[en] Recent conversations concerning organic food systems have focused on the conventionalization hypothesis, which posits that the organic food sector has become increasingly bifurcated between “historical” players in the organic movement on one side, and on the other by distributors and industrial operators recently arrived in the sector, who practice a more conventionalized form of organic agriculture which is now on the ascendancy. The most prominent explanations for the growth and dominance of a conventionalized organic food system have been economic, based in the logics of input costs, especially land rent. We use the cases of the Belgian Blue commodity system and the Belgian organic beef commodity system to argue that conventionalization is also cognitive. To understand the role of cognition in the ascendance of the conventional organic food sector, we utilize concept of “référentiel”—or system of cognitive references—as developed by Muller and Jobert. We believe that comparing organic and conventional practices as two systems of cognitive references makes a deeper understanding of conventionalization possible in two ways: first because it makes it clear that the two systems coexist on a cognitive level, understood in a broad sense as tightly knit sets of knowledges, beliefs, standards, and images. Secondly, the concept of référentiel enables one to understand how the conventional system can become irreversible (lock-in effect) and thus incompatible with the development of the organic system.
Disciplines :
Sociologie & sciences sociales
Auteur, co-auteur :
Stassart, Pierre M ; Université de Liège - ULiège > Département des sciences et gestion de l'environnement > Département des sciences et gestion de l'environnement
Jamar, Daniel
Langue du document :
Anglais
Titre :
Steak up to the horns: Conventionalisation of Organic stock farming: knowledge's lock-in in the agrifood chain.
Titre traduit :
[fr] Du steak jusque dans les cornes: conventionalisation de l'élevage en agriculture biologique et verrouillage des connaissances dans les filières agro-alimentaires
Aertsens, J., & Van Huylenbroeck, G. (2007). Characteristics of the Belgium organic beef sector. In P. Stassart, M. Mormont, D. Jamar, D. Stilmant, J. Aerstens, & G. Van Huylenbroeck (Eds.), How can organic farming contribute to sustainable production and consumption patterns (pp. 15-21). Brussel: Belgian Science Policy.
Baret, P. (2005). Le Blanc Bleu Belge: Un paradoxe géné tique (p. 3). Louvain La Neuve.
Benford, R. D., & Snow, D. A. (2000). Framing process and social movements: An overview and assessment. Annual Review of Sociology, 26, 611-639.
H Best 2007 Organic agriculture and the conventionalization hypothesis: A case study from West Germany Agriculture and Human Values 25 1 95 106
D Bourn J Prescott 2002 Critical reviews Food Science and Nutrition 42 1 34
D Buck C Getz J Guthman 1997 From farm to table: The organic vegetable commodity chain of Northern California Sociologia Ruralis 37 1 3 20
M Callon 1986 Eléments pour une sociologie de la traduction. La domestication des coquilles Saint-Jacques et des marins-pêcheurs dans la baie de Saint-Brieuc L'Année sociologique 36 169 208
H Campbell R Liepins 2001 Naming organics: Understanding organic standards in New Zealand as a discursive field Sociologia Ruralis 41 1 21 39
Coopman, F., Van Zeveren, A., & Peelman, L. (2001). Ontstaangeschiedenis van het Belgisch Witblauw Rundvee en de rol van genetica in de verdere ontwikkeling van dit ras. Vlaams Diergeneesckundig Tijdschrift, 70, 88-103.
R Cowan P Gunby 1996 Sprayed to death: Path dependence, lock-in and pest control strategies Economic Journal 106 436 521 542
Darnhofer, I. (2006). Organic farming between professionalisation and conventionalisation. The need for more discerning view on farm practices. Odense: European Joint Organic Congress. http://orgprints.org/7390/. Accessed 24 June 2008.
de Bonneval, L. (1993). Systèmes agraires, systèmes de production: vocabulaire français-anglais avec index anglais. Paris: INRA Éditions.
Fouilleux, E. (2003). La politique agricole commune et ses réformes; une politique à l'épreuve de la globalisation. Paris: L'Harmattan.
Friedland, B. (2005). Commodity systems: Forward to comparative analysis. In N. Fold, & B. Pritchard (Eds.), Cross-continental food chains (pp. 25-34). London: Taylor & Francis Group.
