear performances. Dent Mater 27 (2011), 692–700.
Palaniappan, S., Elsen, L., Lijnen, I., Peumans, M., Van Meerbeek, B., Lambrechts, P., Nanohybrid and microfilled hybrid versus conventional hybrid composite restorations: 5-year clinical wear performance. Clin Oral Investig 16 (2012), 181–190.
Pesun, I.J., Olson, A.K., Hodges, J.S., Anderson, G.C., In vivo evaluation of the surface of posterior resin composite restorations: a pilot study. J Prosthet Dent 84 (2000), 353–359.
Rosin, M., Schwahn, C., Kordass, B., Konschake, C., Greese, U., Teichmann, D., et al. A multipractice clinical evaluation of an ORMOCER restorative-2-year results. Quintessence Int 38 (2007), e306–e315.
Tantbirojn, D., Cheng, Y.S., Verluis, A., Hodges, J.S., Douglas, W.H., Nominal shear or fracture mechanisms in the assessment of composite-dentin adhesion. J Dent Res 79 (2000), 41–48.
Lindquist, T.J., Ogle, R.E., Davis, E.L., Twelve-month results of a clinical wear study of three artificial tooth materials. J Prosthet Dent 74 (1995), 156–161.
Ohlmann, B., Uekermann, J., Dreyhaupt, J., Schmitter, M., Mussotter, K., Rammelsberg, P., Clinical wear of posterior metal-free polymer crowns: One-year results from a randomized clinical trial. J Dent 35 (2007), 246–252.