An in vitro evaluation of leakage of two Etch and Rinse and two Self-Etch adhesives  after thermocycling

[en] Our experiment evaluated the microleakage in resin composite restorations bonded to dental tissues with different adhesive systems. 40 class V cavities were prepared on the facial and lingual surfaces of each tooth with coronal margins in enamel and apical margins in cementum (root dentin). The teeth were restored with Z100 resin composite bonded with different adhesive systems: Scotchbond! Multipurpose (SBMP) a 3-step Etch and Rinse adhesive, Adper! Scotchbond! 1 XT (SB1) a 2-step Etch and Rinse adhesive, AdheSE® One (ADSE-1) a 1-step Self-Etch adhesive and AdheSE® (ADSE) a 2-step Self-Etch adhesive. Teeth were thermocycled and immersed in 50 % silver nitrate solution. When both interfaces were considered, SBMP has exhibited significantly less microleakage than other adhesive systems (respectively for SB1, ADSE-1 and ADSE, p = 0.0007, p < 0.0001 and p < 0.0001). When enamel and dentin interfaces were evaluated separately: 1) for the Self-Etch adhesives, microleakage was found greater at enamel than at dentin interfaces (for ADSE, p = 0.024 and for ADSE-1, p < 0.0001); 2) for the Etch and Rinse adhesive systems, there was no significant difference between enamel and dentin interfaces; 3) SBMP was found significantly better than other adhesives both at enamel and dentin interfaces. In our experiment Etch and Rinse adhesives remain better than Self-Etch adhesives at enamel interface. In addition, there was no statistical difference between 1-step (ADSE-1) and 2-step (ADSE) Self-Etch adhesives.

Disciplines :

Dentistry & oral medicine

Author, co-author :

Geerts, Sabine ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département de science dentaire > Dentisterie conservatrice de l'adulte - Occlusodontie

BOLETTE, Amandine ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Institut de dentisterie - conservatrice de l'adulte

SEIDEL, Laurence ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Non budgétaires

Gueders, Audrey ; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Liège - CHU > Institut de dentisterie - conservatrice de l'adulte

Language :

English

Title :

An in vitro evaluation of leakage of two Etch and Rinse and two Self-Etch adhesives after thermocycling

Publication date :

2012

Journal title :

International Journal of Dentistry

ISSN :

1687-8728

eISSN :

1687-8736

Publisher :

Hindawi Publishing Corporation

Peer reviewed :

Peer Reviewed verified by ORBi

Available on ORBi :

since 11 May 2012

Statistics

Number of views

102 (24 by ULiège)

Number of downloads

4 (4 by ULiège)