Godard, O., & Hubert, B. (2002). Le développement durable et la Recherche Scientifique à L'INRA. Paris: INRA.
D Goodman EM DuPuis 2002 Knowing food and growing food: Beyond the production-consumption debate in the sociology of agriculture Sociologia Ruralis 42 1 5 22
Goodman, D., Sorj, B., & Wilkinson, J. (1987). From farming to biotechnology. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Grobet, L., Pirottin, D., Farnir, F., Poncelent, D., Royo, L. J., Brouwers, B., Christians, E., Desmecht, D., Coignoul, F., Kahn, R., & Georges, M. (2003). Modulating skeletal muscle mass by postnatal muscle-specific inactivation of the myostatin gene. Genesis, 35, 227-238.
J Guthman 2002 Commodified meanings, meaningful commodities: Re-thinking production-consumption links through the organic system of provision Sociologia Ruralis 42 4 295 311
J Guthman 2004 The trouble with 'organic lite' in California: A rejoinder to the conventionalisation Sociologia Ruralis 44 3 301 316
Guthman, J. (2004b). Agrarian dreams: The paradox of organic farming in California. Berkeley: University of California Press.
A Hall V Mogyorody 2001 Organic farmers in Ontario: An examination of the conventionalization argument Sociologia Ruralis 41 4 399 322
Hanset, R. (1996). Le Blanc-Bleu Belge face à la nouvelle donne économique. Les Elevages Belges, 3, 12-21.
Hanset, R. (2002). Le Blanc Bleu Belge et la Césarienne. Publication Herd-Book BBB, 3, 1-27.
Heclo, H. (1978). Issue networks and the executive establishment. In A. King (Ed.), The new American political system. Washington DC: American Entreprise Institute.
IFOAM (2005). The principles of organic agriculture. http://www.ifoam. org/about_ifoam/principles/index.html. Accessed 18 November 2007.
J Jaffe M Gertler 2006 Victual vicissitudes: Consumer deskilling and the (gendered) transformation of food systems Agriculture and Human Value 23 2 143 162
Jamar, D., Decruyvenaere, V., Stassart, P., & Stilmant, D. (2006). Reconversion to organic farming, between organic rules and agro-food chain referential: How to fit out the organic fattening referential? In C. B. Andreasen, L. Elsgaard, S. Søndergaard, & G. Hansen (Eds.), Proceeding of European Joint Organic Congress, Odense, May 30-31, Organic Eprint: http://www.orgprints.org.
Jobert, B., & Muller, P. (1987). L'état en action, politique publiques et corporatismes, Paris: PUF.
P Kaltoft 1999 Values about nature in organic farming "practice and knowledge" Sociologia Ruralis 39 1 39 53
E Landais 1996 Elevage bovin et développement durable Courier de l'environnement 29 59 72
Law, J. (1994). Organizing modernity. Oxford: B. Blackwell.
Lips, D., De Tavernier, J., Decuypere, E., & Van Outryve, J. (2001). Ethical objections to cesareans: Implication on the future of the Belgian White Blue. In M. Pasquali (Ed.), EurSafe 2001, food safety, food quality, food ethics (pp. 291-294). The Third Congress of the European Society for Agricultural and Food Ethics, 3-5 October, Florence, Italy, Preprints.
S Lockie D Halpin 2005 The 'Conventionalisation' thesis reconsidered: Structural and ideological transformation of Australian organic agriculture Sociologia Ruralis 45 4 284 307
Lockie, S., Lyons, K., & Lawrence, G. (2000). Constructing green foods: Corporate capital, risk, organic farming in Australia and New Zealand. Agriculture and Human Values, 17, 315-322.
Majone, G. (1989). Evidence, argument and persuasion in the policy process. New Haven: Yale University Press.
N McMahon 2005 Biodynamic farmers in Ireland. Transforming society through purity, solitude and bearing witness? Sociologia Ruralis 45 1-2 98 114
Micoud, A. (2003). Ces bonnes vaches aux yeux si doux. In F. Dubost, & B. Lizet (Eds.), Bienfaisante nature (pp. 217-236). Paris: Le Seuil.
PH Mooney SA Hunt 1996 A Repertoire Of Interpretations: Master frames and ideological continuity in U.S. Agrarian mobilization The Sociological Quarterly 37 1 177 197
K Morgan J Murdoch 2000 Organic vs. conventional agriculture: Knowledge, power and innovation in the food chain Geoforum 31 2 159 173
Muller, P. (1989). Airbus, l'ambition européenne. Logique d'Etat, logique de marché. Paris: L'Harmattan.
Muller, P. (1995). Les politiques publiques comme construction d'un rapport au monde. In A. Faure, G. Pollet, & P. Warin (Eds.), La construction du sens dans les politiques publiques. Débat autour de la notion de référentiel (pp. 153-179). Paris: L'Harmattan.
P Muller 2000 L'analyse cognitive des politiques publiques: Vers une sociologie politique de l'action publique Revue Française de Sciences Politique 2 50 189 209
T Mutersbaugh 2005 Fighting standards with standards: Harmonization and social accountability in certified Agrofood networks Environment and Planning A 37 11 2033 2051
J Riedler C Braun-Fahrländer W Eder M Schreuer M Waser S Maisch 2001 Exposure to farming in early life and development of asthma and allergy: A cross-sectional survey The Lancet 358 1129 1133
Ruttan, V. W. (1997). Induced innovation, evolutionary theory and path dependence: Sources of technical change. The Economic Journal, 107, 1520-1529.
Sabatier, P. A., & Jenkins-Smith, H. (1993). Policy change and learning and advocacy coalition approach. Boulder: Westview Press.
Smit, A., Driessen, P. P. J., & Glasbergen, P. (2006). Constraints on the conversion to sustainable production: The case of the Dutch potato chain. Business Strategy and the Environment. http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi- bin/abstract/112773392/ABSTRACT?CRETRY=1&SRETRY=0. Accessed 17 November 2007.
Sonnet, R. (1982). Analytical study on retail cuts form the double muscled animal. In J. W. B. King & F. Ménissier (Eds.), Muscle hypertrophy of genetic origin and its use to improve beef production (pp. 565-574). The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff
Stass, S. (2007). «Tant que Piétrains et sélectionneur collaborent». Departement of Environmental Sciences and Management. Arlon, Université de Liège. DEA Environmental Sciences and Management, 152 p.
Stassart, P. (2003). Produit Fermier: Entre qualification et identité. Brussels: Presses Interuniversitaires Européennes Peter Lang.
Stassart, P. (2005). Construction d'un marché alternatif de viande bovine fermière. Economie Rurale (286-287), 28-43.
Stassart, P., & Jamar, D. (forthcoming). Conventional dynamics: Missing protocol and legitimacy systems, relationship between organic stock farmers and retailers in transition towards sustainability. Sociologia Ruralis.
Stassart, P., Mormont, M., & Jamar, D. (in press). Recherche Intervention pour une Transistion vers le Développement Durable. Economie Rurale, 308.
Stassart, P., Mormont, M., Jamar, D., Stilmant, D., Aerstens, J., & Van Huylenbroeock, G. (2007). How can organic farming contribute to sustainable production and consumption patterns (p. 182). Brussel: Belgian Science Policy.
P Stassart S Whatmore 2003 Metabolizing risk: Food scares and the un/re-making of Belgian beef Environment and Planning A 35 3 449 462
H Tovey 1997 Food, environmentalism and rural sociology: On the organic farming movement in Ireland Sociologia Ruralis 37 1 21 37
Thrift, N. (2003). Qualification de l'origine des viandes bovines selon les manières de produire. Dissertation in Zootechnic Sciences, Departement Animal Sciences. INAP-G, Paris, 442 p.
Van der Aa, W. (1992). Manuel du boucher charcutier. Deurne: MIM.
T Vos 2000 Visions of the middle landscape: Organic farming and the politics of nature Agriculture and Human Values 17 3 245 256
Whatmore, S., & Thorne, L. (1997). Nourishing networks: Alternative geographies of food. In D. Goodman and M. Watts (Eds.), Globalising food (pp. 287-304). London: Routledge.
J Wilkinson 2006 Fish: A global value chain driven onto the rocks Sociologia Ruralis 46 2 139 153