More statistics

Scopus citations^®

Scopus citations^®
without self-citations

OpenCitations

Bibliography

Bullard R. H., Leinfelder K. F., Russell C. M., Effect of coefficient of thermal expansion on microleakage. The Journal of the American Dental Association 1988 116 7 871 874
Crim G. A., Garcia-Godoy F., Microleakage: the effect of storage and cycling duration The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 1987 57 5 574 576
Pioch T., Staehle H. J., Duschner H., Tavernier B., Colon P., Effect of dentin adhesives on the enamel-dentin/composite interfacial microleakage American Journal of Dentistry 2001 14 252 258
Rees J. S., O'Dougherty D., Pullin R., The stress reducing capacity of unfilled resin in a class V cavity Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 1999 26 5 422 427
van Meerbeek B., Yoshida Y., Lambrechts P., Vanherle G., Duke E. S., Eick J. D., Robinson S. J., A TEM study of two water-based adhesive systems bonded to dry and wet dentin Journal of Dental Research 1998 77 1 50 59 (Pubitemid 32770488)
van Meerbeek B., Vargas M., Inoue S., Adhesives and cements to promote preservation dentistry Operative Dentistry 2001 supplement 6 119 144
van Meerbeek B., de Munck J., Yoshida Y., Buonocore Memorial Lectureadhesion to enamel and dentin: current status and future challenges Operative Dentistry 2003 28 3 215 235 (Pubitemid 37237447)
van Meerbeek B., Yoshihara K., Yoshida Y., Mine A., de Munck J., van Landuyt K. L., State of the art of self-etch adhesives Dental Materials 2011 27 1 17 28
Pashley D. H., Tay F. R., Breschi L., Tjderhane L., Carvalho R. M., Carrilho M., Tezvergil-Mutluay A., State of the art etchrinse adhesives Dental Materials 2011 27 1 1 16
Bradna P., Vrbova R., Dudek M., Roubickova A., Housova D., Comparison of bonding performance of self-etching and etchrinse adhesives on human dentin using reliability analysis. The Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 2008 10 6 423 429
Ernst C. P., Ktter T., Victor A., Canbek K., Brandenbusch M., Willershausen B., Marginal integrity of self- and total-etching adhesives in two different application protocols Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 2004 6 1 25 32 (Pubitemid 38530561)
Ferrari M., Cagidiaco M. C., Kugel G., Davidson C. L., Dentin infiltration by three adhesive systems in clinical and laboratory conditions American Journal of Dentistry 1996 9 6 240 244 (Pubitemid 126441878)
Fortin D., Swift E. J. Jr., Denehy G. E., Reinhardt J. W., Bond strength and microleakage of current dentin adhesives Dental Materials 1994 10 4 253 258
Frankenberger R., Perdigao J., Rosa B. T., Lopes M., No-bottle vs 'multi-bottle' dentin adhesivesa microtensile bond strength and morphological study Dental Materials 2001 17 5 373 380 (Pubitemid 33651208)
Grégoire G., Joniot S., Guignes P., Millas A., Dentin permeability: self-etching and one-bottle dentin bonding systems Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 2003 90 1 42 49 (Pubitemid 37309299)
Hara A. T., Amaral C. M., Pimenta L. A. F., Sinhoreti M. A. C., Shear bond strength of hydrophilic adhesive systems to enamel American Journal of Dentistry 1999 12 4 181 184
Holtan J. R., Nystrom G. P., Olin P. S., Phelps R. A., Phillips J. J., Douglas W. H., Bond strength of six dentinal adhesives Journal of Dentistry 1994 22 2 92 96
Inoue S., Vargas M. A., Abe Y., Yoshida Y., Lambrechts P., Vanherle G., HidehikoSano, van Meerbeek B., Microtensile bond strength of eleven contemporary adhesives to dentin Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 2001 3 3 237 245 (Pubitemid 33771577)
Owens B. M., Johnson W. W., Effect of insertion technique and adhesive system on microleakage of class V resin composite restorations Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 2005 7 4 303 308 (Pubitemid 43048582)
Pilo R., Ben-Amar A., Comparison of microleakage for three one-bottle and three multiple-step dentin bonding agents. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 1999 82 2 209 213
Swift E. J., Triolo P. T., Barkmeier W. W., Bird J. L., Bounds S. J., Effect of low-viscosity resins on the performance of dental adhesives American Journal of Dentistry 1996 9 3 100 104 (Pubitemid 126441846)
van Meerbeek B., Peumans M., Verschueren M., Gladys S., Braem M., Lambrechts P., Vanherle G., Clinical status of ten dentin adhesive systems Journal of dental research 1994 73 11 1690 1702
van Meerbeek B., de Munck J., Mattar D., van Landuyt K., Lambrechts P., Microtensile bond strengths of an etchrinse and self-etch adhesive to enamel and dentin as a function of surface treatment Operative Dentistry 2003 28 5 647 660 (Pubitemid 37229799)
Vargas M. A., Swift E. J., Microleakage of resin composites with wet versus dry bonding American Journal of Dentistry 1994 7 4 187 189
Cao L., Geerts S., Guéders A., Albert A., Seidel L., Charpentier J., Experimental comparison of cavity sealing ability of five dental adhesive systems after thermocycling Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 2003 5 2 139 144 (Pubitemid 37158225)
Guéders A. M., Charpentier J. F., Albert A. I., Geerts S. O., Microleakage after thermocycling of 4 etchrinse and 3 self-etch adhesives with and without a flowable composite lining Operative Dentistry 2006 31 4 450 455 (Pubitemid 44276633)
Rosales-Leal J. I., Microleakage of class v composite restorations placed with etchrinse and self-etching adhesives before and after thermocycling Journal of Adhesive Dentistry 2007 9 supplement 2 255 259
Lopes G. C., Vieira L. C. C., Araujo E., Direct composite resin restorations: a review of some clinical procedures to achieve predictable results in posterior teeth Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry 2004 16 1 19 31 (Pubitemid 38535218)
Lopes G. C., Oliveira G. M., Direct composite resin restorations in posterior teeth. Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry 2006 27 10 572 579
Javaheri D. S., Posterior direct composites: clinical protocol Dentistry Today 2007 26 3 94 97
Mackenzie L., Shortall A. C., Burke F. J., Direct posterior composites: a practical guide Dental Update 2009 36 2 71 80
van Meerbeek B., Peumans M., Poitevin A., Mine A., van Ende A., Neves A., de Munck J., Relationship between bond-strength tests and clinical outcomes Dental Materials 2010 26 2 e100 e121
Almeida K. G. B., Scheibe K. G. B. A., Oliveira A. E. F., Alves C. M. C., Costa J. F., Influence of human and bovine substrate on the microleakage of two adhesive systems Journal of Applied Oral Science 2009 17 2 92 96
Apap M., Adhésifs auto-mordanants: un bon plan ? L'Information Dentaire 2007 43 2804 2816
Degrange M., Lapostolle B., L'expérience des batailles des adhésifs L'Information Dentaire 2007 89 112 118
Ernst C. P., Options for dentin bonding Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry 2006 18 2 61 67
Peumans M., de Munck J., van Landuyt K., Lambrechts P., van Meerbeek B., Three-year clinical effectiveness of a two-step self-etch adhesive in cervical lesions European Journal of Oral Sciences 2005 113 6 512 518 (Pubitemid 41784338)
Fukegawa D., Hayakawa S., Yoshida Y., Suzuki K., Osaka A., van Meerbeek B., Chemical interaction of phosphoric acid ester with hydroxyapatite Journal of Dental Research 2006 85 10 941 944 (Pubitemid 44578608)
Nagakane K., Yoshida Y., Hirata I., Fukuda R., Nakayama Y., Shirai K., Ogawa T., Suzuki K., van Meerbeek B., Okazaki M., Analysis of chemical interaction of 4-MET with hydroxyapatite using XPS Dental Materials Journal 2006 25 4 645 649
Yoshida Y., Nagakane K., Fukuda R., Nakayama Y., Okazaki M., Shintani H., Inoue S., Tagawa Y., Suzuki K., de Munck J., van Meerbeek B., Comparative study on adhesive performance of functional monomers Journal of Dental Research 2004 83 6 454 458 (Pubitemid 41756839)
Degrange M., Les systmes adhésifs amélo-dentinaires Réalités Cliniques 2005 16 4 327 348
Perdigao J., Monteiro P., Gomes G., In vitro enamel sealing of self-etch adhesives. Quintessence International 2009 40 3 225 233
van Landuyt K. L., Kanumilli P., de Munck J., Peumans M., Lambrechts P., van Meerbeek B., Bond strength of a mild self-etch adhesive with and without prior acid-etching Journal of Dentistry 2006 34 1 77 85 (Pubitemid 41785718)
Brandt P. D., de Wet F. A., du Preez I. C., Self-etching bonding systems: in-vitro microleakage evaluation Journal of the Dental Association 2006 61 6 248 251
Asmussen E., Peutzfeldt A., Short- and long-term bonding efficacy of a self-etch adhesive systems Operative Dentistry 2007 32 73 78
Hosaka K., Tagami J., Nishitani Y., Yoshiyama M., Carrilho M., Tay F. R., Agee K. A., Pashley D. H., Effect of wet vs. dry testing on the mechanical properties of hydrophilic self-etching primer polymers. European Journal of Oral Sciences (2007) 115 (3) 239-245.